On the Trails: Mutual bonds

Mutually beneficial relationships (a type of symbiosis, which just means “living together”) are common under the aegis of Mother Nature. Some obvious ones are bees and hummingbirds getting nectar from flowers while moving pollen from plant to plant, and robins and bears eating fruits and excreting, and thus dispersing, viable seeds. There are many other mutualisms too, but there is a not-obvious one that is and has been fundamentally important to most of the plants on earth.

Many kinds of fungi form close, mutually beneficial, relationships with plant roots, obtaining some carbohydrates from the plant while transferring phosphorus and other nutrients from the soil to the plants. These are the mycorrhizal (“fungus-root”) relationships (between the roots of plants and the underground filaments of the fungus) that have often been mentioned in the essays in this space. Many local species of fungus (including, for example, the Amanita mushroom) participate in such relationships. Experiments have shown the benefits of these relationships to the plant partners; the benefit to the fungi is not always clear, but many of these fungi cannot live without their plant partners. It has been estimated that at least 80 percent of all plants are involved with mycorrhizal partners.

Beyond the critical ecological importance of present-day mycorrhizal mutualisms, however, lies an important historical and evolutionary perspective: Researchers have good evidence that the first green plants to colonize the land — a few hundred million years ago — had some kind of close fungal associate. This relationship was not technically mycorrhizal, because the first land plants (derived from freshwater green algae) did not have proper roots, but it was, nevertheless, a close physiological association of fungus with plant. Fungi invaded land well before the green plants did, and must have been adept at foraging for nutrients in the poor soils that then prevailed. So they were there, perhaps availing themselves first of exudates from the photosynthetic plants and eventually drawing nutrition directly from the plants themselves and providing soil nutrients in exchange. If those researchers are right, then all the great diversity of plants we see around us was made possible in the beginning by a mutualism.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

All of this raises a big question in my head: If fungal partners have been so important historically and so many kinds of current-day plants have such fungal partners, then why are there a number of plants that do not have these partners? For example, mosses are reported to lack fungal partners, although their cousins, the liverworts and hornworts often have them. Examples of non-mycorrhizal plants in our local flora include starworts, paintbrushes, louseworts, sundews, lupines, sweetgale, mistletoes, many members of the mustard family, and numerous others. A look at that abbreviated list tells us that one way to thrive without a fungal partner is to have another means of supplementing nutrition: Many of the non-mycorrhizal plants are insectivorous (sundews), or at least partly parasitic (paintbrush, louseworts, mistletoe), or harbor nitrogen-fixing bacteria (lupines, sweetgale). In addition, some plants-without-fungal-partners have extraordinary roots (the so-called cluster-roots of some lupines, for instance) that give the plant a huge amount of root surface for taking up nutrients. All those ways of supplementing plant nutrition may account for some of the species that lack a fungal partner, but not all, so the question is only partly answered.

By definition, mutualisms involve some reciprocity between participants. But it is not uncommon for the balance to favor one partner more than the other. In fact, there are hundreds of examples of relationships in which one participant simply exploits the other, giving nothing back — what was probably once mutualistic has become exploitative. For instance, orchids produce seeds that require a mycorrhiza for germination, but because the seed contains no food stores for the embryo, the fungi get little or nothing; the orchids apparently control the relationship by chemically attracting the fungal filaments. Some orchids (such as the coralroots) lack green leaves altogether and are totally dependent on their fungi, without reciprocating: The plant gets both nutrients and carbohydrates from the fungus, which draws such sustenance from the soil or other plants. The two-sided arrangement has become one-sided. Undoubtedly there are instances in which the fungus gets one-sided benefits too, and this may have been the case very early in the evolution of the land plants.

In some cases, the relationships are still more complex. Some plants require “companion plants” to support their mycorrhizae, so there are three participants in the relationship. For example, certain Australian Lobelias require the presence of mycorrhizas associated with broombush (Melaleuca uncinata) in order to germinate. Some species in the gentian family (such as centaury, Centaurium) develop full mycorrhizal associations only when certain other plants (such as clover, Trifolium) are present, too.

Some plants have very specific requirements as to what fungus makes a good partner. Many orchids are fussy this way. And when plants are introduced to new countries, as the pines have been to the southern hemisphere and eucalypts have been to the northern hemisphere, they may not grow well unless their own particular mycorrhizae are moved with them. The local varieties of fungus won’t do.

In contrast, garlic mustard is a useful herb in the Old World that grows without harm to other plants, with which it coevolved. But when introduced to North America, it became a highly invasive weed, in large part because it kills or damages the plant/fungus partnerships that prevail here, so the native species fail to thrive.

• Mary F. Willson is a retired professor of ecology.

More in Neighbors

Sabrina Donnellan and her family attend a community luncheon for federal employees at Shepherd of the Valley Lutheran Church on Saturday, March 8, 2025. (Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire file photo)
Living and Growing: Choose empathy during these difficult times

“It is your concern when your neighbor’s wall is on fire.” —… Continue reading

Braised carrots with garlic and thyme, freshly cooked. (Photo by Patty Schied)
Cooking For Pleasure: Braised carrots with garlic and thyme

When I was growing up, my parents never, ever served cooked carrots… Continue reading

On a nice day it’s always safe to talk about the weather. (City and Borough of Juneau photo)
Gimme A Smile: What to say when you’ve got nothing to say

It could happen, right? Despite your very best efforts, you could find… Continue reading

A black bear sow and her cub walk along the Trail of Time at the Mendenhall Glacier Visitor Center. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Living and Growing: The bear

The folks of Southeast Alaska are fortunate in that we sometimes experience… Continue reading

Laura Rorem is a member of The Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. (Courtesy photo)
Living and Growing: Practicing true patience

“Have patience, have patience, Don’t be in such a hurry, When you… Continue reading

Just-baked cinnamon rolls ready to serve. (Photo by Patty Schied)
Cooking For Pleasure: Easy cinnamon rolls

My father really loved cinnamon rolls. In his later years I would… Continue reading

The Rev. Tim Harrison is the senior pastor at Chapel by the Lake. (Courtesy photo)
Living and Growing: The numbers tell the story

I love numbers and math. One of my first career aspirations was… Continue reading

Page Bridges of Holy Trinity Episcopal Church in Juneau. (Photo courtesy of Page Bridges)
Living and Growing: Spiritual self defense

True spiritual power is quiet, under the radar. One beautiful thing about… Continue reading

A bowl of gumbo. (Photo by Patty Schied)
Cooking For Pleasure: Shrimp gumbo for Mardi Gras

I love gumbo. Several years ago I was lucky enough to go… Continue reading

Nuns wait for a seating area to be opened before a recitation of the rosary for Pope Francis’ health at St. Peter’s Square in Vatican City, on Monday night, Feb. 24, 2025. (James Hill/The New York Times)
Living and Growing: Let us journey together in hope

Friends, we are a little over a week away from the beginning… Continue reading

Fresh rainwater sits on top of the ice at Auke Lake. (Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Gimme A Smile: Looking for spring in all the wrong places

Is it spring yet? Is it spring yet? We’re through Valentine’s Day,… Continue reading

Tari Stage-Harvey is the pastor of Shepherd of the Valley Lutheran Church. (Photo courtesy of Tari Stage-Harvey)
Living and Growing: Seeing is believing

Christians are nearing the time of Lent, 40 days of repentance and… Continue reading