A judge Friday agreed to the scheduling of a competency evaluation for the man accused of shooting two Hoonah police officers to death last August.
Judge David George appeared by telephone in Juneau Superior Court and agreed to set a date for a mental health evaluation for John N. Marvin Jr. at the request of his counsel, Eric Hedland, and with no opposition by State Assistant District Attorney Amy Williams.
The date, however, will not be set until Hedland’s expert witness finishes an evaluation report and sends it to Hedland, who in turn then allows District Attorney Dave Brower to examine it.
According to Hedland that report was not to have been in his possession until Aug. 31. George requested that it be finished before Aug. 29 and will set a scheduling hearing for Marvin’s competency to stand trial after he hears back from Hedland by Aug. 17.
George would like a competency hearing before Sept. 6.
George also ruled against Hedland’s opposition to the introduction of certain evidence from the State and an assertion by Hedland that the defense was properly silent in the face of the state’s motion.
“You know I really disagree with that Mr. Hedland,” George said. “For a number of reasons.”
Among George’s reasons was that although it is true the State has to give advanced warning of evidence admitted, under case law the court, after giving opportunity for response, is simply to consider it properly out of presence of the jury to determine relevance and then to balance the effect of that. There is no requirement that it be done at a hearing; it could be done in a written document.
“But in any event if the defense felt as though hearing was necessary in response to the motion filed it could request an oral argument or an evidentiary hearing,” George said.
A notice of affirmative defense by insanity has been listed on court dockets.
George asked if Hedland had anything else to discuss.
“There are things I could say but I won’t,” Hedland said.
Replied George, “Probably a good idea.”
A tentative 21-day trial date has been set to begin Oct. 13, before Judge George in Juneau.
Marvin is accused of an ambush-style fatal shooting of Sgt. Anthony Wallace, 32, and Officer Matthew Tokuoka, 39, of the Hoonah Police Department as the two officers spoke together on the street in front of Marvin’s Hoonah residence. Family members of the two were present at the time of the shooting.
Marvin barricaded himself inside his residence in a standoff with law enforcement officials before surrendering on Aug. 30, roughly 36 hours after the shooting.
Marvin has pleaded not guilty and faces two charges of first-degree murder and two charges of weapons misconduct.
If convicted, Marvin faces a sentence of 99 years on each murder count if it is determined Wallace and Tokuoka were “uniformed or otherwise clearly identified peace officer(s),” according to Alaska law. He could face five years in prison for each of the weapons misconduct charges.
During National Police Week in May, retired HPD chief John Milan accompanied two memorial photos of Wallace and Tokuoka to the national memorial ceremony in Washington, D.C. The names of Wallace and Tokuoka were then engraved on the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial wall.
The village of Hoonah has declared Aug. 28 as Matt And Tony Day.
• Contact reporter Klas Stolpe at 523-2263 or at klas.stolpe@juneauempire.com.





Comments (16)
Add commentIF convicted? IF Convicted??? WTF???
Use his ass for target practice and be done with this low life scumbag and save us hard working, law abiding tax paying citizens our money for more important things. He's a cop killer with a lengthy police record and known by lots of people in Hoonah as TROUBLE!!!
IF CONVICTED?
THAT'S RIGHT, LETS KILL EVERYONE IN THESE TYPE OF CASES. WHY HAVE JUSTICE, WE DON'T NEED IT.
IF CONVICTED
WHAT IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN JUSTICE? IF WE DON'T HAVE JUSTICE, THIS TYPE OF BEHAVIOR WILL JUST BE THE NORM FOR EVERYONE.
JUSTICE, SERIOUSLY? YOU'RE ASKING FOR JUSTICE
FOR THIS COP KILLER? Where was the justice for the cops? Oh, yeah, that's right, THEY don't count, only those that kill cops matter to you. How about the families he destroyed? Oh, that doesn't matter either does it? Those children are going to grow up without their dad because that piece of scum murdered them. He doesn't deserve justice.
Yes Justice
Oh made you GOD? Your way off base with what I meant. You have to have a clear and opened mind to see the whole picture of the laws of the land. Your first statement sounded like you didn't believe in justice for anyone. Remember what GOD says, we who judge will be judged 10 time more when we face our maker.
