• Overcast
  • 46°
    Overcast
http://sealaska.com
  • Comment

Catholic Church changes stance toward homeless

Posted: November 21, 2012 - 1:04am

ANCHORAGE — Parishioners at a Catholic church in downtown Anchorage were taken by surprise at mass on Sunday morning.

They were expecting to hear a homily, but instead the pastor of Holy Family Cathedral set it aside to talk about how the homeless, who frequent the church’s property, have become a safety threat.

After years of being tolerant of the homeless, offering them sandwiches and allowing them to come inside and warm up, Father Anthony Patalano’s Sunday message signals a sharp change in direction.

Patalano spoke of the church’s longtime service to the those who live on the streets — from serving them sandwiches to being instrumental in creating the Brother Francis Shelter, Beans Caf√©, Clare House and Covenant House — all programs that serve the homeless. He also said the parish has allowed alcoholics and disturbed people to come on the church grounds, in order to offer assistance.

But the pastor said times have changed.

“The current situation with the alcoholics and the disturbed is far worse than we have experienced in the past. The level of drinking, camping, gathering in groups and disturbances is past the point of toleration. It endangers our safety and inhibits people from coming to our parish,” Patalano said.

He also told parishioners he was physically attacked, as well as other two priests. He also spoke of sex acts and drug deals going down on church property — and frustrations over bathrooms being left a mess and the homeless relieving themselves outside.

Ed O’Neill, a parishioner who has long been involved in the battle to keep homeless inebriates off city streets, said he supports the priest.

“He’s on the front line, and he knows best,” said O’Neill. “Unfortunately I wasn’t aware of how serious it was until I heard that announcement.

O’Neill also is head of ARBRA - Anchorage Responsible Beverage Association, which cleans up homeless camps, a problem he said seems to be improving. He said ARBRA will be working on what it can do to help the church.

O’Neill said he hopes the church doesn’t go through with plans to fence off the grounds and put security there all the time. But he said he recently saw a symptom of the problem, when a woman disrupted mass.

“And she had to be ushered out of there. I don’t know what her issues were, but I think it probably had a lot to do with intoxication,” O’Neill said. “It happens a lot to restaurateurs and businesses all around Anchorage.”

The pastor laid out new rules on Sunday that specifically forbid drugs, drug dealing, alcohol, intoxication or sexual activity on church property. Also, restroom use is now limited to parishioners. Church grounds will be closed from 10 p.m. until 6 a.m.

Just a block away at City Hall, John Martin was serving soup in tin cans to the homeless. Martin is one of Anchorage’s highest profile homeless men. For a year-and-a-half, he’s come to city hall almost every day to protest Mayor Dan Sullivan’s policies on the homeless, which include removing illegal camps set up in the city.

Sullivan said in a statement that he’s asked that routine patrols be conducted of church property. Police also will be helping the church address safety issues, he said.

Martin was sympathetic to the church.

“I get that. They’re having to deal with the mess. They’re having to deal with the violence,” he said.

He said a homeless camp might cut down on many of the problems.

Martin said he himself has spent nights sleeping under the Holy Family Cathedral’s church steps, though these days he’s living in the woods.

  • Comment

Comments (12)

Add comment
ADVISORY: Users are solely responsible for opinions they post here and for following agreed-upon rules of civility. Posts and comments do not reflect the views of this site. Posts and comments are automatically checked for inappropriate language, but readers might find some comments offensive or inaccurate. If you believe a comment violates our rules, click the "Flag as offensive" link below the comment.
Latitude58
14470
Points
Latitude58 11/21/12 - 07:50 am
4
2

This just seems to be getting worse

Maybe it's the reporting or just my impression, but there seem to be more homeless chronic inebriates than there were just ten years ago. Is that in fact true?

If so, why? Were they always there and are now concentrating in the cities due to hard times in the villages? Or are the overall numbers increasing?

Compassion is a good thing, and as a rich and enlightened society we need to care for our most vulnerable members. But as the church is discovering, compassion alone can't solve this problem, and in some ways worsens it.

If we keep ignoring it...it won't go away. What to do?

Raininak
1653
Points
Raininak 11/21/12 - 07:54 am
1
6

WWJD

WWJD? Those darn lepers!

Latitude58
14470
Points
Latitude58 11/21/12 - 08:39 am
2
3

I guess...

...he'd turn water into (fortified) wine.

onder
415
Points
onder 11/21/12 - 03:14 pm
2
6

Church?

If the churches could only practice what they preach they might find themselves more accepted than they are currently. Maybe they don't want to have anything to do with a person that can not contribute to the bowl as it goes around.

onder
415
Points
onder 11/21/12 - 03:15 pm
0
0

?

?

lvmykyk
1805
Points
lvmykyk 11/21/12 - 04:23 pm
3
1

Name ONE secular institution

that has done as much for the homeless and downtrodden, as faith based programs. Just ONE, because I cannot think of a single one that does as much as the faith community does. I may be over looking some, I really might. Salvation Army, St Vincent De Paul both faith supported entities here in Juneau, their support reaches farther than the Glory Hole. Glory Hole is partnered with Northern Lights Church to provide a shelter for adult students. That is just here in Juneau. Why did the government try tapping into and supporting faith base programs? Because those programs already existed and there was no need to reinvent the wheel. If a secular program were to form and start providing the same level of service as the faith base programs, then maybe the faith bashing might be tollerable. But to bash the church for doing something you and your cultural community do not...... At least they have tried, and for longer than a holiday season.

wolfmagic2012
2686
Points
wolfmagic2012 11/21/12 - 04:44 pm
4
1

The Catholics have...

