Top officials from the Alaska Association of School Boards testified Monday afternoon in front of two senators on a subcommittee delegated by the Senate Finance Committee to work on the Alaska Department of Education and Early Development’s budget, describing the goals of a four-year initiative to provide all of Alaska’s students and teachers with tablet computers.
The “1 to 1 Initiative,” as the AASB has dubbed it, would see roughly $200 per student spent every year — with 40 percent of that cost coming from school districts and 60 percent being provided by the state — to have full participation by the fourth year of the program.
As AASB Executive Director Carl Rose and AASB Consortium for Digital Learning Director Bob Whicker described it, “cohorts” of roughly 32,250 users — each representing one-quarter of all K-12 public school students in the state — would be brought into the initiative each year.
“The issue here is engagement,” Rose said. “Kids today, they live in a different world. They multitask. They need their information rapidly. It’s difficult for them to sit in line, sit in a chair and take a lecture.”
Gov. Sean Parnell has already shown interest in the project, proposing $5.9 million for the digitization of education in his operating budget proposal for fiscal year 2014 that would include the approximately $3.9 million that AASB officials say will be needed from the state for the first year of the 1 to 1 Initiative. Parnell touted that prospective investment in the speech he made in December to the Anchorage Chamber of Commerce unveiling his proposed budget.
However, the House Finance subcommittee on the DEED budget proposed deep cuts to the amended budget Parnell submitted to the Alaska State Legislature, including more than halving the $5.9 million for digitized education — down to $2.61 million.
Sen. Berta Gardner, D-Anchorage, noted the House subcommittee’s reduction.
“Given the budget adjustments that were made in the House Education budget subcommittee and that might very well go through … do you see a way to start maybe at half the speed you anticipate, take eight years to reach, and how would that affect the per-student cost?” Gardner asked.
Rose sounded doubtful.
“This is a scalable initiative,” said Rose. “It’s been field-tested. And it is a doable thing. … Eight years is a long time to sustain a project. I’m trying to think of all the legislators who aren’t here who were here eight years ago, right, and the same in our schools. We have a lot of turnover, and I think the time to strike is now.”
Gardner asked if the equipment lease pricing offered by Apple Inc. and other prospective vendors was “dependent on ‘X’ number of units per year.
“And would that change significantly if we didn’t implement at that rate?” Gardner asked.
Rose reiterated his belief that the state should move quickly to implement the digital learning initiative.
“I can’t speak for the vendor, but I will tell you this,” said Rose. “I can see some probability in four years as an investor. I don’t know if I see the same probability and promise for eight years. What you’re talking about here is a four-year promise. I can deal with a four-year promise. As an investor, I don’t think I can deal with an eight-year promise.”
Rose added, “There is a sense of urgency here. If we’re going to change our classrooms, it can’t take eight years to do it.”
A large part of the 1 to 1 Initiative, as proposed, is “professional development” — training teachers how to effectively use tablet devices for educational purposes.
Rose and Whicker suggested schools that are interested in being early adopters will provide a model for the rest of the state.
“I can’t tell you how school districts will do it,” said Rose. “But the ones who want to start will show us the way, and the others will follow.”
“Personally, I’ve been neck-deep in this for a decade, and we’ve thought and thought and thought this through, and I really believe that we are ready to roll that out on the scale that we’re talking about,” Whicker said.
While Apple is involved in the project and other potential vendors like Dell Inc. have yet to sign on, school districts will not be required to use Apple products, according to Rose.
“When you look here, you’re going to see Apple all over this thing,” Rose told the senators. “And so the next question you should be asking is, you know, ‘Is this going to be a sole-source operation?’ And I guarantee you it’s not. … We believe in local control, and we want people to have the latitude to go and make whatever decisions they want to make.”
In response to a question from Sen. Mike Dunleavy, R-Wasilla, chairman of the subcommittee, about what opposition the initiative might face, Rose said the AASB has been hampered by not getting enough information out to the public. He also asked the senators not to embrace the idea of Apple being the initiative’s sole vendor, saying again he wants to allow “local control” over what products schools adopt.
A foreign university is among the other AASB Consortium for Digital Learning partners mentioned in Rose and Whicker’s presentation.
“We have gotten a lot of attention from people that have been paying attention,” said Whicker. “And that means internationally, also. The University of Auckland in New Zealand is very interested because of our aboriginal languages and the role that they play within it.”
Rose said the interest from the University of Auckland prompted the University of Alaska to get involved with the initiative as well.
