Web posted August 31, 2006

Fractured family illuminated in 'Sunshine'
Dissonant clan crosses country, attempts to pull itself together in comedy

By CARRIE RICKEY
The Philadelphia Inquirer

Courtesy of FOX Searchlight
  Along for the ride: "Little Miss Sunshine" tells the story of a disassociated family attempting to pull itself together.
Family. Can't live with 'em; can't kill 'em. "Little Miss Sunshine," a stormy quasi-comedy destined to polarize audiences, is a perfect specimen of this unsentimental attitude.

The Hoovers, three generations of individualists stubbornly resisting blending as a family, have melodrama enough for a season of "Days of Our Lives."

Among their number is a geriatric drug addict, an attempted suicide, and a radiantly ordinary child pageant contestant. Add to these a high-on-life optimist, a teenage nihilist, and a mom as the glue who wants this fractured clan to stick together in the pursuit of an elusive American dream.

The Hoovers don't yet know it, but from the opening scene of the tragedy-tinged farce, they will redefine failure and success in winning-is-everything America.

In this quirkathon written by Michael Arndt, the assortment of New Mexico depressives, unmotivated self-medicators, motivational speakers, and pageant aspirants board a mellow-yellow VW van with a malfunctioning clutch. Their destination is the Little Miss Sunshine pageant in California. Their mission, should they choose to accept it, is to support one another.

From the opening scenes, when all six gather around the dinner table for a bucket of chicken, it is clear that screenwriter Arndt has composed these exaggerated characters as dissonant temperaments fated to harmonize. This is the scene, despite a plot that strictly adheres to Murphy's Law. And primary-color compositions of the American Southwest reminiscent of a Road Runner cartoon.

To the extent that "Little Miss Sunshine" works, and you probably gather that its schematic cartoonishness didn't always work for me, it is because directors Jonathan Dayton and Valerie Faris genuinely like these people.

So do the actors, especially Alan Arkin as Grandpa, Toni Collette as Mom, Steve Carell as the attempted suicide, and Abigail Breslin as the pint-size pageant contestant, who fully inhabit their characters. Like Frances McDormand, Collette is an actress of such bedrock believability that every time the movie goes over the top, she grounds it with her clear-eyed realism.

Less effective - a problem more of script than of acting - is Greg Kinnear's Richard Hoover, the desperately hopeful creator of a nine-step program called "Refuse to Lose." The screenwriter and directors telegraph their disapproval of anyone who claims to hold the key to success. In so doing, they undermine this character - but not the movie.

Careworn on the Carefree Highway, the Hoovers grind toward California for the date with Olive's destiny.

In a field of blondes who resemble miniature Vegas showgirls, can a pudgy, bespectacled brunette who looks like your average third grader take the crown?

That's the wrong question to ask of a movie that advocates it's not the destination but the journey that's important.

Print This
E-Mail This
Send editor a comment
[an error occurred while processing this directive]