• Few clouds
  • 55°
    Few clouds
http://sealaska.com
  • Comment

Internet is a Tower of Babel staffed by untrained writers with no standards

Posted: March 16, 2012 - 12:14am

WASHINGTON — My love affair with newspapers began when I was very young and has continued throughout my life. I still thrill to such names as the Ticonderoga Sentinel, which I discovered while driving through the Green Mountains of Vermont, the Bloomington (Ill.) Pantagraph, where the famous Washington Post columnist David Broder began his career, and the Wapakoneta Daily News, the Ohio hometown newspaper of astronaut Neil Armstrong.

Newspapers such as these do far more than tell you the news. They record our country’s history. They reflect the culture and standards and concerns of our communities. They record the activities of our schools, our churches, councils and Kiwanis, and the births, weddings and deaths that define the passage of generations. They carry ads for everything you could possibly need, from hardware stores to real estate agents and plumbers to cleaning services. Readers relate to their local papers in ways they will never relate to the Internet.

Experts say that traditional media simply cannot compete with the fast-evolving digital offerings of the Web.

In certain respects, this is true. It is the reason that many papers, sadly, have been forced out of business. But the reverse is also true: the Internet is unlikely ever to be able to compete with the public service provided by local papers and their reporters and editors, who love their communities and know every inch of their territory.

As local paper reporters gravitate to larger papers, wire services or broadcasting, they bring with them the disciplines of accuracy and fairness and accountability learned at the local level.

All our great journalists, from Zenger to Reston and Murrow to Cronkite, learned their trade and achieved their greatest triumphs in what we now call the traditional media. They have served us well. Their passion for facts rather than ideology has strengthened the foundations of our democracy.

By contrast, the Internet today increasingly resembles a Tower of Babel, with millions of self-appointed, untrained citizen-journalists writing whatever they feel like writing with few editorial checkpoints.

Often they are simply purveying their prejudices or ideologies dressed up as news. Many seem to specialize in triggering unnecessary health scares, with concerned young mothers as their preferred target. But as every reader of the Internet knows, once misleading information is posted, there is no easy way of correcting it. The errors remain. This is even true of Wikipedia, which tries harder than most to be accurate.

Newspapers have their faults, including their own biases, but overall they remain the most trustworthy sources of information for the general public. It is a matter of honor for the professional journalists who produce them.

But unlike regular newspapers, there are now thousands of “newspapers” on the Internet, ranging from digital editions of The New York Times to look-alikes started almost every week by college students having fun or, more insidiously, by foreign operatives intent on spreading misinformation to deliberately confuse or mislead the American public.

Whereas readers usually know the location of their local newspaper office and can talk with the editors, the location of some of the Internet versions is often shrouded in secrecy. A newspaper or news service with an American-sounding name may be based in China or North Korea. You cannot know for sure.

When scanning the Internet for news or other information, therefore, caution is not only desirable but vitally necessary.

The most serious indictment of today’s “new” or “social media” is the continued absence of any rigorous correcting mechanism. Errors can remain forever uncorrected. This is not only dangerous, but presents an especially serious challenge to the millions of young Americans who have come to rely on the Internet as their primary source of information.

• A former military reporter for London’s Daily Telegraph, John Adams is a Washington consultant and author of “In the Trenches: Adventures in Journalism and Public Affairs.”

  • Comment

Comments (10)

Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
islander
1192
Points
islander 03/16/12 - 09:46 am
0
0

balderdash

News papers have had a history of leading Americans towards one party or the other beginning with the founding of the country. News paper have been notorious for taking a single position on an issue and completely leaving out any other view on the issue. Most Americans accept what they read in newspapers as being the truth. A premise that is so incorrect that it is laughable.

Internet authors know up front that in a few keystrokes the information the write can easily be verified. Try finding answers to questions by looking only through the printed news where editors can easily determine the content by insuring any related story has the same vantage point as another.

The major issue with the Internet is the users have to achieve a mind set where the verify what they read by using the few key strokes required. Unfortunately it seems most readers prefer to find a happy place on the web and chose to limit their reading from source no less directed than the views a newspaper can contain.

fromdustreturned
1468
Points
fromdustreturned 03/16/12 - 09:59 am
2
1

Verification

While it is completely true that users should develop the mindset to verify what they read with "a few keystrokes", the problem is that the vast majority of people are so hamstrung by their invisible prejudices and assumptions that the key strokes are generally to web sites with which they already agree, and the search for "truth" really isn't much more than self-confirmation.

