CBJ settles lawsuit with Gastineau Apartment owners

Apartments were demolished in 2016

The Gastineau Apartments, before it was torn down. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

The Gastineau Apartments, before it was torn down. (Michael Penn | Juneau Empire File)

The City and Borough of Juneau is getting some of its money back.

On Thursday, the city announced by email that it has reached a $1.5 million settlement with the former owners of the Gastineau Apartments, Kathleen and James Barrett.

That Franklin Street housing complex, desolated by a 2012 fire, was condemned and dormant for four years until the City and Borough of Juneau demolished it as a public nuisance. In the years between the fire and its demolition, the Gastineau Apartments were invaded by vagrants and caught fire a second time. An engineer’s assessment concluded the building’s facade was in danger of collapsing into Franklin Street.

After the demolition, the CBJ began court proceedings to recoup the cost of demolition. In June, Judge Philip Pallenberg ruled the city was correct to tear down the complex, but the issue of repayment was not settled.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

The CBJ continued court proceedings against the Barretts, and a trial was set to begin Aug. 13. Thursday’s deal precludes that trial.

The city had been seeking $1.585 million, enough to cover the entire cost of demolition. By email, city manager Rorie Watt said the $1.5 million figure did “concede a bit” but also means the city doesn’t have to go through the risks of a trial, including any potential appeals.

It was not immediately clear how much the city spent on legal fees in pursuing restitution.

According to court documents, the deal calls for the Barretts to repay the city in installments. The first payment, $100,000, is due within 10 business days. Another $300,000 payment is due by Aug. 1 next year. The entire cost must be paid before Dec. 31, 2020, but the Barretts will pay interest unless they pay it all before Aug. 2, 2019.

James Barrett has been the target of enormous public opprobrium, and the deal contains a clause that requires Kathleen Barrett to evict James Barrett from his home at 401 Harris Street and forfeit any ownership interest in that property.

“The CBJ recognizes that 401 Harris Street has been associated with substantial calls for law enforcement services and security concerns for more than 60 people who live or work nearby,” the deal states.

The Barretts own other property in Juneau, including the site of the Gastineau Apartments, a lot at 329 Harris Street, the Bergmann Hotel, and two houses on Fourth Street. If any of those properties are sold, the proceeds will go into a trust account to repay the debt owed the CBJ.

If the Barretts fall short of their payment schedule, the CBJ may seize and sell their properties in town.

“This settlement is the end of a long struggle and it creates the path for redevelopment of these downtown properties,” Watt said in a city press release. “CBJ is glad to put this issue behind us.”

More in Home

A Juneau School District maintenance supervisor examines the ceiling at Riverbend Elementary School on Friday, Aug. 21, 2020. The school, since renamed Kax̲dig̲oowu Héen Elementary School, has experienced roof problems since its construction, according to district officials. (Peter Segall / Juneau Empire file photo)
Juneau’s school board approves project lists for proposed voter bond at $5M, $10M and $15M levels

Roof, heating, ventilation and security prioritized as Assembly considers bond items for fall election.

Debris from a home that partially fell into the Mendenhall River due to a record glacial outburst flood remains on the riverbank on Sunday, Aug. 6, 2023. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Trump executive order seeks to block states and municipalities from enforcing their climate policies

Order could affect everything from recently enacted state carbon laws to Juneau’s renewable energy goals.

President Donald Trump announced yet another abrupt change in economic policy on Wednesday. (Eric Lee / The New York Times)
Trump backs down by reducing many reciprocal tariffs for 90 days, but hikes China’s to 125%

Universal 10% levy remains for other countries; change comes after tailspin in global markets.

A preliminary design shows a park at Aak’w Landing, the cultural and arts center, and a cruise ship in port at Huna Totem’s private dock. (Courtesy of Huna Totem)
Assembly OKs Aak’w Landing tideland lease based on its goal of better managing tourism

Huna Totem says the dock is expected to be operational by the 2027 visitor season.

The Red Chris Mine, a gold and copper mine, seen several years ago after it began to operate in late 2014. (Garth Lenz / Salmon State)
Report cites growing environmental risks at Red Chris Mine in Stikine watershed

Seepage of contaminants at site 130 miles northeast of Wrangell reported by Canadian environmental group.

Students swing on a playground at Meadow Lakes Head Start in Wasilla, Alaska. It closed in 2024 due to funding and staffing challenges. (Image by Lela Seiler, courtesy of CCS Early Learning)
Alaska Head Start programs in limbo after regional office closed by U.S. Health Secretary Kennedy

Tribal programs such as Tlingit and Haida’s not affected by closures.

Alaska House Speaker Bryce Edgmon, I-Dillingham, speaks at a House majority news conference, April 8, 2025, in the Alaska State Capitol in Juneau. Rep. Chuck Kopp, R-Anchorage; Rep. Andy Josephson, D-Anchorage; Edgmon; and Rep. Louise Stutes, R-Kodiak, are seated left to right. (Photo by Corinne Smith/Alaska Beacon)
Alaska lawmakers are divided over state budget, stuck without agreement over dividend, schools

House majority leaders appeal to GOP minority, Gov. Dunleavy for agreement on spending plan.

Quentin O’Domin attempts a 100-inch two-foot high kick during the Traditional Games on Sunday at Juneau-Douglas High School: Yadaa.at Kalé. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Mindsets and methods matter more than muscles for some medalists at Traditional Games

More than 250 competitors young and old test ancient Iñupiaq skills at three-day Juneau event.

The Alaska Youth Choir sings the official state song during its traditional appearance to open the 50th Alaska Folk Festival on Monday night at Centennial Hall. (Mark Sabbatini)
50th Folk Festival opens with longtime, long-absent, new and other performers

Weeklong festival adheres to tradition, but revisits many of its past moments with tales and tunes.

Most Read