many problems, as do other sects, however, giving to and assisting the poor and homeless is not one of those problems. The Catholics by their example, shame the right-wing fundamentalists, who seem to have conveniently forgotten the exhortations of the Master Jesus. I applaud the efforts of the Catholic churches on behalf of the homeless and disadvantaged. You would be amazed at all the good accomplished by the Catholic Community Services right here in Juneau.

wolfmagic2012
2686
Points
wolfmagic2012 11/21/12 - 04:54 pm
3
1

We will always have...

the homeless and poor. Always. At least until Utopia or Heaven is realized on Earth. The object isn't necessarily to fix it - it is to always be there, alleviating the suffering. There will always be those who are unwilling or unable to pull themselves up, and who will always take advantage of the generosity of others, but by always displaying the example of genuine caring and giving, there are so very many who are able and who do come out of poverty and addiction and troubled minds - purely because of the example set before them by others. Look at Mother Theresa. It's not so much a matter of "Why" or "What can we do?" It's more a matter of consistency, and an attitude of service to others. "Just keep doing it."

MikeDziuba
734
Points
MikeDziuba 11/21/12 - 09:42 pm
1
1

Bigger is better when it comes to charity?

Is that the argument/logic you want to defend? Fine, let's go there.

So, by that logic Hamas (a terrorist organization according to the US, EU, Canada, Japan) is superior to Doctors without Borders because Hamas is affiliated with Union of Good (a group of about 50 Islamic charities), while Doctors Without Borders only has two surgeons helping in the West Bank?

For that matter, the US Govt. is the largest charitable giver in the world and guess what, it is a secular institution by law.

So stop the nonsense by implying that charity is better when it's bigger. Charity is charity and it shouldn't be used as a rhetorical weapon for shallow political points. There are plenty of secular organizations in Juneau and throughout the world that do one thing very well: they do good for goodness sake.

Those with no strings attached or without seedy, otherworldly aspirations, should be treasured. And are.

Here are a few:

1. Doctors Without Borders
2. Engineers Without Borders
3. Union of Concerned Scientists
4. Kiva
5. Oxfam
6. United Nations Children's Fund
7. Amnesty International
8. Rotary
9. DonorsChoose
10. Red Cross

Mike

Colorado14er
2433
Points
Colorado14er 11/22/12 - 01:05 am
0
0

I too applaud the Catholic

I too applaud the Catholic Church's assistance to the poor and homeless. They do an immense amount of good. I also support the Holy Family Cathedral's right to take steps to protect their property and the safety of people on that property. Unfortunate, but necessary.

Making a negative or sarcastic comment about churches or religious people, when the subject is the protection of property and safety of people on that property, is petty and pointless.

JustMe
123
Points
JustMe 11/22/12 - 09:00 am
0
0

I commend the work that this

I commend the work that this church has done to be tolerant and helpful to the homeless, and I do understand the Christian desire to help those in need.

But (there had to be a but) these folks are not just poor people down on the luck. They are drunks, pill addicted, illegal drug addicted, mentally ill. Addicts do not live by the same set of rules that the rest of us do. They will (and do) use, lie, steal, cheat and use violence to get whatever they want. They don't live by the same set of rules or standards that govern law-abiding society. The end result of that reality is what this church is facing now.

So what to do with these people? A question difficult enough that those with more training in these things than I do, have no idea aside from giving them more access to more stuff (shelter, food, money). My feeling (as hurtful as it may sound) is that most of these homeless people have family "somewhere". Those that do, should be shipped off to their family members and become THEIR responsibility. That won't solve the entire problem but there will be fewer to deal with at the societal level.

As long as we continue to give the homeless free stuff they will keep taking free stuff. As long as we continue to enable the homeless they will continue to live as they are and they will continue to drain resources (including time, money and the giving spirit of those trying to help). As long as we continue to give without placing expectations in return, more and more homeless will continue to move here. I have heard homeless people in Juneau talking - they moved here from California because of the very ample amount of "stuff" (tangible and service related) that they can receive.

We're not helping the homeless by what we're doing now. We're enabling their continued inappropriate behavior. And we're all feeling better about ourselves because of our "help".

Latitude58
14470
Points
Latitude58 11/22/12 - 09:27 am
0
0

@justme

Not clear who you're talking about when you say "homeless". The drunks and addicts? Or people who are homeless for other reasons? Or are you stating that ALL homeless are drunks and addicts?

Are you suggesting that families should be legally and financially responsible for adult family members? So if your Uncle Ernie becomes a drunk on the streets and moves to Juneau, you should have to take him in and support him? That will require some pretty radical adjustments in our laws, perhaps even a Constitutional amendment. As nice as it sounds, I don't see that one flying.

Note that the article is about Anchorage, not Juneau. And a lot of these people are sleeping in the woods and under stairs...in Anchorage...in November. Seems unlikely that someone's going to move from California for that life.

There are people that are exploiting the system and there are people that truly need help and compassion. How to sort them out is the first problem.

Back to Top

Spotted

Please Note: You may have disabled JavaScript and/or CSS. Although this news content will be accessible, certain functionality is unavailable.

Skip to News

« back

next »

  • title http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376863/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/359852/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376858/
  • title http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376853/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376843/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/368637/
  • title http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376838/ http://spotted.juneauempire.com/galleries/376833/
Fire Academy Graduation

CONTACT US

  • Switchboard: 907-586-3740
  • Circulation and Delivery: 907-586-3740
  • Newsroom Fax: 907-586-3028
  • Business Fax: 907-586-9097
  • Accounts Receivable: 907-523-2270
  • View the Staff Directory
  • or Send feedback

ADVERTISING

SUBSCRIBER SERVICES

SOCIAL NETWORKING