The Fairbanks Four — Marvin Roberts, left to right, Kevin Pease, Eugene Vent, and George Frese — hold up four fingers, symbolizing the Fairbanks Four, in the David Salmon Tribal Hall after they were freed in December 2015 in Fairbanks. (Rachel D’Oro | The Associated Press file)

The Fairbanks Four — Marvin Roberts, left to right, Kevin Pease, Eugene Vent, and George Frese — hold up four fingers, symbolizing the Fairbanks Four, in the David Salmon Tribal Hall after they were freed in December 2015 in Fairbanks. (Rachel D’Oro | The Associated Press file)

Federal judge dismisses Fairbanks Four lawsuit

Freed men had sought compensation from Fairbanks, law enforcement

A federal judge ruled against the Fairbanks Four in an opinion issued Monday, dismissing their efforts to seek compensation from the city of Fairbanks and law enforcement.

In his opinion, judge Hezekiah Russel Holland found Marvin Roberts, George Frese, Kevin Pease and Eugene Vent did not have a case strong enough to overcome a settlement agreement they signed with the city of Fairbanks and State of Alaska as a condition of their release from prison.

“Obviously we’re disappointed and we’re going to appeal the decision to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals,” said Michael Kramer, the attorney for the four men.

Matthew Singer, representing the city of Fairbanks, said he believes the court correctly applied U.S. Supreme Court precedent and that the Ninth Circuit will see the case the same way that Holland does.

Monday’s decision was the latest legal battle for Roberts, Frese, Pease and Vent, who in 1997 were convicted of murdering John Hartman in Fairbanks. Hartman was white, the four men were not. After their conviction, there were widespread protests and suggestions that the Fairbanks Police Department had targeted the four men despite evidence indicating another suspect.

Those suggestions led to a campaign that asked the state to reopen the case against the four men. In 2015, a five-week hearing showed significant evidence that someone else had killed Hartman. Soon afterward, the city of Fairbanks and State of Alaska offered a settlement agreement to the four men: they could go free with charges dropped as long as they agreed to not seek claims against the city or state.

The four men signed the agreement, and they were freed from prison eight days before Christmas in 2015.

Two years later, Kramer (initially representing just Roberts and later all four men) filed suit in federal court, alleging that the city violated their civil rights and that the agreement was the result of coercion, therefore invalid.

Holland, citing prior case law, disagreed with that argument. Instead, he found that the men are unable to bring claims against the city because their original conviction was not declared “invalid,” such as when a case is overturned on appeal.

“In fact, the parties’ stipulation expressly provided ‘that the original jury verdicts and judgements of conviction were properly and validly entered based on proof beyond a reasonable doubt,’” Holland wrote.

In other words, the four men already agreed that they were cleared based on new evidence, not on old evidence deliberately concealed.

Kramer had sought a jury trial which might award cash compensation to the four, but by phone Tuesday he said the case is about justice for four men who were wrongfully convicted.

“We want to achieve justice and we just want the opportunity to put it in a jury’s hands to decide whether Fairbanks police acted properly or improperly in creating the case against them,” he said. “The case is not over. It’s been an uphill battle from Day 1 when the Fairbanks Four were first targeted as suspects by the (Fairbanks Police Department), and 20 years later, unfortunately, they’re still trying to achieve justice.”


• Contact reporter James Brooks at jbrooks@juneauempire.com or 523-2258.


More in Home

Media members and other observers gather at the Alaska Division of Elections office on Wednesday evening as the results of all ballots, including ranked choice tabulations, were announced. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Ranked choice voting repeal fails by 0.2%, Begich defeats Peltola 51.3%-48.7% on final day of counting

Tally released Wednesday night remains unofficial until Nov. 30 certification.

Current senior Kerra Baxter (22) shoots a free throw for now defunct Thunder Mountain High School in last season’s ASAA state championship 4th/6th place game against the Mountain City Christian Academy Lions. Baxter has signed to play Division II college basketball with the University of Alaska Anchorage Seawolves. Baxter will play for Juneau-Douglas High School: Yadaa.at Kalé this season. (Klas Stolpe / Juneau Empire)
Kerra Baxter signs to play for UAA Seawolves

Twin tower elects to stay in state and close to home fan base

Looking through the dining room and reception area to the front door. The table will be covered with holiday treats during the afternoon open house. The Stickley slide table, when several extensions are added, provides comfortable seating for 22 dinner guests. (Laurie Craig / Juneau Empire)
The Governor’s House: Welcoming Alaskans for more than 100 years

Mansion has seen many updates to please occupants, but piano bought with first funds still playable.

Glacier Swim Club members, left-to-right, Cora Soboleff, Clara Van Kirk, Natalie MacKinnon, Ellie Higgins, Leon Ward, coach Lisa Jones, Zach Holden, Josh Ely and Henry Thatcher during the 2024 November Rain swim meet at Petersburg last weekend. (Photo courtesy Glacier Swim Club)
Glacier Swim Club competes at Petersburg’s November Rain

Juneau’s Glacier Swim Club participated in the November Rain Invitational swim meet… Continue reading

A butter clam. Butter clams are found from the Aleutian Islands to the California coast. They are known to retain algal toxins longer than other species of shellfish. (Photo provided by the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife)
Among butter clams, which pose toxin dangers to Alaska harvesters, size matters, study indicates

Higher concentrations found in bigger specimens, UAS researchers find of clams on beaches near Juneau.

An aerial view of people standing near destroyed and damaged buildings in the aftermath of Hurricane Helene flooding on Oct. 8, 2024 in Bat Cave, North Carolina. (Mario Tama/Getty Images)
Members of U.S. Senate back disaster aid request amid increasing storm severity

WASHINGTON — The Biden administration’s request for nearly $100 billion in natural… Continue reading

The language of Ballot Measure 2 appears on Alaska’s 2024 absentee ballots. The measure would repeal the states open primary and ranked choice voting system. (Andrew Kitchenman/Alaska Beacon)
Count tightens to 45-vote margin for repealing Alaska’s ranked choice system going into final day

State Division of Elections scheduled to conduct final tally at 5 p.m. Wednesday.

Juneau Assembly members confer with city administrative leaders about details of a proposed resolution asking the state for more alcohol licenses during an Assembly meeting Monday night. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Petition seeking one-third expansion of alcohol-serving establishments gets Assembly OK

Request to state would allow 31 licensees in Juneau instead of 23; Assembly rejects increase to 43.

The drive-through of the Mendenhall Valley branch of True North Federal Credit Union, seen on June 13, is where a man was laying down when he was fatally struck by a truck during the early morning hours of June 1. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police: Driver of CBJ truck not at fault in death of man struck in drive-through lane of bank

Victim laying on pavement during early-morning incident in June couldn’t be seen in time, JPD chief says.

Most Read