GOD NEVER said that, MAN said that in a book called
the Bible. This book was written by MAN, not GOD. Get YOUR facts straight. If more people worried more about how they are going to face themselves everyday instead of a "maker" maybe they wouldn't commit horrible crimes against other people. You are right on only one point and that is that I do not believe in justice for any person that maliciously or cowardly takes the life of another person. This "man" barricaded himself and shot and killed those two police officers in a malicious and cowardly act and doesn't deserve justice.
WTH
he killed 2 policeman, they didnt have a chance with this trash monger.. his history says it all.. toss the key and let him rot, no special treatment, no time served off, no special gourmet meals at the grey bar hotel.. too bad we dont have the eye for an eye law here.. let the officers family be the judge and jury...
KARMA will kick you in the arse 10 fold...
What a waste of our money....
to have to do all this legal maneuvering in a case where guilt is obvious. If he is so crazy he didn't know right from wrong then send him to the loony bin. If he did just lock him up and let's not give the lawyers anymore money - please!
Justice is one thing, but wasting our money is another. In cases like this I think we can just bypass all the BS and have an expedited trial!
@averagejoe: but then the
@averagejoe: but then the argument could be made for expediting other trials that maybe aren't so obvious (though they may seem to be). The law applies to everyone, and everyone is guaranteed a fair trial (and the fact that this doesn't always happen just shows we should be working to IMPROVE the legal system, not create more loopholes).
For everyone advocating fire and brimstone, I'd advise you to read "In Cold Blood." It's easy to react to a situation with your gut impulse, which is usually some violent caveman fantasy, but it would sure suck if the legal system also subscribed to that fantasy.
It seems to me that, out of
It seems to me that, out of respect for the two men who lost their lives upholding the law, we ought not forget its place and purpose. To give in to our rage and bloodlust, even in such trying circumstances, sets a dangerous precedent. Show this man that, even in the face of such ugly, senseless violence, we are still a civilized people.
You are right Persnikety
We should improve the legal system - that's what I'm talking about. In cases where there is no other possible perp, several eye witnesses, and irrefutable physical evidence, we should have a way to speed up the process so as to not waste everyone's time and money - tell me that doesn't make sense.
@averagejoe: it does make
@averagejoe: it does make sense, sure, but then you have to determine where to draw the line. You have to be super exact in your wording when it comes to the legal system, and I do think many people would have different takes on what is irrefutable evidence.
Also, trials serve other purposes besides determining guilt, like sentencing. I'll be very surprised if this guy pleads not guilty.
Wow -- all the comments about this...
I am Matt's oldests sister -- every now and then I check in on this subject, I dont like to know too much -- I still am going through many different emotions but reading each and everyone of your posts made my emotions go in many directions...one in particular "afishisborn" - thank you, it brought me back to a place I want to stay in my emotions. All of you are right, though. I am not only Matt's sister and have normal emotions of a person who just lost her little brother, but I am a paralegal and I am stuck fighting both thoughts in this legal matter. It sucks -- how does a person think rationally in any of this right? It is so hard to make any sense of it all -- but, for what its worth, I wanted to thank all of you for all your passion, compassion, thoughts, words, etc. And thank you all for taking the time to state your thoughts. It means alot in many ways.
October 13th will be the beginning of more pain for everyone but I know at the end of trial my heart will rest. I have to let it. Please dont ask me what I think about the defendant -- I don't think about him -- I just think about my brother and Tony and the lives they touched.
Mahalo!
Aloha malama pono!
To MolokaiGrl - My thoughts, love and prayers go out to you
and your family and to the family of Sgt. Anthony Wallace.
Marvin is the "poster child" for reinstating the death penalty...Nationwide!
Thank you IceQueen
I was a juror on a murder trial in March of 2011, after Matt's death, and I tell you what -- even though the Defendant was convicted of murder, I was thankful that the death penalty was not an option for us as jurors to have to give. I totally forgot about being a juror until you brought it up - but damn, I do not want to be on the jury panel in this trial. Although I am pretty sure they will do a great job -- it still is a hard thing to do.
Thanks again IceQueen.
Thank you IceQueen
I was a juror on a murder trial in March of 2011, after Matt's death, and I tell you what -- even though the Defendant was convicted of murder, I was thankful that the death penalty was not an option for us as jurors to have to give. I totally forgot about being a juror until you brought it up - but damn, I do not want to be on the jury panel in this trial. Although I am pretty sure they will do a great job -- it still is a hard thing to do.
Thanks again IceQueen.