Allowing school districts to adopt a four-day school week would hand off local control over education and give districts another tool to address families’ needs in rural areas, proponents of House Bill 21 told the House Education Committee Friday morning.
Reps. Peggy Wilson, R-Wrangell, and Tammie Wilson, R-North Pole, who introduced the bill, testified before the committee to make the case for their bill, which would authorize a three-year pilot program for one interested school district that would allow schools within that district to adopt a four-day school week, provided school communities supported the idea of doing so.
“Now, this pilot program will be very helpful to some schools,” said Peggy Wilson. “It allows time for students, parents and teachers to do subsistence gathering, allows time for teachers for professional development without loss of student-teacher contact hours, allows students to work if necessary to help their family, and it allows time for teachers, parents and students to get to medical — you know, in the rural areas, sometimes it takes three days to get to medical appointments and whatnot and get back.”
Tammie Wilson framed the bill as the state government’s opportunity to contribute to the education reform many legislators and state officials have said schools must implement.
“If we’re asking school districts to think outside the box, we have to be willing to do it as well,” Tammie Wilson said.
Reps. Dan Saddler, R-Eagle River, and Paul Seaton, R-Homer, asked whether changing to a four-day school week could affect bargaining agreements with school staff.
“In this particular instance, the teachers are going to go five days,” Peggy Wilson replied. “And the teachers are agreeing to this.”
Tammie Wilson compared the bill to “school choice” measures that have been proposed by other legislators, including Rep. Lynn Gattis, R-Wasilla, chairwoman of the committee, who has sponsored a bill to allow nonprofit organizations and other unelected entities to operate charter schools.
“This bill gives choice,” said Tammie Wilson. “It gives choice to a school district.”
Saddler, the most inquisitive committee member throughout the meeting, asked whether schools within whichever school district is selected for the pilot program could keep a five-day school week if they so choose.
“What the bill does is give them the option of four days,” Tammie Wilson said. “They could absolutely do five. … It’s about local control and the community and what they see fit.”
A few members of the public testified over the phone. Among them was Southeast Island School District Superintendent Lauren Burch, whose district unsuccessfully applied with the Alaska Department of Education and Early Development to adopt a four-day school week last year. The district’s efforts to switch over to a four-day school week spurred Peggy Wilson, who represents the area, and Tammie Wilson to prefile H.B. 21 last month.
“We have overwhelming support for it,” Burch said of the four-day school week proposal. He said the district estimates it could increase attendance by 20 percent if students no longer had to attend class Fridays.
“We won’t save any money on it,” Burch added. “We will offer opportunities on those Fridays for kids that are behind on things or have individual challenges.”
Fridays will also be used for professional development time for teachers, Burch told the committee. He also said at least one school in the district voted against having a four-day school week at a public meeting last year and said its choice would be respected, while adding, “I kind of expect those sites to come around to that a little bit at a time.”
Rep. Pete Higgins, R-Fairbanks, attended the meeting despite not sitting on the Education Committee. He said he thinks the pilot program in H.B. 21 should be broader, ensuring that if the Southeast Island School District is interested and other districts are as well, they would not be in competition for the opportunity.
"I think we should be able to open this up to all the districts instead of just one district," Higgins said. "Then you could actually compare the pilot programs and see how it’s working."
Tammie Wilson said she is not opposed to allowing more than one school district to pilot a four-day school week, and Peggy Wilson indicated she agrees. The sponsors also noted, however, that the DEED already has the power to authorize a four-day school week if the commissioner signs off on it.
Although Gattis said at the beginning of the committee meeting that she intended to see H.B. 21 moved out of the Education Committee on Friday and another bill was scheduled to be heard at the meeting, she called an at-ease an hour into the meeting so committee members could attend a House majority caucus press conference.
Gattis said the at-ease was supposed to last 20 minutes, but almost one hour elapsed before legislators returned and gaveled the meeting back into session.
After apologizing for the longer-than-anticipated break, Gattis said the meeting had run out of time and adjourned before further testimony or motions on H.B. 21 could be offered.
• Contact reporter Mark D. Miller at 586-1821 or at mark.d.miller@juneauempire.com.




Comments (14)
Add commentReally??
Leave for press conference then come back late and apologize while stating time had run out and adjourning testimony? Sounds like some legis were tired of hearing testimony...way to listen to constituents.
