The Alaska Department of Fish and Game euthanized an adult male black bear that was captured while searching for food in downtown Juneau Wednesday afternoon.
Ryan Scott, the area management biologist for Fish and Game, said in a phone interview that the bear was put down shortly after it was tranquilized when they realized it was the same bear that was captured and relocated a little more than two months ago.
The bear, estimated to be about 6 to 8 years old, was originally captured on Behrends Avenue, a residential neighborhood about a mile and a half away from the downtown area, on July 7 after Fish and Game had receiving multiple complaints that it was getting into garbage, a bird feeder and someone’s dog food.
“It was one of those cases where the bear had become very habituated to that Behrends Avenue neighborhood,” Scott said.
Fish and Game had tried to capture the bear twice at that time, and caught it on the third attempt. It was tranquilized, tagged and relocated to an undisclosed place.
“We were able to dart it, and we ear-tagged it so we’d be able to identify it, we moved it, and lo and behold, it showed back up,” Scott said.
Scott said it was relocated somewhere in the wild, north of Juneau. He would not give an exact location since he doesn’t want people to search for the relocated bears.
Scott said he was surprised the bear, which weighed an estimated 250 pounds, came back to Juneau as quickly as it did, especially since the intent of relocation is to put a bear in a place where it’s difficult to return home, and to give it time to alter its conditioned behaviors.
“Over the years we’ve seen bears come back, (but) it often takes a long time,” Scott said. “It’s not overly surprising to have them come back, but I thought he was good candidate — put him out, put him in a place where there’s plenty of natural food, and things like that. But apparently that bear was focused was trying to get back to where it was from and where it knew the area, and its home range and, essentially, where it was comfortable.”
Fish and Game once again began fielding near daily complaints about the bear beginning two weeks ago, Scott said.
Last Friday, they received reports it was near the State Office Building parking lot, and then that same night, in the Foodland IGA parking lot. Police ended up chasing it off by firing off bean bag rounds, upon Fish and Game’s request not to shoot it. It was night time and officials were unprepared for a capture, so they asked police to push the bear near the Juneau Federal Building toward Cope Park, Scott said.
The bear was also seen last week on the rooftop of the Senate Mall building on Franklin Street, which was evidenced by Facebook photographs that began appearing online. It was last reported seen by police on Front Street on Monday in a garbage can, Scott said.
On Wednesday, the bear re-appeared downtown, attracting a crowd as it climbed up stairs and onto a rooftop landing between Franklin Street and Shattuck Way behind City Hall.
Police officers, both on-duty and off-duty, and Animal Control responded to the scene to help, and they shut down vehicular traffic during the lunch hour. Police tape was placed on scene to set up a perimeter to keep both tourists and locals at bay, as they snapped pictures and crowded around to watch authorities dart the bear, carry it down the stairs on a blue litter and into a truck that drove away.
An unknown person on the landing was seen videographing the entire incident. Kathy Dye, the director of media and publications for the Sealaska Heritage Institute, which has offices nearby, also videotaped the bear in action as it gracefully balanced walking on a thin wood railing and sniffed around the concrete rooftop “backyards.”
Scott, who was on scene alongside Doug Larsen, the Fish and Game Regional Supervisor for the Southeast, believes the bear got to the landing by walking up some stairs and using a chain-link fence for leverage.
“There was a landing there, so it was able to walk up the steps to a certain point,” Scott said. “Bears are amazing climbers, and my understanding is it used a small section of a chain-link fence to climb up onto the next roof portion.”
Once there, responding police officers tried to keep it in one spot until Scott and Larsen arrived on scene. By the time Scott got there, the bear was docile and laying down atop the landing, he said. He said he did not receive any reports of the bear acting aggressive towards people.
Scott said the ear tag identified the bear as being the same one seen at the State Office Building and Foodland IGA parking lots. He added it also exhibited similar behavior that was seen on Behrends Avenue.
“It’s unfortunate really ‘cause the bear was able to get into garbage,” he said. “... The bear has become habituated to people — obviously, it’s very comfortable around people, and it’s also food conditioned.”
