Opinion: New study shouldn’t revive fluoridation in Juneau

Opinion: New study shouldn’t revive fluoridation in Juneau

Let’s focus instead on good nutrition, proper dental hygeine.

While fluoridation of the municipal water supply in Juneau has been a dead issue since it was resoundingly defeated in a 2007 referendum, a recent study reported in the Empire and elsewhere has resurrected it. This study found an increase in the number of dental carie (cavity) procedures in Juneau Medicaid recipients under 7 years of age in 2012 as opposed to 2003. It found no statistically significant increase in the number of procedures in older children.

Even the authors admit this study is limited in scope, since it covers only two single years, nine years apart. It fails to account for any other factors besides fluoridation that might have contributed to an increase in carie treatment under Medicaid. Most notably, the measure of tooth decay in the study was Medicaid reimbursement rates and procedures, yet the study made no attempt to account for changes in Medicaid coverage between the two years. This is huge.

It is entirely possible that the increase in dental carie procedures was not due to more cavities from lack of fluoride, but to more aggressive treatment of borderline cases that may not have been treated previously. If Medicaid increased their reimbursement rates or made it easier for dentists to obtain Medicaid reimbursements, then dentists might bill more treatments to Medicaid.

[Opinion: Ending Juneau’s water fluoride program was a mistake]

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

The paper admits changes in reimbursement rates when it notes: “According to retired State Dental Chief Dr. Whistler … Medicaid made adjustments in the form of increases for dental claims CDT codes in 2009 and 2010, which may have resulted in Medicaid reimbursement increases even without the provision of more services.”

Remember this study is not measuring the actual amount of tooth decay, but the number and cost of dental caries procedures reimbursed under Medicaid. The failure to account for the impact of changes in Medicaid reimbursement seriously undermines the study’s results and conclusions.

Whatever you think about this or any study, the discussion about fluoridation in Juneau was never solely about potential benefits of putting fluoride in the water. It was about weighing those benefits against the potential risks, especially to specific subsets of the population, such as infants and the elderly.

It was about whether the water supply is the best way to administer fluoride, given that its benefit is primarily topical and fluoride toothpaste and gels are universally available to those who want them. And it was about the public’s right to choose whether to ingest fluoride, since the municipal water supply belongs to all of us and we all have a right to clean drinking water.

[Opinion: 53 packs of tortillas]

If fluoride was some utterly benign substance that impacted only teeth, it would be one thing. It isn’t. There is credible research indicating fluoride is a neurotoxin that impacts the developing brains of fetuses and infants. It can affect the thyroid gland in doses close to those recommended in fluoridated water. Research shows it can cause arthritic symptoms and bone fractures. There is a reason every tube of fluoride toothpaste sold in this country has a poison warning label that starts by saying “do not swallow.”

In 2007 there was robust debate about all these issues. Fluoridation proponents spent more than $160,000 to make their case, outspending opponents 20-1. The public was not convinced. The proposition was overwhelmingly rejected 61-37 percent.

This recent study was newsworthy, mostly because it was about our own town. However, given the study’s serious limitations and the fact that Juneau thoroughly considered the issue and came to a clear conclusion, it is unlikely that an attempt to resurrect fluoridation is in the cards — nor should it be.

Let’s focus instead on those things we agree improve dental health: good nutrition, proper dental hygiene, sealants and fluoride treatments when appropriate. We can encourage education and adoption of these proven measures in our homes and in our schools, and leave the issue of fluoridating Juneau’s water in its grave where it belongs.


• David Ottoson is a resident of Juneau. My Turns and Letters to the Editor represent the view of the author, not the view of the Juneau Empire.


More in Home

2022 Juneau-Douglas High School: Yadaa.at Kalé graduate Brooke Sanford (5) reacts with teammates during a Regis University Rangers home volleyball match this season in Denver, Colorado. (Regis photo courtesy Makayla Salter)
Former JDHS volleyball star Brooke Sanford discusses college adjustments

Local 2022 graduate takes game to higher court while pursuing education degree in Colorado.

An empty classroom at Juneau-Douglas High School: Yadaa.at Kalé. Juneau is one of four districts federal education officials said was underfunded by the state during the COVID-19 pandemic. (Lisa Phu/Alaska Beacon)
Four Alaska school districts, including Juneau, move on without federally promised money

$17.5M pandemic funding dispute wth state ends; Juneau wasn’t counting on its $90K share.

A firefighter carries a hose toward a Mendenhall Valley house still experiencing flareups hours after a fire started early Saturday morning. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
JPD: Fire that destroyed home deliberately set by man who died from cause ‘not related to the fire’

Relative suffered life-threatening burns reentering house trying to find man, according to police.

Juneau-Douglas High School: Yadaa.at Kalé hockey players and Bartlett High School hockey players work for a puck during the Crimson Bears 10-6 win over the Golden Bears Saturday at the Treadwell Ice Arena. (Klas Stolpe / Juneau Empire file photo)
ASAA concerned incident in JDHS hockey game not reported

Visiting Bartlett High School player had to be restrained and escorted from ice.

Hundreds of residents and cruise ship passengers visit the Juneau Maritime Festival at Elizabeth Peratrovich Plaza on Saturday, May 4, 2024. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Juneau’s younger population dropping fast, older residents increasing rapidly, latest state count shows

8.3% drop in residents under 35 between 2020 and 2024, 21% increase in residents 65 and older.

(Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Suspicious package in mail leads to drug bust at downtown hotel

$42,700 of suspected illegal drugs and more than $2,000 in cash seized, JPD reports.

Village of Wrangell (Ḵaachx̱aana.áakʼw in Tlingit) in 1868 on present day Front Street. (Photo by Eadward Muybridge)
Plans taking shape for Saturday’s Army apology for 1869 bombardment of Wrangell

Program starts by retracing steps of Shx’atoo, the Tlingit man hanged by Army after the 1869 attack.

An aerial shows the footprint of the test well drilled in the mid-1980s on land owned by the Kaktovik Native village corporation within the 1002 area of the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Trump wants oil drilling in Alaska. A lease sale in ANWR just flopped.

No bidders for 400,000 acres offered; some Alaska officials said Biden actions ensured failure

A long line of residents pick up groceries at the Southeast Alaska Food Bank on Aug. 20, 2022. (Jonson Kuhn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Lawsuits for backlogged public assistance programs result in mandatory monthly progress reports by state

Alaska agrees to such reports for cash assistance after judge orders similar requirement for food stamps.

Most Read

You're browsing in private mode.
Please sign in or subscribe to continue reading articles in this mode.

Juneau Empire relies on subscription revenue to provide local content for our readers.

Subscribe

Already a subscriber? Please sign in