Sundown Friday marked the beginning of Passover, the commemoration of the Jews’ emancipation from enslavement in ancient Egypt.
This year Passover falls on a day of enormous significance in the struggle for freedom in modern Egypt — April 6. That date is synonymous with the April 6 Youth Movement — formed in 2008 and named for the date of a planned strike to support Egyptian workers — that became the backbone of last year’s Tahrir revolution that toppled Egypt’s most recent pharaoh, Hosni Mubarak.
As Jews sit down for Passover Seder, the coincidence of these dates should remind us that — on this night and all others — the struggle for freedom in Egypt is one deeply linked to our own as Jews. And that even as Egypt’s political transition remains murky, Jews — and indeed all Americans — have a moral stake in its outcome.
This connection with Egypt’s struggle for freedom might seem to contradict the role of Egypt in biblical history. In many respects, the Bible sets up Egypt as the consummate “other.” Egypt is not only the place of Jewish enslavement; it is the site of the first attempt at genocide in Jewish history (the pharaoh’s decree to kill all newborn Jewish boys). The Hebrew word for Egypt, “Mitzrayim,” signifies oppression, as its root connotes a “confining” or “narrow” place. Even today, Jews are taught to remember that “we were all slaves in Egypt once.”
Yet Egypt has also played a positive role in Jewish history. In the Bible, Egypt was often a place of refuge and growth. Abraham fled to Egypt during famine in Canaan. Joseph prospered in Egypt after falling into favor with the pharaoh. Similarly, Moses was rescued from the Nile by an Egyptian princess, then raised in the house of the pharaoh.
In modern times, Egypt was home to a thriving Jewish community numbering nearly 80,000 in 1945. But after the establishment of Israel in 1948, Egypt expelled its Jews and went on to fight four wars against the Jewish state. Yet Egypt was also the first Arab country to sign a peace treaty with Israel. Even as Egypt has at times exhibited strong currents of anti-Semitism, it was also a refuge for some fleeing persecution in Europe. My grandmother escaped from her native Romania during the Holocaust with the aid of Egyptian and Turkish diplomats.
For Christians, these paradoxes should also resonate during Easter. Christians, of course, believe the same stories from the Hebrew Bible. Egypt is also where Jesus fled from Herod, and it has one of the world’s oldest Christian communities, even as the Copts today suffer persecution. And Easter is historically rooted in Passover: The Last Supper was a Passover Seder.
America’s relationship with Egypt is likewise defined by contradictions. Egypt was a one-time Cold War foe turned strategic partner, a dictatorship with which we did business, even as we sought to forge ties directly with its people. America has given considerable military aid to Egypt, but it has also spent more than $28 billion in non-military aid in Egypt since 1975, including critical investments in healthcare, education, infrastructure and democracy promotion. These contradictions have continued since the Tahrir revolution, as the Obama administration both unreservedly supports Egypt’s democratization, yet must also engage with Egypt’s current non-democratic government.
More than a year after the Tahrir revolution, the situation in Egypt remains of deep concern. The country continues to languish under military rule, its government often engaging in self-defeating behavior such as its recent crackdown on nongovernmental organizations. The economy remains in a state of near free-fall.
Yet there are many signs of hope. Egyptians across all parts of society, including liberals, women, youth, moderate Islamists, and even the seemingly non-political (the “Party of the Couch”), continue to try to build a democracy.
As this struggle unfolds, there is a temptation to shrink from Egypt’s contradictions and just defend America’s “core interests,” such as the Camp David accords and the freedom of the Suez Canal.
But important as these interests are, any policy based on them alone does not measure up to the richness of our history with Egypt or the magnitude of this moment.
Ultimately, the battle for freedom in Egypt can only be led, as it has been, by Egyptians. But we should not be satisfied until — in the words of America’s own Moses, the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., himself quoting the Jewish prophet Amos — “justice flows down like waters and righteousness like a mighty stream.”
This Passover, this April 6 and this Easter, let us all remember that there is no mightier stream than the Nile.
• Ratner is a former appointee at the Obama administration State Department, where he worked on the U.S. response to the revolution in Egypt and the broader Arab Spring. He wrote this for the Los Angeles Times.




Comments (9)
Add commentOMG and this guy is Jewish?
OMG and this guy is Jewish?
Funny how he never mentioned that the Muslim Brotherhood won nearly half of the parliament seats last year and that they are running candidates in the upcoming elections for President in Egypt. If they are successful in winning the Presidency wonder how that will bode for the Jews and Israel.
I'm thinking not a whole lot of democracy will be going on.
And he so breezily passes over the plight of the Coptic Christians.
Must be more of that liberal historical revisionism on display.
Can anyone explain why American Jews vote so heavily Democrat?
Exodus.
History is repeating itself with the exodus of Christians from Jewish strongholds.
The American 'Moses'? Let us not get carried away.
@Calypso
To answer your question, one of the main reasons American Jews vote so heavily Democrat (unless it was in the Bush/Gore 2000 election in heavily Jewish areas of Florida in a state governed by Bush's brother)** is because the Democratic Party has a history of defending the civil rights of historically oppressed minority groups, like Jews.
And the republican party does not.
In fact, the republicans have a history of oppressing minority groups such as gays, blacks, and most recently, their War On Women.
p.s., the ** comment above was sarcasm. Jews in Palm Springs didn't really vote overwhelmingly republican that election, even though the results indicate otherwise.
Jo
Nice try. Go back to the sixties and before and tell me again about the 'history' of civil rights being defended by the Democratic Party. I am assuming you were there.
Yeah, no kidding about
Yeah, no kidding about democrats and civil rights. Does democrat senator Robert Byrd being a grand dragon with the KKK ring a bell? How 'bout Al Gore's dad and his vote against the civil rights act of 1964 in congress?
Take another stab at it, jo. Why do American Jews vote democrat?
p.s. Palm Springs is in California - it's Palm Beach in Florida.
@Calypso: Jo was simply
@Calypso: Jo was simply confuddling democrats with liberals, as many Americans do. Liberals have a history of defending disenfranchised groups and minorities. It was a liberal who freed the slaves, liberals who founded the country, and a liberal who opened the national parks and instituted labor reforms.
And before the 60's, both parties had liberal and conservative wings. In fact, the Republican party was once the party of the northern U.S., and the Democratic party represented the south, by and large. But not anymore, obviously.
So there. Glad I could clarify for you.
@p - but why when Jews are
@p - but why when Jews are great businessmen, do they vote Democrat when that party is all about big government?
I'm not buying your answer - the Jews in America are not "disenfranchised".
How do you explain the Arab Spring and the current administration's backing of that? Allowing radical Muslims to rule those countries is not going to help the Jewish people.
And is it ever correct to call the Democrat party the Democratic party?
@Calypso: let's spell it out
@Calypso: let's spell it out in clear terms: you and your ilk are exclusive. Members of your clique must be a certain way, or you exclude them. The Democrats are inclusive; they accept everyone you reject.
Jews have a long history of oppression. Anti-semitism is still rampant in many circles (including yours; see: Jews are the chosen people but are still going to hell; Jews run Hollywood; Jews run the banks; Jews killed Jesus; etc.).
Persecuted peoples tend not to side with those who persecute.
@p - liberalism really is a
@p - liberalism really is a mental disorder.
You're nuts. More projection?