The process of finalizing the FY14 operating budget is ongoing in both the House of Representatives and the Senate.
The House Finance Committee adopted its subcommittees’ findings into a committee substitute for Parnell’s budget last week. It is expected to consider budget amendments this week.
Meanwhile, Senate Finance subcommittees are preparing to close out their sections of the budget and bring their recommendations back to the full Finance Committee for review.
• Contact reporter Mark D. Miller at 586-1821 or at mark.d.miller@juneauempire.com.





Comments (21)
Add commentNew library?
So cutting edge Juneau is stuck building a new new library we truly do not need and cannot afford??? The idea of buying every kid in Juneau a Kindle was floated out there two years ago as a more cost effective education solution for our youth, but the Friends of Library lobbied and organized the campaign to bury us in more debt.
Next on Juneaus list of wasteful spending, the Whale! Mayor Bruce and pals behind that boondoggle have to be driving over the same potholes we can't afford to fix, but the Arts are so important and Skip needs a million dollar paycheck.
Crazy!
It's inevitable
Learning is going digital. It already has. The Age of Paper is over, especially for children. Let's get on with it.
But one thing from Mr. Rose's comments stuck out with me: “Kids today, they live in a different world. They multitask. They need their information rapidly. It’s difficult for them to sit in line, sit in a chair and take a lecture.”
Yeah, and that's a problem. The pace of information input has certainly changed. It's gone from a trickle or stream to a deluge, a tsunami. We all experience it every day when we get 87 gazillion Google search responses. Then have the idiot box on all day long bombarding the house with rapid-fire marketing to go along with the cell phone texts...
Information technology has evolved. Human brains haven't. Our kids need space to learn serenity. Learn how to turn off the noise, to focus, to think and concentrate on a single subject for a sustained period of time. When are they getting that? When are they allowed to unplug?
And Notta, I tend to agree with you regarding the Library - maybe we need a Community Center more than a library, at a much lower cost. As far as your rant about the whale, get a clue, it's privately funded, fool.
Apple all over again...
This seems to me to just like the Apple computer scheme. Put them in every school, teach the kiddies how to use them and then send them out into the work place to discover that Microsoft Windows is the dominate system and all of its supported software. To finally end up with young people not really as prepared as they could have been.
Are we really going to do this again? Do any of you see businesses using tablets to run their day to day operations.
This yet another example of spending money to spend money.
AK, almost the entire medical
AK, almost the entire medical profession is using tablets. Besides, Apple has gotten with the times and can run most widows applications to, as I understand it. I am still mired in the Windows world, so I cannot speak with absolute certainty, but as far as I know, they can do everything a PC can do.
No no no no
Just no.
fools
fool, littledude5.8 the libary we're stuck with & now you want a community center.
It is difficult
...for them to sit and take a lecture? Ha, that is just laughable. Go ahead and make your students more brain-dead and then you WILL fail as teachers altogether. They won't survive college if they can't sit and listen. What a joke.
I have a cousin in Cali
...who seriously believes that google is all-knowing so he literally bases his life on it. He believes Google has converted him whereas I debated and said, "LIFE converted me." Man, get your kids some books and READ it to them! Ask them what the story was about and you may be surprised how much effective an imagination really is than Google is.
I love books
I, for one, love a good book. The tactile feel and smell is great, but the reality is that books are a dying media. Barns and Noble and Borders have gone away. College text books are more and more being offered digitally. I agree that we can't let the kids loose on the internet to use google and wikipedia as their sole source options, but digital texts are going to happen. (Wanna bet no current students know what a card catalog or dewie decimal system is?).
The reality is that the education system needs to properly guide the students in the technology use (parents should help as well).
PC vs Mac (doesn't matter really) it is all the same internet.
AKjust-us
Seems to me that the FedEX and UPS guys have been using tablets for many years now.
You could give kids laptops but they're a lot more expensive and they'd get trashed the first time chocolate milk got spilled in the keyboard. A tablet could be build cheap and nearly kid-proof. Also much easier to learn intuitively.
Regarding your Microsoft vs Apple rant, in case you haven't noticed (and you haven't), Microsoft invents almost nothing for the desktop level. They simply wait until Apple invents it, then they copy it. So if your kid is learning Apple stuff, they're generally about three years ahead of what the corporate world will be rolling out on the desktop.
"A large part of the 1 to 1
"A large part of the 1 to 1 Initiative, as proposed, is “professional development” — training teachers how to effectively use tablet devices for educational purposes."
