• Overcast
  • 55°
    Overcast
http://sealaska.com
  • Comment

Could new scanners be first step towards sensible security?

Posted: December 13, 2011 - 1:00am

Recent travelers to Ted Stevens Anchorage International Airport might have seen the first step in a long walk back to restoring sanity to America’s air travel security procedures.

Anchorage recently received new full-body scanners that help detect foreign objects — possibly weapons, but much more likely a medical device, wallet or cell phone — without creating invasive images of people going through them.

Instead, according to a report in the Anchorage Daily News, “the scanner’s software displays a generic, gray human form and indicates any concealed metallic or nonmetallic objects that might be under the traveler’s clothes.”

The article further describes how the location of an object found by one of the new scanners is highlighted in yellow on that generic form, narrowing down the anatomy screener’s need to look more closely. A passenger is asked to search the area indicated himself to see if a forgotten item raised the scanner’s suspicion.

Of course, this new machine — which the article states is expected to be in Juneau shortly after the first of the year — does nothing to mitigate the hassle of airport security — long lines, removing shoes and unloading laptops, iPads and so on from a briefcase before reversing the process at the end — hopefully well before your plane takes off. And, the undignified and intrusive pat-down procedures are still in place which involve probing in ways formerly reserved for the wedding night — or at least the third date.

Still, the new scanners no longer take a detailed under-the-clothes picture, and add another step between initial concern and a physical search of the body. This means the Transportation Security Administration has taken an unfortunately unusual measure that means less overbearing and overreaching security, not more.

In the 10-plus years since 9/11, American air travelers have seen color-coded “threat-level” charts, the end, by and large, of accompanying someone to or waiting for them at the gate, the aforementioned removal of electronics and shoes (fortunately, the discovery of the would-be “underwear bomber” never led to our stripping down to our BVDs), the inability to bring more than tiny amounts of liquid past security and the pat-downs that turn travelers into suspects.

Of course, the chart system never stated Americans should have less than an “elevated” fear of impending attack and spent nearly five straight years at the two highest levels, “high” and “severe.” This led to its replacement by a system that only alerts us when there is an “elevated” or “imminent” threat, another small step towards sane security.

But those steps have been few and far between. The other measures may do a lot to make us “feel” secure — a September poll conducted by the libertarian-leaning Reason magazine showed 69 percent of Americans believe TSA has made air travel safer — but their actual usefulness remains unclear. Remember, a malfunction, not security, kept would-be underwear bomber Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab from blowing up a December 2009 flight.

Only 49 percent of respondents to that Reason survey expressed confidence the TSA would actually catch a would-be terrorist, while 44 percent lacked that confidence. Those poll results could be explained by an unexpressed belief enhanced security measures at airports put on a good show, but even their intrusiveness won’t stop a determined or intelligent terrorist.

It’s too early to tell whether the new scanners mark the end of ever-increasing security, no matter the cost to dignity and civil liberty.

Hopefully, though, they represent a realization on behalf of the TSA and the Department of Homeland Security that defenses against terrorism need to evolve, not increase in order to maximize safety.

Whether that happens is largely up to us as citizens and travelers. We need to keep insisting security make sense.

We also must acknowledge there is no such thing as absolute and complete safety, no matter how draconian our security measures become. Sensible security, though, can catch the overwhelming majority of would-be attackers while allowing everyone else to travel with some semblance of dignity and ease.

Let’s keep encouraging our government to take meaningful measures to actually keep us safe while forgoing those that make us feel safe at the expense of our dignity.

• Charles Ward is Deputy Managing Editor of the Juneau Empire. The views expressed here are his own, and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Empire’s editorial board.

  • Comment

Comments (9)

Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
dingdong
84
Points
dingdong 12/13/11 - 05:22 pm
0
0

Failure and Waste

The TSA is a horrible waste of taxpayer money and taxpayer time. Not one terrorist has been caught since TSA has taken over security in our airports. In spite of millions of people being groped and sexually molested by the agents, all they have come up with is barrels of cosmetics, cigarette lighters and other harmless material carried by harmless people. It is time to dismantle the TSA and privitize security and let airports handle it. If anything is needed, expand the air marshall program. Stop the theatrics and the attempt to convince us we are safer because of these clowns.