Development of a critical mindset is sadly lacking, although I might be basing that assessment on a skewed sample or an inadequate sample size.

MC Trig
-1
Points
MC Trig 03/16/12 - 10:00 am
0
0

Well, here's the solution...

...lock em up and throw away the key!

blackdog
6
Points
blackdog 03/16/12 - 10:15 am
2
0

"Their passion for facts

"Their passion for facts rather than ideology has strengthened the foundations of our democracy."

It is nice to reminisce about those long forgotten journalists who had a modicum of integrity. Today it is often more informative to notice what mainstream news outlets choose not to report.....

swimmergirl
4368
Points
swimmergirl 03/16/12 - 10:48 am
0
0

blackdog...or....

what NON-mainstream "news" outlets choose to "report" over, and over, and over, and over......which clearly works to "deliberately confuse or mislead" the American public - over 50% of folks in Missisipi still believe President Obama is a Muslim.........

As I said in the other piece - the caution is to always consider the source, and to learn to distinguish opinion from fact.

blackdog
6
Points
blackdog 03/16/12 - 11:09 am
1
0

Agreed swimmer, and most

Agreed swimmer, and most democrats still think the Obama/Clinton administration is anti-war and anti-coporatist.

I think most people understand that the internet is full of lots of BS but most people still give the mainstream media/traditional press an undeserved benefit of the doubt. Watching the same story by MSNBC and Fox or reading about the same in the NY Times and Washington Post doesn't give you a balanced account of the truth. You just get different lies and distortions. It's just good-cop/bad-cop IMHO.....

wolfmagic2012
2658
Points
wolfmagic2012 03/16/12 - 11:27 am
0
0

No charging to the newspapers...

...defense from me. Newspapers are obsolete. Don't talk to me about journalistic integrity...how about suborned ownership? Newspapers have been feeding milk and pap (little meat) to the masses for over a hundred years, and each year that went by, the problem worsened. Manipulators of public opinion. Just as with today's newspapers, one must wade through the great volume of information on the Internet being researched and each person must determine for themselves the truth or falsehood of what they are accessing. Journalistic integrity. What a joke. The only journalistic integrity that exists, comes from the heart of individual journalists who strive to present the truth as they see it. Too bad most are frequently told what they will be reporting, by corporate owners up to their eyeballs in conflict of interest and subornation of the truth. Newspapers or internet... anyone who believes everything they read is a fool. The truth is a secret revealed to those who diligently seek it.
Thank God for the Internet, for the newspapers have failed miserably when it comes to serious, unbiased journalism.

Jesster
0
Points
Jesster 03/16/12 - 04:15 pm
0
0

It depends on what "resembles" means. . ..

Your title says the internet "is" a tower of Babel, while the article says "resembles". Is that journalistic integrity, or a clever way to capture readers' attention??

Persnickety Persimmon
4173
Points
Persnickety Persimmon 03/16/12 - 04:30 pm
0
0

@Jesster: it's called a

@Jesster: it's called a metaphor.

ospreyy
96
Points
ospreyy 03/17/12 - 02:44 am
1
0

The good times weren't so good

Newspapers of the past lied just as much or more than today -- we just didn't know it. Those sainted reporters lied about Kennedy all the time. Not only did they cover up the affairs, but they also told tons of lies about the Cuban Missile Crisis. They never did report how the US caved in and withdrew missiles from Turkey, but instead reported that the USSR caved in.

Back to Top

Spotted

Please Note: You may have disabled JavaScript and/or CSS. Although this news content will be accessible, certain functionality is unavailable.

Skip to News

« back

next »

  • title http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376863/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/359852/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376858/
  • title http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376853/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376843/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/368637/
  • title http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376838/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376833/
Fire Academy Graduation

CONTACT US

  • Switchboard: 907-586-3740
  • Circulation and Delivery: 907-586-3740
  • Newsroom Fax: 907-586-3028
  • Business Fax: 907-586-9097
  • Accounts Receivable: 907-523-2270
  • View the Staff Directory
  • or Send feedback

ADVERTISING

SUBSCRIBER SERVICES

SOCIAL NETWORKING