My Turn: Broken committment

  • By THOMAS GARBER
  • Friday, August 12, 2016 1:00am
  • Opinion

On Aug. 1, 2015, Quinton Chandler with KBBI radio published “North Pole lawmaker seeks investigation into the state Office of Children’s Services.”

Rep. Tammie Wilson, R-North Pole, reported that she’s heard hundreds of problematic stories, many with common elements: caseworkers removing children without evidence of a threat to safety. Not giving biological families priority when placing children in a new home, and constantly changing criteria for families to regain custody of their children. Wilson says, “They take the children for just an allegation and we can’t even figure out how they’re substantiating it. We do know that once an allegation is made, it becomes the parents’ obligation to prove that it didn’t happen.”

In 2012 the Alaska Ombudsman published investigation report J2011-0222, regarding OCS’s grievance process. The ombudsman found that; “OCS has not carried out the grievance process in a fair and efficient manner, has not adequately notified citizens of the process, has not responded consistently to grievances filed by citizens, and has not consistently responded to grievances in a timely or adequate manner.”

In 2013 the ombudsman published another report A2013-0776, regarding the Department of Health and Social Services Background Check Program (BCP). The program, created by law in 2005, established background check requirements for persons and entities licensed or certified by DHSS, or eligible to receive payments from DHSS to care for individuals served by Department programs. Between 2007 and March 2012, DHSS has permanently banned individuals from employment if the applicant had a substantiated finding of abuse or neglect by OCS.

In both reports the ombudsman explains that a 2006 settlement in U.S. District Court where Mark Ruby asserted that OCS had denied him due process for failure to properly notify him of a substantiated finding of child abuse and his right to an appeal. The lawsuit led to a settlement in which OCS agreed to adopt regulations to provide increased due process protections, including a formal appeal procedure to contest a substantiated finding of child abuse or neglect.

OCS implemented regulatory changes in December 2006. In order to address the fact that the grievance procedure did not actually contain any significant rules of procedure, section 215 was inserted to allow grievants in cases of substantiated findings who wished to call witnesses and present evidence to forgo the grievance procedure and simply take their cases to the Office of Administrative Hearings. An administrative judge would hear the case, and present a proposed decision to the Commissioner of Health and Social Services for action.

Tammie Wilson publicly called for a grand jury investigation regarding removal and placement of children. However, reading the specifics of the ombudsman reports they clearly demonstrate that even after the U.S. District Court settlement, all forms of OCS’s grievance process remain unreasonably administered. My personal experience with the OAH process compounded the OCS’s grievance process, there is no due process! Tammie Wilson needs to honor her August 2015 public announcement calling for a grand jury investigation. First, read the ombudsman reports!

• Thomas Garber lives in Kenai.

More in Opinion

Web
Have something to say?

Here’s how to add your voice to the conversation.

The Aiviq, a private icebreaker the U.S. Coast Guard is considering purchasing for Arctic operations with Juneau as its home port, is seen on March 24, 2012. (Courtesy of the U.S. Coast Guard)
Opinion: Giving credit where credit is due

It’s been a long time since the Juneau economy has been bolstered… Continue reading

Gus Schumacher, an Anchorage cross-country skier, testifies at a Senate Budget Committee hearing last Wednesday. (Budget committee screenshot)
An Alaska Olympian went to D.C. to testify on climate change. Then a senator dredged up old tweets.

Gus Schumacher hit with climate science quiz in exchange that went viral in conservative circles.

U.S. Sen. Dan Sullivan, R-Alaska, second from right, attends a bill signing by President Donald Trump on Thursday, Oct. 11, 2018, in the Oval Office of the White House. (Official White House photo)
Opinion: Sen. Dan Sullivan, a conservative in name only

It’s easy to imagine Sen. Lisa Murkowski broke out in a smile… Continue reading

(Anne Onamuss / For the Juneau Empire)
My Turn: Alaska’s deepest trouble is nonsupport of education

People are exiting The Great Land and are reluctant to come here… Continue reading

The studio model of Starship “Enterprise” from Star Trek is on display at The Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum on its reopening on Oct. 14, 2022, in Washington, DC. (Photo by Alex Wong/Getty Images)
Opinion: No Alaska governor has ever so boldly held schools and students as political hostages

“Star Trek” reference looks past real argument for school funding.

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Black-and-white view of Gaza goes too far

Alexander Dolitsky’s letter rebuffing Dixie Belcher’s attempt to humanize the tragedy unfolding… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: Murkowski and Sullivan should oppose Trump

The New York Times reported Saturday that Mr. Trump said, “some migrants… Continue reading

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Letter: If you see roadside rubbish, please pick it up

I met a young Tlingit lady and her friend this weekend, picking… Continue reading

Looking up at the 1882 Edward Webster House on Telephone Hill from Second Street and Main Street in January 2024. (Photo by Laurie Craig)
Opinion: Juneau Assembly holds firm on Telephone Hill development

In a rare moment of near unanimity during a special Assembly meeting… Continue reading