Bingo - that right there sums up the whole "Initiative". And Mr. Rose, just how large is that "part"?
And how many additional layers of administration is this "Initiative" going to require?
Cha-ching - union dues ---> political influence.
This line is funny too - "We believe in local control, and we want people to have the latitude to go and make whatever decisions they want to make.”
Since when? The marching orders always come from the higher ups.
Since I'm banned from posting "live links(!)", read this - "The Association of Alaska School Boards is the Alaska state chapter of the National School Boards Association, a government sector lobbying association."
Member dues collected in 2007 were around $2M for this organization. Their website reads like the talking points of the progressives regarding No Child Left Behind, vouchers, early childhood education, etc.
And according to an article last month in the Alaska Dispatch, Apple has four lobbyists in town this session!
You decide if you like this "Initiative".
Calypso Post the information
Calypso
Post the information about oil lobbying that I know your aware of. I find it laughable that your trust people that live in other country's that compete with American companies that's sole purpose is to make money over people that are trying to evolve the education system into current times.
4 lobbyists? How many does bp have in town now? 2 for EVERY member of our legislation?
Your party of 'pick & choose' is becoming more transparent and its just revealing the disfunction and chaos that it truly has become.
stu - I'm totally transparent
stu - I'm totally transparent with my ideology. Right now I have to "choose" the Republican party because there are only two choices. I'm not hiding a thing.
And yeah, I'm fed up with the billions of dollars this country funnels into the education system with nothing but pathetic results. I'm not alone either. Maybe you're the one that needs to look outside your progressive bubble and see what others are saying.
Thank goodness for oil lobbyists. You must know that natural resources, of all kinds, are what keeps Alaska afloat. It's certainly not the education system that pays the state's bills.
All you'll hear from that "industry" is a giant sucking sound.
Slack 58
Do your research before you call others fools.. CBJ is donating the land, maintenance, and likely head tax dollars for Nimbus II, the Whale, so to me that ain't private donations Dude
Am I so wrong to want my children to pick up a book?
I think that the act of reading a book should be encouraged in all schools. I love that my daughter values her book collection and uses her creativity to make cute little book marks. I just don't see why the school district should discourage a little good old fashioned reading. Too much technology is making our kids lazy. There was a huge problem in the JSD several years ago where students were stealing the MacBooks and selling them for drugs. Tablets should be a possession that is bought by parents. It's a privilege and they should be recreational. While I don't think that tablets are a horrible invention, I do think as a parent that I prefer my child bringing home a book from the library and learning the respect and knowledge that comes with doing so.
I'm also the mother of a toddler. She may enjoy playing with my smart phone but when it comes time to read to her, there is something special about choosing our books for story time. I couldn't imagine that reading Goodnight Moon would be even a fraction as special if I was reading it from a tablet. Just a bad idea all around.
@ Calypso
I am wondering where you found your information regarding this Association's revenues?
Cool. What games will come with it?
What movies and games come with it? They can even use the pad to watch sporting events instead of PE class.
What they REALLY need...
...is a Big Chief tablet and a No. 2 pencil. Multi-tasking is another name for not paying attention. It's bad enough that formative minds sit in front of screens in their off time. But to provide them all with their own one-eyed monster for their study time is counter-productive. No wonder ADD is so prevalent in the public schools. They cultivate it.
ldm76 - I found the revenue
ldm76 -
I found the revenue numbers for the National School Boards Association at sunshinereview.org.
They're not very transparent and it's hard to find any current numbers. This organization and all the state associations under them are non profits and are layer upon layer of tax payer funded education lobbying groups that exist solely to promote an agenda and influence politicians.
2010 revenues for the Association of Alaska School Boards were $3.5M. Guidestar.org has their IRS form 990 but you'll have to create an account to look at it.
"The Association of Alaska School Boards (“AASB”) represents 53 school boards and 330 individual school board members in Alaska. AASB collects approximately 30% of AASB’s budget from a public source – membership dues for individual members paid for by each member’s respective public school district. The remainder of AASB’s budget comes from grant funding or payment for the services it provides, such as superintendent searches or policy development
work."
Yeah, you guys are right.
Yeah, you guys are right. Learning to harness technology is such a horrible thing. Why back in my day we used pencils and paper books. It was so special to curl up next to the oil lamp and scribble in the book, and if you needed you could use them in the outhouse! Yeah all this technology is so overrated...