Alaska? Nope, the author on a guided trip on a river in Montana in June 2017. (Jeff Lund | For the Juneau Empire)

Alaska? Nope, the author on a guided trip on a river in Montana in June 2017. (Jeff Lund | For the Juneau Empire)

Friend and foe?

As hunters and anglers, we are allies and enemies.

There was an article in the Bozeman Chronicle Sunday about fishing pressure on the Madison River in Montana, a river I can’t wait to visit this summer.

You know, do the tourism thing, be another one of those out-of-staters crowding out the locals on their home water…

Anyway, a 54-mile section of the river took 180,000 angler days in 2017. “Angler days” is different than individual anglers. A dude who fishes there twice won’t be counted twice, but both his days go toward the total. Of the 180,000 days sustained, 69 percent of them were from out-of-staters.

That’s a lot, and I was one of them. There weren’t people everywhere, but there could have been people anywhere, around any bend. Sounds familiar.

Things have calmed considerably since summer, but with limited daylight to make frigid skiff trips to cold rivers to chase feisty steelhead, the discussion and summer planning seasons are underway.

What happened this summer and what does that mean going forward? The weather was warm, the rivers low, the tourists plentiful. Some salmon returns were epic, others anemic.

What if the winter is a light one and instead of a solid snowpack, we get rain? I’m not one to get excited about driving to work in the dark, through six inches of fresh snow, but I also don’t want fish to cook in low rivers during August.

I was thinking deeply about the 2019 salmon bonanza and that article one dark night, (4:13 p.m. and I know, Fairbanks folk…) and I wondered how long can southeast Alaska keep this up – not only supplying for the locals, but also for guests. Not that there is an alternative because lodge and charter operations are livelihoods, and who am I to say, “Hey, guy, you should shut down because you have too many boats. Find another job so I can fish in peace.”

I was also thinking about how I hope Montana manages its resources well because on cold, windy days like today, the thought of casting hoppers to brown trout with a 5-weight in the warm sun, sounds just about perfect.

My annual trout trip outside is always a highlight and for the local guy from Ennis, Montana, who wakes up early and finds me in his spot, fishing it diligently, but incorrectly, I almost feel bad. Not bad enough to move, but I do get it. I’m planning for Montana now. He might be planning for Alaska. It’s only fair, I guess, that if a month after I ruin his (or her) program on his river, I should find him on my river, at my spot (that is not mine at all) I’d shrug and move on rather than shake my fist.

I guess that’s the funny thing about inviting people to share in what we enjoy as Alaskans, we might as well, because we can’t exactly keep it a secret. So, what do we do? Like it or not, southeast Alaska needs tourists by the ship, boat, skiff and plane loads. We also want and need fish for the freezer.

As hunters and anglers, we are allies and enemies, getting in the way of each other when we try to catch trout for fun, salmon and deer for food, but banding together to protect the rights of each other.


• Jeff Lund is a writer and teacher based in Ketchikan. “I Went To The Woods,” a reference to Henry David Thoreau, appears in Outdoors twice a month.


More in Home

The city of Wrangell, where a landslide on Nov. 20, 2023, killed six people including a family of five. (City and Borough of Wrangell photo)
Wrangell residents gather to remember landslide victims on one-year anniversary

“We want you to know that we have noticed the incredible heart of this community.”

Alaska Supreme Court Justices Susan M. Carney and Peter Maassen are seen on Feb. 8, 2024, in Juneau. (James Brooks/Alaska Beacon)
Susan M. Carney to serve as Alaska Supreme Court chief justice

Alaska’s five Supreme Court justices have voted to make Justice Susan M.… Continue reading

President Donald Trump and Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy pose for a photo aboard Air Force One during a stopover at Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson in Anchorage in 2019. (Sheila Craighead / White House photo)
With virtually all of the top Trump spots filled, Dunleavy says he’s staying as governor

Governor, who has two years remaining in his second term, makes announcement on talk radio Monday

The village of Kake on Kupreanof Island. (Alaska Department of Commerce, Community and Economic Development photo)
Group of residents and a flock of frozen turkeys catch catamaran to Kake in time for Thanksgiving

Hosts of community celebrations on boat Tuesday after weekend ferry mishap strands them in Juneau.

Juneau-Douglas High School: Yadaa.at Kalé freshman Joshua Beedle pins Sitka High’s JD Keith in the 112-pound division Friday at the Sitka Invitational. (James Poulson / The Daily Sitka Sentinel)
Crimson Bears grapplers swarm The Rock

JDHS wrestlers second to Mt. Edgecumbe at Sitka Invitational.

Ann Stepetin (left) and Marion Dau (center) talk to Pauline Duncan about her woven aprons and other items for sale at the Indigenous Artists and Vendors Holiday Market on Friday, Nov. 24, 2023 at Elizabeth Peratrovich Hall. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Juneau Public Market expected to be biggest since 2019 — and online shoppers can start browsing now

41st annual three-day event starts Friday, along with Indigenous Artists and Vendors Holiday Market.

Ranked choice votes in Alaska’s U.S. House race are tallied Wednesday, Nov. 20, at the state Division of Election’s office. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Recount of defeated ranked choice repeal ballot measure faces long odds — but has an ardent attorney

Lawyer for other “election integrity” efforts argued Supreme Court should overturn Trump’s 2020 defeat.

Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo
The Hubbard state ferry docks at the Alaska Marine Highway System terminal in Auke Bay on Monday, June 26.
Break in Kake’s ferry dock mooring fouls Thanksgiving plans for dozens of people stranded in Juneau

Ship loaded with vehicles and food forced back to Juneau after wind damage to village’s dock Saturday.

Spawning sockeye salmon returning from Bristol Bay swim in 2013 in Lake Clark National Park and Preserve’s Tazimina Lake. Sockeye salmon, also known as red salmon, accounted for about two-thirds of the value to commercial fishers of this year’s total Alaska salmon catch. (D. Young/National Park Service)
Alaska’s total commercial salmon harvest this year was ultra-low in both quantity and value

State: Number of fish harvested third lowest since 1985, value to fishers third lowest since 1975.

Most Read