A sculpture of Constantine the Great by Philip Jackson in York. (Public domain photo republished under a Creative Commons license)

A sculpture of Constantine the Great by Philip Jackson in York. (Public domain photo republished under a Creative Commons license)

Living and Growing: Christianity or Churchianity?

Several cruise ship passengers arriving in Juneau this September were greeted on the dock with a sign that asked a religious question: “Why Aren’t Christians More Like Jesus?” Why indeed?

Having read widely as an amateur theologian, I have concluded that what Jesus started as a spiritual movement, Christianity, has often degenerated into various forms of bureaucratic religiosity, churchianity. To state the obvious, if church-goers do not have becoming more like Jesus as a personal goal, it is unlikely that they will make any progress in that direction.

Further, religious institutions that do not have similar spiritual goals can lose sight of their purpose. Who can dispute, for example, that the Vatican lost track of its identity when it allowed pedophile priests to continue their criminal abuse of unsuspecting families and their children?

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

If you need details on this systemic problem, read the Boston Globe’s investigative report in book form, “Betrayal, The Crisis in the Catholic Church.” If you prefer a DVD version, check out the Blu-Ray edition of “Spotlight” which features an interview with the actual reporters who did the hard work exposing patterns of criminal abuse later detected by others worldwide. Both versions are available via Juneau’s Public Library and its statewide partners. I own and cherish both.

Aside from the value of investigative journalism, the theological question remains: how did it happen? It appears that Rome’s spiritual shepherds forgot their sheep, all those innocents who were taught to depend on their church to dispense anything related to God. While Christ condemned those who would harm children, (see Matt 18:6, Mark 9:42, & Luke 17:2), the Roman Catholic Church put institutional interests ahead of individuals. Jesus did not matter.

This conflict of interests illustrates the root problem of churchianity: Christ’s messages get lost. Jesus ends up as a ceremonial mascot or icon designed to attract members rather than being treated as Lord and Master, as in the original spiritual movement known as Christianity.

Lest readers think I am just beating up on the Vatican, I overheard at one church conference, “We Protestants are more Catholic than we like to admit.” The churchianity problem is an ecumenical indictment; other faith tribes who think they are immune are deluding themselves.

Just as Scripture needs to be discussed in context, so does the history of modern Christianity. Revisiting history does not mean it should be revised to make it more palatable to current sensitivities. Rather, looking back to the past is important for understanding where we have been.

Constantine the Great, the fourth-century Roman Emperor, had a major impact on the Christian religion. Prior to his reign, Christianity was illegal and persecuted, but it then became the official religion of the Roman Empire.

It is difficult to exaggerate the significance of this Constantinian shift as a relatively new religion moved from persecuted to privileged. Earlier converts to Christ risked their lives; in contrast, those who joined the church after its governmental acceptance faced no such trials. Before Constantine, Christians could be killed for their belief; later, those who did not convert could be killed for their unbelief.

Earlier, faith involved personal transformation within an intimate spiritual community. After Constantine, Christianity became a structured institution with creeds, clergy, and canon. Gradual transition to the state church changed the character of what had been apostolic practice.

After the Constantinian shift, this religion’s organizational focus shifted from personal deeds to gatekeeper creeds along with other systematized rituals.

While the Protestant Reformation tried to deal with some unfortunate aspects of Christianity’s legacy organization, over time, the problem recurred: Jesus got lost.

At Judgment, God will determine whether churchianity or Christianity prevails, but I urge believing readers to consider what Jesus said (Matt 7:21-29), especially verses 24 and 26:

“…everyone who hears these words of mine and puts them into practice is like a wise man who built his house on the rock.”

“But everyone who hears these words of mine and does not put them into practice is like a foolish man who built his house on sand.”

Heed the warning in Revelation chapters 2 and 3:

“He who has an ear, let him hear what the Spirit says to the churches.”

• Mike Clemens has previously written columns in this space headlined “Twisting Scripture to suit themselves” and “Rethinking Hell?” “Living and Growing” is a weekly column written by different authors and submitted by local clergy and spiritual leaders. It appears every Saturday on the Juneau Empire’s Faith page.

More in Neighbors

Braised carrots with garlic and thyme, freshly cooked. (Photo by Patty Schied)
Cooking For Pleasure: Braised carrots with garlic and thyme

When I was growing up, my parents never, ever served cooked carrots… Continue reading

On a nice day it’s always safe to talk about the weather. (City and Borough of Juneau photo)
Gimme A Smile: What to say when you’ve got nothing to say

It could happen, right? Despite your very best efforts, you could find… Continue reading

A black bear sow and her cub walk along the Trail of Time at the Mendenhall Glacier Visitor Center. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Living and Growing: The bear

The folks of Southeast Alaska are fortunate in that we sometimes experience… Continue reading

Laura Rorem is a member of The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. (Courtesy photo)
Living and Growing: Practicing true patience

“Have patience, have patience, Don’t be in such a hurry, When you… Continue reading

Just-baked cinnamon rolls ready to serve. (Photo by Patty Schied)
Cooking For Pleasure: Easy cinnamon rolls

My father really loved cinnamon rolls. In his later years I would… Continue reading

The Rev. Tim Harrison is the senior pastor at Chapel by the Lake. (Courtesy photo)
Living and Growing: The numbers tell the story

I love numbers and math. One of my first career aspirations was… Continue reading

Page Bridges of Holy Trinity Episcopal Church in Juneau. (Photo courtesy of Page Bridges)
Living and Growing: Spiritual self defense

True spiritual power is quiet, under the radar. One beautiful thing about… Continue reading

A bowl of gumbo. (Photo by Patty Schied)
Cooking For Pleasure: Shrimp gumbo for Mardi Gras

I love gumbo. Several years ago I was lucky enough to go… Continue reading

Nuns wait for a seating area to be opened before a recitation of the rosary for Pope Francis’ health at St. Peter’s Square in Vatican City, on Monday night, Feb. 24, 2025. (James Hill/The New York Times)
Living and Growing: Let us journey together in hope

Friends, we are a little over a week away from the beginning… Continue reading

Fresh rainwater sits on top of the ice at Auke Lake. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Gimme A Smile: Looking for spring in all the wrong places

Is it spring yet? Is it spring yet? We’re through Valentine’s Day,… Continue reading

Tari Stage-Harvey is the pastor of Shepherd of the Valley Lutheran Church. (Photo courtesy of Tari Stage-Harvey)
Living and Growing: Seeing is believing

Christians are nearing the time of Lent, 40 days of repentance and… Continue reading

Cooked Chinese-style fried rice. (Photo by Patty Schied)
Cooking for Pleasure: Chinese-style fried rice

At most of the Chinese restaurants I’ve eaten at over the years,… Continue reading