When visitors from around the world enjoy a cruise through Alaska’s Inside Passage, they are experiencing the Tongass National Forest as a scenic wonder.
I live in Sitka, and when I look at the Tongass, I see salmon because I’m a salmon fisherman, and the Tongass is first and foremost a salmon forest. It is one of nature’s great salmon-producing factories.
Though the Tongass has just 5 percent of Alaska’s land area, it produces almost 30 percent of the state’s wild salmon.
Add up all the commercial salmon fishing, all the sport fishing for salmon and trout, all the salmon that Alaskans take to feed their families, and you learn that the fish coming from the Tongass drive almost $1 billion of economic activity in Southeast Alaska’s economy every year.
The Tongass could produce even more salmon if vast areas of the old-growth forest had not been mowed down. Logging operations that supported two giant pulp mills chewed up streams, caused erosion, and spoiled miles and miles of good fish habitat.
I’m familiar with places on Prince of Wales Island that have been so hammered for so long, local coho runs are finding it difficult to survive. We used to have really good fisheries in places like Clarence Strait, Sumner Strait, and Point Baker. Those areas have been really hurt by clear cutting huge areas of old-growth forest.
These days, the Forest Service says it recognizes the need to change the way it manages the Tongass. It will move away from old growth logging, and try to shift logging into second-growth areas. As that shift takes place, the agency wants to maintain jobs by doing a lot of work to repair past damage inflicted by old-style logging.
That kind of talk is good news, but the Forest Service is still pushing big timber sales in old-growth forest. The agency spends millions and millions of dollars every year preparing timber sales nobody buys. These days, the good timber that’s left is too remote and too expensive to cut and still make a profit in the face of cheap competition around the world.
Still, I’m encouraged to see a growing number of restoration projects — like the public-private partnership that will restore the Sitkoh River this season. There’s plenty of that work to be done throughout the Tongass.
Culverts that block fish passage need to be fixed or removed. Old logging roads that cause erosion need to be closed and replanted. Workers can thin dense undergrowth along streams, to improve habitat. And contractors can be hired to put some downed trees back in those streams, to break up the flow of water that fish, especially coho, need to survive.
Today’s modest timber industry can survive too. The Forest Service should put its timber money into accelerating the shift to second-growth wood production. Second growth is smaller, but it can be a good source of dimensional lumber.
When we talk about the old growth forests of the Tongass, though, the real economic future is not logging, it’s salmon. When you are cutting down old growth, you withdraw capital from the bank — and you’re not earning interest any more. Leaving the forest standing pays steady dividends — every year, salmon return to the forested streams and rivers throughout the Tongass.
The West Chichagof-Yakobi wilderness area near Sitka, for example, produces an awful lot of my annual income. To me, that wilderness is not a playground for adventure travelers, it is a breadbasket that helps feed my family.
I commend the Forest Service for pursuing more and more restoration projects. They’re on the right track doing more thinning of second-growth areas. I just wish the agency would give up on trying to resurrect the old industrial-scale timber industry by offering big sales of old-growth. Protecting the old-growth in the Tongass is a sound investment in the future of one of the region’s biggest industries, salmon.
• Severson is a salmon troller who lives in Sitka.





Comments (21)
Add commentGood piece - good reason for TU to stop selling out
If AK Trout Unlimited quit pimping Sealaska clearcuts by attaching their stuff to pipe dream projects they might at least get on the right planet.
I think Martin already
I think Martin already qualified the bill is of no threat to salmon. Ill take the word of a Ph D over a fisherman any day.
http://juneauempire.com/opinion/2011-06-12/sealaska-land-bill-won8217t-h...
That's the trouble .....
ravenhose ......... you're all wrapped up in idolizing any "authority figure" You'll never be able to see the facts in a clear light as long as you lick Sealaska's boots.
your a vulgar,
your a vulgar, disgusting,pitiful, fool. Just shut up... plain and simple: SHUT up
Excellent piece by Spencer Severson.
This is exactly why Sealaska isn't able to argue againt the fisherman's point of view. Clear cut logging is a LOSS to salmon, and the loss of salmon is a loss for the forest, as well as fishermen.
ravenhose....
"sticks and stones ......."
it is you're, not your!
it is you're, not your!
it is you're, not your!
There's a handful of Sealaska boot lickers these days. Does it pay good? Being a shareholder certainly doesn't.
I would hope a shareholder
@ Good: I would hope a shareholder made more at there job than their dividend. ANCSA wasnt meant to provide its shareholders with a lifestyle; it was made to create opportunities where at a point, shareholders would have to work to earn them and take advantage of them. The resources and opportunities are there- its up to shareholders to use them.