Persnickety Persimmon
4173
Points
Persnickety Persimmon 12/13/11 - 05:35 pm
0
0

You had me nodding until you

You had me nodding until you said "privatize security." What, so profit can be the ultimate goal and not, you know, security? Silly idea.

Expanding the Air Marshall program is a good idea, though.

Latitude58
14495
Points
Latitude58 12/13/11 - 10:09 pm
0
0

How many planes...

...have been hijacked and crashed into skyscrapers since TSA took over the airports?

sheqelim
488
Points
sheqelim 12/14/11 - 01:53 am
0
0

Full body scanners are

Full body scanners are supposed to be _less_ invasive? I'd rather just let TSA fondle my junk.

pearl
0
Points
pearl 12/14/11 - 06:42 am
0
0

The new software changes NOTHING

The software does not change one thing about the objections to these machines. The machines are still collecting the same images - just not displaying them - so they still are storing the naked photos of everyone who passes through.

Also, the dangerous radiation is the same, so who are these liars kidding? This represents zero improvement, but it illustrates the gullibility of the public if they accept it.

bigdan57
325
Points
bigdan57 12/14/11 - 08:30 am
0
0

Body scanners

So, how soon do we expect to have to go through a security check to get on the float plane to Angoon or Tenakee? I can't count the times I have carried a gun on those flights!

dingdong
84
Points
dingdong 12/14/11 - 07:17 pm
0
0

@Lat 58

How many airplanes were hijacked and crashed into skyscrapers before TSA took over the airports before 9/11? When you agree to give up your liberty in exchange for percieved security, this is what kind of system you end up with. The TSA is just theater performance. Make people be their personal monkeys, shake down disabled persons in wheelchairs, molest a girls scout troop, and fondle grandma in the name of security. Common sense is gone. Why not allow law abiding citizens to carry concealed weapons is they choose and have the flight attendant warn any scoflaws that there are armed citizens on board? Or use a system similar to the Israelis where people are questioned and profiled rather that the invasive demeaning, ineffective clown act.

Latitude58
14495
Points
Latitude58 12/14/11 - 08:29 pm
0
0

dong

"Why not allow law abiding citizens to carry concealed weapons is they choose and have the flight attendant warn any scoflaws that there are armed citizens on board?"

Why not? Simple. I would not be at all willing to get on a flight with a nutcase like you onboard packing.

J. E. Fume
5005
Points
J. E. Fume 12/14/11 - 09:52 pm
0
0

I'm not overly thrilled with

I'm not overly thrilled with the long waits at airports and the feeling of being penned cattle herded onto the plane. However, you people who pooh-pooh security measures announce to the world that you are simpletons of the highest order. Hijackings were a major problem long before the advent of bin Laden and his boys. Furthermore, the British intelligence services by dumb luck stumbled onto a group of terrorists who had plans that would have made 9/11 seem like a cub scout picnic. Make no mistake, we live in a dangerous world. Sure TSA is a pain in the butt. However, I'd rather be fondled a little bit and have to put up with a story here and there about some indignant grannie who got moved out of her wheelchair than to have to experience the likes of 9/11 again.

By the way, the idea of having passengers carrying firearms was not well thought out. Bullets flying around in a pressurized cabin is asking for disaster.

Back to Top

Spotted

Please Note: You may have disabled JavaScript and/or CSS. Although this news content will be accessible, certain functionality is unavailable.

Skip to News

« back

next »

  • title http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376863/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/359852/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376858/
  • title http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376853/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376843/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/368637/
  • title http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376838/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376833/
Fire Academy Graduation

CONTACT US

  • Switchboard: 907-586-3740
  • Circulation and Delivery: 907-586-3740
  • Newsroom Fax: 907-586-3028
  • Business Fax: 907-586-9097
  • Accounts Receivable: 907-523-2270
  • View the Staff Directory
  • or Send feedback

ADVERTISING

SUBSCRIBER SERVICES

SOCIAL NETWORKING