The bear was euthanized by gun shot, and its body is being stored in a Fish and Game freezer. It was not immediately known what will happen to its remains.
Several factors are weighed when deciding to euthanize a bear, Scott says. A bear will be euthanized immediately, he said, if it acts aggressively towards people or if it makes contact with a person.
“There are no second chances with that really,” Scott said.
But in this case, the bear’s history is what influenced the decision, Scott said.
“It’s not just one thing,” he said. “... This isn’t a case where it’s one single event that I determined how to proceed with a particular animal. First, it was into all kinds of stuff in July, we provided the opportunity for it to live out in the wild and go that route, and it made its way back, and it’s been generating calls for about two weeks now.”
Scott added the decision to euthanize a bear is not one that he takes lightly.
“I guess I’m hoping people won’t get upset if they understand that we had handled this bear once before, we had provided the opportunity for it do go on and do natural things,” Scott said. “Nobody likes killing bears, including Fish and Game staff. So while we don’t like it, it is at times a necessary thing in our opinion, and this particular bear based on the history was one that I determined we should do that with.”
Two to three bears are euthanized in Juneau every year, he said. The last one that was euthanized was just 30 days ago. In that case, it was again a large adult male bear that frequented roughly the same area downtown and exhibited similar behaviors.
Juneau sees a lot of bear activity this time of year as bears prepare for hibernation. Scott says this bear was not a so-called “problem bear,” rather he was just doing what bears do.
“These bears are doing exactly what they’re programed for, and they will exploit a food source if they find it,” he said. “Lots of people use the term ‘problem bear,’ but so much, so often it’s really not necessarily a bear problem — it’s an attracting problem that we need to work on.”
He added, “We don’t want to lose sight of like it or not we live in a place where there’s lots of black bears, and bears and people I think can coexist pretty well. But we got to keep those (food) attractants out of there that way we don’t create bear problems.”
• Contact reporter Emily Russo Miller at 523-2263 or at emily.miller@juneauempire.com.






Comments (38)
Add commentSee the guy in the green tshirt?
In the first photo? He was a bigger pest than the poor bear. He kept chasing people out of the Emporium Mall (Heritage Coffee) building like he owned the place, then climbed out on the deck with a video camera and ignored the police and game warden ordering him off the roof as he was stressing the bear out.
The bear was in the Sealaska parking lot when tourists began crowding in for photos. The bear was trying to escape and got himself cornered in that alley next to Miner Mercantile. I thought the police and the game warden did an excellent job of clearing the area, both for their safety and to minimize stress to the bear.
I just heard the news the bear had to be killed due to previous activity downtown and having been tagged. It's a shame. He'd lost his fear of humans and we all know how that happens. People who are too lazy to secure their trash or thinking that feeding the bear is a kindness sentence them to certain death just for being a bear.
Ryan scott for mayor
First time i have seen common sense in this town in a long time.
Common sense - W Bear - L
Kill em all.
Oh, my...
Poor little guy. Sorry to hear that, but sometimes choices have to be made.
Sure seems to me like this
Sure seems to me like this guy deserved another chance especially considering he wasn’t even aggressive.
If he came back then he wasn't taken far enough away.
This is truly sad.
Choices?? hunh?
Look at it from the government's point of view...
It's cheaper to kill the poor bear then to relocate it and when you work with/for the government, it's ALWAYS about the money!! That's the deciding factor. What will it cost? Doesn't matter who gets hurt, who gets killed, just what will it cost? That bear should NOT have been killed, after all, like Scott said he was just doing what bears do. And unfortunately for the bear, Scott was just doing what he is paid to do and in the most cost effective way.
Choices...
Absolutely... It's all about choices. Can you imagine what a jury of your neighbors would have done had this animal hurt someone? Juneau might as well right a blank check and the media and these comments would have castigated them for NOT making this decision earlier. Schools, roads... everything would have suffered. Once the jury is told that Juneau had TWO opportunities to remove a known problem bear and neglected to do so, the giant sucking sound is that of money being sucked out of of OUR pockets. There is no way Juneau could win that case.
