• Overcast, light rain
  • 54°
    Overcast, light rain
  • Comment

Empire Editorial: Education reform shouldn't be rushed

Posted: February 20, 2014 - 12:09am

Gov. Sean Parnell wants to see widespread education reform by the end of the legislative session in April. Setting goals is good, but what’s even better is setting achievable ones.

Education reform can happen in 90 days, but will the reforms be properly vetted, researched and implemented in that time?

Something as far-reaching as overhauling our public education system shouldn’t be rushed.

What voucher model will Alaska follow, and what effect will that have on Alaska’s public schools? What happens if a private school underperforms after receiving state funds? Will it still receive state funding without any way for the state to ensure results? And if a community turns down a new charter school, will the education commissioner be able to override that decision?

These questions and many more are unanswered, and there’s only two months left in the 28th Legislature. Waiting until the 29th Legislature is the right choice.

Lawmakers need time to analyze how vouchers have been implemented in other states. If education reform was the only bill on the table, perhaps there would be enough time to find the best fit for Alaska’s unique needs.

Individual items like doing away with the high school exit exam and increasing base funding are doable this year. Vouchers are not. We’re not saying vouchers are a good idea or a bad one, but whatever the state’s direction, it needs to be thought out so the program doesn’t turn out like the Affordable Care Act website.

According to a 2013 Washington Post article, Lower 48 students have used vouchers for unaccredited schools. States have been left with little to no oversight of what students learn and whether their teachers are qualified.

If the Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster decided to start a private school in the back of a bowling alley, the state may not have a choice but to give the school tens of thousands of dollars — or more — in vouchers. Without understanding the pitfalls other states have fallen into, Alaska will be more likely to repeat the mistakes of others instead of learning from them. On the other hand, some states have found success using vouchers, which allowed students from low-income families to attend schools they otherwise would never have had the opportunity to enroll in.

More importantly, is the education reform touted in HB278 and SB139 the change Alaska needs? A survey paid for by the National Education Association-Alaska reveals a different problem. According to educators surveyed, factors outside school walls are what’s keeping students from learning and graduating on time. Drugs, drinking, abuse and poor home environments are to blame for poor performance, teachers say. These issues are ones that vouchers and funding increases aren’t likely to fix. Tossing money at the problem is hacking at the branches instead of going after the root.

Alaska’s education system needs to evolve as times change, but such a widespread overhaul in so little time could provoke more problems than solutions if it isn’t done right the first time.

  • Comment

Comments (4) Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
Judy Hodel
Judy Hodel 02/20/14 - 01:36 pm
Accept All That Apply

Make tax money to private schools contingent on those schools following all of the public school requirements: accept and educate all sudents that apply, including the disabled; take the same standardized tests and post scores annually; similar educational requirements and goals; teacher backgrounds and pay should be similar; pubicize the annual budget, so the public can see where tax money is allocated…
Most private and parochial schools would refuse the money.

Wayne Coogan
Wayne Coogan 02/21/14 - 09:04 am
Think about that Judy...

accountability and testing is a good thing. However, we should not require private schools to morph into bloated, inefficient bureaucracies that mimic public schools. Giving parents the choice to direct their children's education entitlement to competitive options is entirely reasonable. Any public school threatened by competition should examine its efficacy. In the private sector we do that every day.

Judy Hodel
Judy Hodel 02/21/14 - 02:43 pm
Competition Smoke Screen

The Governor would like to make this an issue about public schools being worried about "competition". He could not be more misguided, misinformed, or mistaken.

This is an effort for religious/anti-government entities to gain access to public money to further their agendas within their own group.

If a parent chooses to have their children educated in an environment that limits their child's critical thinking skills and access to science while declaring government is bad, so be it. They just don't get to use public funds to do so.

If you parents want to send your kids to a private school that teaches them that the earth is 6,000 years old, that Noah really did float around in that boat for 40 days with all those animals on board and that puts creationism ahead of evolution, then have at it.

But do it with your own money. That State should not pay for the dumbing down of your children, you should.

Wayne Coogan
Wayne Coogan 02/21/14 - 05:23 pm
Thank you for your reply...

but please understand it IS our own money we are referring to... that is, our share of the public money earmarked for each and every child equally. The Noah comment is a red-herring fallacy. What if a private school did a better job of teaching the same material as a public school? Would you object to a mother of modest income having the choice to send her children there?

Back to Top


  • Switchboard: 907-586-3740
  • Circulation and Delivery: 907-586-3740
  • Newsroom Fax: 907-586-9097
  • Business Fax: 907-586-9097
  • Accounts Receivable: 907-523-2230
  • View the Staff Directory
  • or Send feedback