Alaska Editorial: Lawmakers slip surly bonds of tax pledge

Norquist's pacts losing punch

This editorial first appeared in the Anchorage Daily News:

More lawmakers put nation before tax promise

Grover Norquist and his Americans for Tax Reform have wielded a powerful pledge for a generation, a pledge that became obligatory for most Republican candidates and some Democrats running in conservative strongholds.

It reads like this:

“I, ______, pledge to the taxpayers of the ______ district of the state of ______ and to the American people that I will:

One, oppose any and all efforts to increase the marginal income tax rates for individuals and/or businesses; and

Two, oppose any net reduction or elimination of deductions and credits, unless matched dollar for dollar by further reducing tax rates.”

The pledge has played its part in the fierce resistance of congressional Republicans over the last few years to any rollback in the “temporary” Bush era tax cuts.

But some lawmakers are awakening to the need to walk away from the pledge, despite Norquist’s claim that the pledge is a promise to the constituents who voted for them, one that binds them for as long as they are in office.

Not so, say lawmakers like Alaska U.S. Sen. Lisa Murkowski.

Asked about her view of the pledge, which she signed before her first full term in Senate, Murkowski said her answer is in a letter she wrote to Norquist in November 2011:

“Dear Mr. Norquist,

“Just as the U.S. Constitution prescribes that Senators shall be elected for terms of six years, pledges I sign only cover the six year term (proceeding my signing). Thus the pledge I signed in 2003 is no longer valid. Thank you for your attention to this matter.

“Sincerely,

“Lisa A. Murkowski

“United States Senator”

Alaska Rep. Don Young, another lawmaker who once signed the tax pledge, doesn’t feel bound either.

“Regarding pledges, Congressman Young’s only pledges are to the Constitution and the people of Alaska,” Luke Miller, his spokesman, wrote in an e-mail Tuesday.

In recent days, other Republican lawmakers like Sens. Saxby Chambliss of Georgia and Lindsay Graham of South Carolina have suggested they might wiggle on their Norquist pledges if President Obama and Senate Democrats are willing to talk about spending cuts and reforms in entitlements, primarily Medicare and Medicaid.

Some more independent lawmakers never embraced the Norquist pledge and refused to be cowed by his threats of running hard-right candidates against them in primaries. Former Republican Wyoming Sen. Alan Simpson, no tax-and-spend liberal, dismissed Norquist’s pledge as “no taxes, under any situation, even if your country goes to hell.”

Others, like House minority leader Eric Cantor, R-Virginia, have said the pledge is a big deal in D.C. but not among the folks back home.

Chambliss, Graham and Rep. Peter King of New York, who invoked the one-term rule like Murkowski and was accused by Norquist of “weasling,” have made clear that their oath of office trumps any tax pledge and their highest obligation is to the good of the country.

That’s the right course. None of these lawmakers is a champion of tax increases. But those thinking clearly and honestly understand that the United States can’t wrestle its debt under control without both spending cuts and tax increases. What if Democrats had signed pledges never to cut a penny from Medicaid, Medicare or any social program?

What would we have? Absolute and perpetual legislative paraylsis. Or, to put it another way, insanity.

Both cuts and taxes need to be done with care. Tax increases need to start at the top. Both sides need to compromise. That’s clearly the wish of well more than half the American people.

Pledges born of rigid ideology only hobble the people elected to find answers that work, while the ideologues bask in their self-destructive self-righteousness — enjoying power unburdened by duty or accountability.

Republicans who violate the Norquist pledge won’t become Democrats. But they may become problem-solvers, with a wider view of the national interest and a determination to put the nation’s finances back on solid footing by recognizing that half the country thinks Grover Norquist’s pledge is a waste of good paper.

Good of the country comes before tax pledge.

More

Mon, 02/27/2017 - 08:37

Rich Moniak: Presidential lies that matter

President Donald Trump did not have “the biggest electoral college win since Ronald Reagan” as he said during his first press conference last week. The fact that he’s wrong doesn’t justify calling him a liar though. It’s an insignificant statement. But like his predecessors, it should serve as a warning that, whenever it serves his own interests, Trump will discard the truth on serious matters.

Read more
Mon, 02/27/2017 - 10:20

Letter: State senator’s form letter full of misinformation on Planned Parenthood

I have been in correspondence with my Senator, Dan Sullivan. I was able to let him know by email that I want him to continue support of Planned Parenthood federally and locally. I am disheartened by the form letter I received from him. His letter was full of misinformation that reflected/used the words that pro-life organizations do. If he is going to write back to his constituents, he should use language that shows he is aware of what the laws are and how funding really works. Read more

Mon, 02/27/2017 - 08:32

My Turn: Gov. Walker shouldn’t fleece taxpayers while cutting budget

Gov. Bill Walker, you should be ashamed of yourself for stooping so low to even consider further fleecing the very taxpayer who supports a lot of this so-called government, especially since you already took 50% of the permanent fund as another form of tax to support your already top-heavy bureaucracy that never seems to get or have enough to spend.

Read more
Mon, 02/27/2017 - 08:31

ANWR: Let it be

Nearly 20 years ago historian Stephen Ambrose visited Juneau as part of the Alaska Humanities Forum. The author of “Undaunted Courage,” “Citizen Soldiers” and other bestselling books, Ambrose said the last century had been darkened by world wars. But overall the century’s theme was inspiring: democracy prevailed over totalitarianism.

Read more
 

CONTACT US

  • Switchboard: 907-586-3740
  • Circulation and Delivery: 907-586-3740
  • Newsroom Fax: 907-586-9097
  • Business Fax: 907-586-9097
  • Accounts Receivable: 907-523-2230
  • View the Staff Directory
  • or Send feedback

ADVERTISING

SUBSCRIBER SERVICES

SOCIAL NETWORKING