It's sad. And I take no pleasure from saying so, but they made the correct decision.
Euthanasia?
Procedures like these, carried out in the interest of public safety, are not acts of euthanasia.
A euthanasia is a kind death, a good death, a beautiful act of compassion upheld in civilized societies whose primary goal is to relieve suffering while keeping the individual's needs prioritized.
Sadly, this article tries to redefine euthanasia as a punishment, a penalty. It isn't.
May I suggest that for any future articles, please consider more appropriate words to describe acts that prioritize society rather than the individual such as: put down, dispatched, humanely killed, etc.
Mike
Yep
Next time! Love those words. Lets hope. Empire please call it what it is mans dominance exterminating an un-needed predator from our community.
Great picture of the dead bruin. People should be exposed more often to the circle of life. Let's take out a dozen or so more as we have too many in town.
Garbage, bird seed, dog food...
That's what killed this bear.
Not a problem bear, its a
Not a problem bear, its a people problem. Start fining people who don't take care of their garbage. Dont leave the dogfood outside. you live in bear country. And concerned, the picture is of a tranquilized bear. I can guarantee they didnt blast him in downtown in front of the tourists...
Who gets the sausage?
I hope the meat was salvaged and given to the Glory Hole.
euthanasia
Merriam-Webster's Definition of EUTHANASIA: the act or practice of killing or permitting the death of hopelessly sick or injured individuals (as persons or domestic animals) in a relatively painless way for reasons of mercy
Poor headline choice of words; better/accurate choices are:
put down... kill... shoot...terminate.
Sad but necessary decision by F&G to kill this bear. People are responsible for this bear's death, by creating its habituation.
I agree with other posters...$$$ fines for the folks who leave bird seed, dog food, garbage, etc. accessible to these animals.
Resources
Hi readers,
There's many resources for how to avoid this situation in the future. Please take note of the links provided above to the City and Borough of Juneau and to the Alaska Department of Fish and Game. They provide, in my opinion, some good tips on living in bear country.
Dead bears
I lived in Juneau in the 80's, 82 thru 89, and I
don't remember ever having a problem with
black bears back then. We used to watch them
from the 7th floor of the federal building feeding
on hillside above town, but rarely if ever was
there and issue with bears actually coming into
town. So why all the problems now? Maybe
it's because there are just too damn many of
them for the local ecosystem to hold.
I don't think killing a few is going to hurt the
local population one little bit.
I might suggest next time they relocate black
bears they take them one of the ABC islands.
That way the brown bears over there can have
another source of protein.
@ bjfluetsch
that's actually a good idea ... seriously. although I cant imagine the meat would be very tasty given its steady diet of garbage and dirty street water. my father hit a dear when i was a kid, dnr (in MN) let us tag it, fed our family for months. sucks to kill animals sometimes.
bears have very powerful spiritual energy and in my opinion should be respected, like all of life, however a fed bear is a dead bear...
I am just lost for words over
I am just lost for words over this.
The what ifs! what if what if what if - argh!
Choices? whos choice? yours? bahhHHH! Are you a god? NOT!
What killed this bear was a bullet!!!!
The act of killing this bear , the photo - all a disgrace.
The bear should have been taken further away, period.
Seems to me that nearly every
Seems to me that nearly every bear that has been tagged and moved out of town has managed to find its way back. Most of our "urban" bears aren't much of a problem. We've got them wandering all over the place in the valley and Douglas but there are rarely problems because locals generally leave them alone. But add 15,000 visitors with cameras to the mix and you've got a recipe for disaster. Unless there's a zoo or something willing to take these bears when they are captured, it seems a waste of resources to move them over and over again. The biggest "what if" will happen when one of these bears lays a smackdown on somebody in town. Once they become habituated the way this bear was, they just need to be put down. My only problem with the way this bear was handled had more to do with the shot that was taken with the tranq dart. Talk about aiming small.
Lets see some reporting on
Lets see some reporting on our changing climate, oh I forgot the empire is owned by Rupert Murdoch of Fox News which is all about sick entertainment!
The video is totally inappropriate.
reality to hard to deal with c&m?
