• Broken clouds
  • 63°
    Broken clouds
  • Comment

19 months and counting on Tongass National Forest exemption appeal

Posted: March 21, 2014 - 12:04am

The state of Alaska has been left to “sit and wait” for more than a year and a half by the federal court system, Alaska Assistant Attorney General Tom Lenhart said.

Lenhart gave an update on the Tongass National Forest’s exemption from the Roadless Area Conservation Rule to the Alaska Board of Forestry during its meeting Thursday. In 2011, the state “immediately” filed an appeal with the federal courts when they struck down the Tongass’ 2003 exemption from the Roadless Rule, reinstating restrictions imposed in 2001 on unroaded areas of the forest’s 17 million acres.

“It was atrocious, in my opinion,” Lenhart said during his presentation.

Lenhart said most appellants hear back from the courts within three to 12 months. Nineteen months have passed, he said, and the state has no word on the exemption appeal.

“All we can do is sit and wait,” Lenhart said.

Opponents of the rule say it blocks the state from millions of dollars of economic development in the country’s largest national forest. Proponents of the rule say the land and the animals that call it home need to be protected. The Tongass was exempt from the rule until 2011, when the Organized Village of Kake, the Southeast Alaska Conservation Council and other environmental organizations won a lawsuit.

Forestry board member Eric Nichols, of the Forest Industry Trade Association in Ketchikan, said Southeast Alaska’s economy is beginning to be “stifled” by the rule.

“There’s a lot of things that get put off until this thing comes into play,” Nichols said. “It’s starting to have an impact on Southeast.”

Lenhart replied that reinstating the Tongass exemption wouldn’t be a fix-all for the timber industry.

“Even if we win this, it’s no silver bullet for the industry,” he said. “That by itself doesn’t cut down a single more tree.”

Also at the board meeting, U.S. Forest Service Tongass Supervisor Forrest Cole gave an update on the new Tongass Plan Advisory Committee, which will amend the Tongass management plan to comply with the Roadless Rule.

Almost 80 people applied to be a part of the committee, Cole said. The Forest Service sent along 35 names to the U.S. secretary and undersecretary of agriculture, who will appoint 15 committee members and one alternate soon, he said. The committee will decide on a “proposed action” by May.

The goal of the group is to come up with a “narrowly focused amendment” that’s easy to implement into the current management plan, Cole said.

“If it was a complete revision of the forest plan there’s no way it could get done,” he said.

Cole said a draft of the amendment will be “on the street” in August 2015, when it will be up for feedback and edits. The new plan will be finalized in August 2016, he said.

“So far the stars are aligning in order to get the advisory committee set up and the amendment started,” he said.

• Contact reporter Katie Moritz at 523-2294 or at

  • Comment

Comments (8) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
Judy Hodel
Judy Hodel 03/25/14 - 03:29 pm
Dog Hair Forest

In Sitka there has been increasing consensus that old-growth timber should be left alone. This is due in large part to memories of when the Starrigavan Valley watershed, just outside of town, was clearcut in the 1960s.

Today, a secondary growth of red alder and salmonberry bushes grows in the valley -- locals refer to it as "dog-hair forest." The 2nd growth trees are spindly things a person cannot walk through. And there is no understory thus no wildlife.

The destruction is a continual reminder of how government subsidized out-of-state logging companies came to town, clearcut, and departed with only a moonscape veined with logging roads, and a few "leave-strips" of old-growth in their wake.

Samuel Joplin
Samuel Joplin 03/26/14 - 11:54 pm
Judy Judy judy

There needs to be a balanced approach. Cutting all the old growth timber is not balance. Making the entire national forest roadless is not balance. The roadless rule goes too far, much in the same way that clearcutting the entire Tongass would go too far. Oh.. If that Starrigavin area had been properly thinned to promote better growth of the stronger trees, it would have regenerated much faster. But oh no we can't cut any trees. Roadless rules unnecessarily lock up the forest and make it less accessible.

Kevin Nye
Kevin Nye 03/27/14 - 08:23 am
"These Aren't The Droids We Are Looking For"

"The timber industry has destroyed our planets natural carbon-storing environments: the forests and wetlands. Now we have excessive amounts of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere causing mega storms. These storms costs American taxpayer’s lives and billions of dollars."

Trent Morrison, your above comment reminds me of the Imperial Storm Troopers in the first Star Wars movie who recited (regurgitated) the LIE that was implanted into their heads by Obi Wan Kenobi via his use of The Force.

I am continually amazed at how you people have swallowed that whole hoax of a LIE about how "Man" has been powerful enough to create "Global Warming"-oh wait-"Climate Change" (you all had to change the terminology because obviously it is NOT getting "warmer") so that carbon taxes can be collected and so that more land can be locked up.

It has been an excellent Lie that has been propounded, and used to great effect. But it is still a Lie and I, and many of us will never grab on to it like a sucker fish onto a gob of nightcrawlers on a treble hook...

Back to Top


  • Switchboard: 907-586-3740
  • Circulation and Delivery: 907-586-3740
  • Newsroom Fax: 907-586-9097
  • Business Fax: 907-586-9097
  • Accounts Receivable: 907-523-2230
  • View the Staff Directory
  • or Send feedback