@ Zerocut: Boot licking? yeah You can paint it however you like but your just a foolish hater whose opinion is of no value and the less people hear you the louder you rant. This forum is nothing more to you than a bathroom stall for your disgusting scrawling.
I take you for nothing more than an unemployed, drunk zero- your offensive abuses of this forum are of no value to anyone but yourself to give your meaningless life a sense of disturbed purpose.
This is my last post to you and from here on out your worthless arguments will be ignored.
ravenhose .....
..... you're right, I am unemployed (I'm retired) and I'm a "drunk" (recovering alcoholic since 1980). A least I opened my eyes to the error of my ways, and changed. I hope you can do the same.
ravenhose .....
BTW... you really demonstrated your sensitivity and compassion for the troubles of others, by your use of the term "drunk".
Overfishing vs Clearcutting
"We used to have really good fisheries in places like Clarence Strait, Sumner Strait, and Point Baker. Those areas have been really hurt by clear cutting huge areas of old-growth forest."
During the 1979 -1983 seasons, Clarence and Sumner looked like a Lake Havasu party with the amount of boats out there fishing.
It is more likely that over fishing hurt the salmon population there more than clear cutting. 1984-85 were a bust. Thus the fishing restrictions brought about in '86.
There is that and the fact
There is that and the fact that the market tanked. Its not how many fish you catch but the price per pound. The fishing industry is a mere shadow of what it used to be. I say that with sadness; not criticism. I was a deckhand for several years, and my dad and grandpa were commercial fisherman.
I remember fishing in Southeast-trolling with my dad- pre permit days and it was an unforgettable period of my life.
Not to mention, many Sealaska employees are/were commercial fisherman too. Why would they want to throw fisheries under the bus?
Ravenhose ....
.... could it be that they're all riding the Sealaska corporate Gravytrain?
Why indeed? Perhaps timber profits
In 1995, Sealaska was willing to throw fisheries under the bus. In Senate Bill 2539, (landless) they selected according to ADF&G "many of the most productive salmon streams in the region". Included were many LUD II lands and selections included Naha River, Nutkwa Creek, Salmon Bay, Rocky Pass area, Bay of Pillars, Anan Cree, Farragut River, Calder-Holbrook, Lake Eva, Upper Hoonah Sound and Trap Bay, Kadashan, Long and Seal Bay in Tenakee Inlet.
Fortunately, those areas were spared at that time, but it shows that when big trees/salmon producing areas overlap (as they often do) Sealaska will choose to cut.
I remember sunny summer day's in the Tongass......
My brother and cousins had fond memories of the cathedral of light in every direction. We believed that we out of all the races of man that lived as Indians once we're the lucky ones to not have lost the spirits that we inherited.
Then the Sealaska Tribe ran through the middle of it with chainsaws and bulldozers.
well Dominic
Congress did it to you. Their whole plan with ANCSA was to sucker you in with corporations and use that to cut all the trees and make sure that someone else made all the money. I guess it worked. And it's still working. The poor fisherman who wrote this probably doesn't even know that "salmon forest" is going to be the title of Murkowski/Sealaska's next land grab once S.730 fails and they go back to their back room with roundtablers to try again next year.
Tongass fish factory
The last wild sustainable fishery left in the world. I will always be able to buy lumber for a price, but may live to see the day when all salmon are farmed and cheap. I, for one, do not want to have to explain that to my ancestors when I meet them.
Tongass fish factory
The last wild sustainable fishery left in the world. I will always be able to buy lumber for a price, but may live to see the day when all salmon are farmed and cheap. I, for one, do not want to have to explain that to my ancestors when I meet them.
No qcgsnk,
I blame Sealaska. It is an example of a management that has spent most of the time entrenching itself to the easy money at the top that isn't affected by the economy. How many time have we heard about the down turn in the economy from the CEO. Then in the proxy statement he's pocketed seven hundred thousand plus dollars on a base salary of three hundred and fifty thousand dollars?
Sealaska's has allowed the friends and the enemy's of the Native people to mock us as hypocrites for our stewardship of the Tongass. I just don't want to be left in the position, years down the road, that I didn't know what they were doing. Then on top of that having to explain why I didn't do anything about it.
One Hundred Yards
The Law Of Thee Land.....
Will be protected fish streams of the State of Alaska.
No production what-so-ever; within one hundred yards of any, Salmon Stream!!!!