SEATTLE - Airbus topped Boeing both in the number of planes produced and in the total of new orders last year, but the U.S. company prevailed in perhaps the most important tally: the actual money received for airplanes delivered to customers.
Whether calculated on list prices or on more realistic data using standard sales discounts, Boeing's deliveries were worth about $4 billion more than Airbus's.
Airbus said Tuesday that it won 271 net orders versus Boeing's 142, and delivered a company record 498 airplanes compared to Boeing's 481. The European plane-maker's executives also conceded serious problems with the A380 superjumbo jet program and with the money-draining A400M military cargo plane.
Orders and deliveries are the numbers that get the most attention, but from a business perspective, the value of deliveries is key.
According to data from aircraft valuation firm Avitas, after standard sales discounts the Boeing jets delivered in 2009 were worth an estimated $32.8 billion.
Airbus' 2009 deliveries were worth an estimated $28.4 billion.
Despite delivering 17 fewer airplanes, Boeing produced a more valuable mix: Airbus's output of the more expensive large jets didn't match Boeing's 777 production line in Everett.
Airbus rolled out only 20 of its larger-sized wide-bodies: only 10 from the moribund A340 program and another 10 from the A380 superjumbo program, which has slowed to a crawl because of production issues.
In contrast, Boeing rolled out 88 of its expensive large wide-body 777s in 2009, a record pace.