What is wrong with the video? It shows exactly what was going on. Pat Race has a longer video of the bear on other news channels, a bit longer but enjoyable.
I’ll give the bear a 10 for
I’ll give the bear a 10 for the balance beam performance.
@ladydulcinea I probably
@ladydulcinea
I probably shouldn't get bent out of shape over snippy comments in the newspaper but I think the "guy in the green shirt" is me and I feel like I'm being mischaracterized.
This all happened in our back alley and before the police arrived I was telling people they probably shouldn't back the bear into a corner. I don't think I was being abrasive about it but the alley is a dead end and I was worried that the bear might not have any other way out except through the gawkers.
When the police arrived I began filming and was careful to stay out of their way and out of the way of the bear. I shot footage from my apartment, the yoga studio and a separate rooftop.
The police were aware that I was filming and you can hear me talking to the officer several times throughout the video footage.
I did hear an uproar from the crowd at the police line when a couple of us went out on the roof above our office but it was just noise from up there and I assumed people were concerned we were on the same roof as the bear. We were not, that roof is separated by the alley way and knowing we were safely out of the way I continued to film.
I know my way around the building and I wasn't anxious to pester the bear or get in the way of the police or game officers. The officer on the scene was aware that I was filming and I even saved him the trouble of climbing a fence by letting him out onto the roof through my apartment.
I understand that darting and killing the bear was an emotional event and I apologize if I was brusque with you.
Thanks Pat! A great filming
Thanks Pat! A great filming job!
@catandmouse
We are not owned by Fox News.
Sick
The tourist are just about gone time to kill the bears.
This is just sick! The bear was killed for avoiding people! The bears are regulars on Franklin and gold street and the bear proof cans don't work I have watched them knock them over and bounce on them till the lid pops open. They are also into business trash! The 5 to 20 thousand tourist a day are creating. It is time to institute a wildlife relocation tax at 5 dollars a head that should pay for the wild life to be relocated farther away than the end of the road. That or put signs downtown telling tourist how they are helping to kill the wildlife they came to see and give them photos of the dead bears. If the bear was aggressive towards people it would be different but it was not, it was avoiding them to the point when trapped it didn't charge.
Bears travel. I have heard
Bears travel. I have heard stories of relocated bears practically beating the fish and game guys back to town. Want to keep them from killing bears? Clean up after yourself and keep garbage, pet food, whatever away from bears. I have lived here for decades and have never had a bear problem on my property.Had problems with bears eating my neighbors garbage, but I have had no issues. Its really not that hard...
kpawsuh -
Hit the nail on the head. Hear, Hear!
Kpawsuh
Agreed in full, it really isn't rocket science!
@Patrace
Pat,
You took some excellent video of the situation and I agree, there was a lot of excitement going on at the time. Perception of events is tied directly to location and timing. You did not insult me in the Emporium, but others were complaining you had run them off.
The warden and the police out on the street were more than a little upset that you and the two women were so close to the bear out on that deck. They had no idea which direction the bear would take or that the dart would do it's job and the concern was for your safety.
As for the bear, it was a shame he had to be put down. He did not appear to be angry or aggressive. I do not think the warden took any pleasure from the decision he had to make. He advised us to look away - "that it wouldn't be pleasant" - as he was filling syringes for the injections given after the darting.
Anyone with an ounce of compassion for creatures would be sad at the outcome.
Euthanized???
It was shot, not euthanized. Fish and Game definitely took the easy way out. It was already knocked out, spend the $5.00 bucks in gas and drive it out the road and drop it off. If it came back a second time then put it down. Giving it one chance was lame. Especially since it was not acting aggressive.
Just watched the video
That bear didn't show any aggression what so ever! Even being cornered. They could have taken him out to the end of the road, not Thane but way past Eagle Beach and let him go. They did not have to kill it. He was a beautiful, healthy bear and didn't deserve to be killed (I agree, he was NOT euthanized). So what if he was tagged and he returned? He didn't commit any crime except he dared to walk around town; didn't harm anyone, attack anyone, act aggressive, nothing!