I hope this goes through. I
I hope this goes through. I don't know if a 4 day optional 5th day school week would be better or worse...and neither do any posters here after. After three years I'd be very interested to see some results and experience. I really like that they are picking one district and allowing the schools to decide. I'm sure each school will have some meetings, get public opinion and then vote on it.
I don't feel this is a huge piece of legislation but its better then anything produced so far.
I as a parent like the idea - comments...
1. May be a challenge to parents who currently work a M-F 5-day workweek Will Rally still operate on Fridays?
2. Should cut down on school bus costs and energy costs significantly over the year
3. Could cut down on Substitute Teacher costs over the year
To me, this is an example of trying to work smarter not harder and trying to keep costs down. This is an example of initiatives that I believe instills trust in the public for their government...
trying to problem solve instead of relying solely on money or of whining and complaining all the time. kudos to these two legislators for starting the conversation!!!
"There is no school equal to a decent home and no teacher equal to a virtuous parent.." Ghandi
considerations
In a smaller school district it is fairly common for a majority of the HS students to be traveling on Friday for some activity. That reason has been put forth many times in an effort to try a four day school week. When say 12 of 15 students are traveling what the value of holding school for the 3 left behind?
I can see a balance where say elementary students have a five day week and the remaining students are on a four day week. The school district should be able to determine what is best for their students.
Idle Hands
One day a week parents and teachers will be at work, but the kids will be on their own. This sounds like an open invitation to trouble-making. This is a solution in search of a problem.
School isn't a continent day
School isn't a continent day care.
Questions and Comments
Interesting concept....especially since I was raised in the bush, and spent years living a subsistence lifestyle as a kid. This does bring questions.....I don't remember many, if any, 3 day hunts or trips to fishing camp. These trips were more like a week or more, and these trips occurred in the summer and the fall, not the middle of winter. But what concerns me more is.....will this eliminate the teachers in-service days, since now they will have an in-service day every week? Or will in-service days be continued so there are fewer actual days spent teaching? Will this "day off" cause the school year to run longer, or will this day of doing little, if anything, be considered a school day?
Currently, our graduation rate is abysmal, our educational system is ranked among the lowest, and we spend a higher dollar amount per student, compared to other districts around the nation.
We need to take steps to improve the education level of our students. Currently our educational system has been dumbed down to the point that we are no longer competitive. I think what needs to change is the culture surrounding our educational system, and education in general. We, as parents, need to be supportive of education, and ensure our kids put in their study time at home. We, as parents, need to provide a home environment that places a high level of importance on our kids getting a quality education so they can grow up to be successful. These, in my humble opinion, are the changes that are needed……not more money thrown at the schools, not four day school weeks, but parents taking responsibility to ensure their children get the very best!
The dumbing down of Juneau
I think it's a terrible idea, What other nations are having their two young people go to school for seven days a week 12 hours a day. Their countries are turning out brilliant scientist, surgeons, Computer programmers etc. What are we going to produce McDonald's workers Gardiners snow shovelers.
Their children got summer vacation during the depression so they could work in the fields. We don't work our children in the fields anymore. Child labor laws and all that. I think they should go to school longer than five days a week and certainly longer than six hours a day
Just my two cents
4 day
school week? Friday will be video game day and time to eat more chips, wow. Somebody get the the dunc cap out and put the fool who came up with that idea in the corner.
Yeah what are these
These are educators, teachers. People who went to school and then went to college and made a plan to dedicate their lives to educate children. The track is it'll make enough money I drive by the school lot after school very nice cars parked in the parking not. To get three months a year off. My child is grown and graduated I really don't know why I care about this, I do I want America to produce smart, Talented, Brilliant geniuses. Like most the rest of the world does.
Just a rant I guess.
I was taught school was a
I was taught school was a job. Be there on time and do the work. What does a 4 day school week say to kids?
Maybe
4 12 hour days, It's a compromise.
Yeah I really don't see this thing going very far.
Long days at school. I
Long days at school. I thought research pointed to later start times for kids worked better.
Long days at school. I
Long days at school. I thought research pointed to later start times for kids worked better.
This bill allows family minors to play an active role in
subsistence harvesting (not unlike the farmbelt in winter?) while granting credited teachers an additional day per week to further hone one's teaching skills.
Sorry, I thought they came with it.
Perhaps if the student carried his/her homework aboard the skiff I could see it. But to shorten the school year on behalf of rural subsistence gathering?
This is a tough sell.