It’s a good thing Gertrude Stein never said, “A phone is a phone is a phone.” Clearly, these days, her tautology would be a disconnect, received like a dropped call. The mobile devices we’re so dependent on, attached like an extension of our brains, are so much more. Ultimately, they allow everything to be knowable.
But while the smooth, mirrored glass on an iPhone presents a funhouse from which anyone can observe all the YouTube videos, Facebook updates, Tweets and apps, ad infinitum and at an instant — when blended with the speed of driving, it’s enough to send a person careening through the glass of a car windshield onto the hard, real world pavement.
Reconciling the collision of these two worlds will take some discipline, growing pains and — if the National Transportation Safety Board has its way — regulation. Last week, the NTSB recommended that every state ban the use of mobile devices by drivers. That includes hands-free devices too. No texting, no phoning, no nothin’.
Today, nine states and D.C. prohibit all drivers from using handheld cell phones while driving. Except in Maryland, all laws are “primary enforcement” — an officer may cite a driver for using a handheld cell phone without any other traffic offense taking place. As for text messaging: 35 states and D.C. ban it for all drivers. And even if you’re thinking of reading that text message at a stoplight, don’t. Maryland’s texting-while-driving law, which took effect in October, prohibits all drivers in Maryland from using an electronic device to write, send, or even read a text message while operating a motor vehicle in the travel lanes of the roadway.
Clear as a lens at the Space Telescope Science Institute, these laws make sense.
It’s all too common a phenomenon to look over, behind or in front and see a fellow commuter juggling the wheel, his coffee mug and his lifeline to the Internet, and want to honk a wake-up call so he get back to reality.
Yet, he who is without fingers should cast the first PDA out the window.
The challenge is, if these apparatuses are becoming extensions of us, providing guidance on how we live, shop, work and play, then how conceivable is it that we can actually exist sans contraption?
After all, we live in a world where media cannot not be found. We’ve become so accustomed to it always there, always on, that we reference it before we even look to the reality it’s supposed to be displaying. The postmodern philosopher Jean Baudrillard described this brave new world as hypereality, or as a map so detailed that it ends up taking the place of that which it is referencing. (By the way, he wrote about this long before there were Garmin GPS devices loaded in every new car.)
Navigating around the obstacles all this media displays, and more than a bit ironic (just as part of the virus is needed to create the antibody), Sergey Brin, co-founder of Google and an investor in Tesla Motors, has recently been on the road to achieving the vision of a driverless car. Indeed, it was reported that via artificial intelligence, deploying GPS video cameras and radar sensors, driverless cars — which have been successfully tested in California — could soon be all over our roads, with the result being fewer accidents and lighter, streamlined vehicles. Holy Knight Rider!
But until all our cars can drive themselves, we should continue to heed the advice given by the band The Doors: “Keep your eyes on the road, your hands upon the wheel.”
• Novick is a writer and communications consultant in Towson, Md. His email is abe@abebuzz.com. He wrote this for the Baltimore Sun.





Comments (6)
Add commentTechnology's the Problem
And technology can be the solution.
I'm curious about hands-free phones. How is talking to someone through a bluetooth device any more distracting than talking to an actual passenger? Will talking in cars be banned next?
Driverless cars are going to change the roads and vehicles as we know it. And quickly. Frankly, I'd be fine not driving most of the time. Plenty of other things I could do instead, like text on my cellphone.
If you're really curious
If you're really curious about hands free phones as contributors to accidents, look up NHTSA research on the subject. I don't agree that driverless cars will be quickly changing our roads and vehicles.
Durian
I was curious so I did look it up. Actually, NHTSA has very little on the subject. A 2003 study concluded that hands-free cell conversations did reduce driver attention, but it didn't compare that with conversations with passengers.
NHTSA states that talking with passengers is the #1 distraction most drivers are subject to.
NTSB recommends banning all cell usage, including hands-free, unless the hands-free is built into the car. Wonder why the exception?
Nevada just passed a state law allowing driverless cars. Google just got a patent on their driverless car technology. The advantages are immense. This technology will be coming on very quickly. Within 5 years they'll be commercially available. Within 10, common. Within 20, ubiquitous.
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/technology/2011/06/nevada-authorizes-dri...
@Latitude58
No, don't be ridiculous, talking to fellow passengers in cars will not be banned. There is a difference between talking handsfree on the phone and talking to a passenger. The passenger is aware of the road conditions and may get quiet while you're changing lanes, tell you that the car in front of you is braking, etc. There are studies to support this conclusion and a simple Google search is all you need to do.
The writer's message is spot on: hang up and drive -- it's safer and no one needs to be on the phone while driving.
Gee Jimmy
Get a sense of humor. Of course talking to passengers won't be banned. And I'll be ridiculous if I want.
I didn't see any study directly comparing talking to live passengers vs talking on a hands-free phone. Did you?
Passengers can participate in navigation, assuming they're capable. But what about children? Or a blind passenger? Or a drunk passenger? Or the wife who's been admonished by her husband for 'back seat driving' and now doesn't make driving comments?
And for the record, I do not drive and talk on a cell (or text) concurrently.
@Latitude58
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3vFcIpzF7pc