‘What’s for dessert?’: We want the sweet stuff and we want it now

‘What’s for dessert?’: We want the sweet stuff and we want it now

It’s the clarion call of children everywhere.

  • By PEGGY McKEE BARNHILL
  • Sunday, March 31, 2019 7:00am
  • Neighbors

“What’s for dessert?”

It’s the clarion call of children everywhere. Do you notice that they never ask, “What vegetable are we having for dinner tonight?” or “When are we ever going to have Brussels sprouts?” Nope. They all want info about the sweet stuff, and they want it now.

When I was a kid, dessert had to be earned. If I wanted dessert, I had to eat my vegetables first. That was the rule. When faced with a plate full of succotash or the dreaded broccoli, I really needed that info. My plaintive query, “What’s for dessert?” was a calculation, plain and simple. Did I really want dessert? Did I want it badly enough to eat those forlorn veggies? If dessert was nonexistent or uninspiring, like pudding or a piece of fruit masquerading as a sweet, I would simply say, “I’m full.”

But if we were having ice cream or chocolate cake with chocolate frosting, then I would choke down the succotash or somehow manage to swallow that broccoli. Those were the days that I wished for a dog. My friends could slip their vegetables to their dog under the table — why couldn’t I? Oh well, if we did have a dog, he probably wouldn’t have liked broccoli either.

[If you want to know someone better, talk about the weather]

My kids speak that phrase on a regular basis: “What’s for dessert?” More often than not, the answer is “nothing.” I consider I’ve done my bit if I manage to get supper on the table before 9 p.m. and include at least one fruit or vegetable. There might be a box of cookies on the hutch, or a tub of ice cream in the fridge, but the likelihood of me fixing a special dessert to finish off dinner is dismally low.

Birthdays are the notable exception. The deal is, on your birthday you get to name your dessert, be it cake, pie, chocolate mousse, whatever. It’s a tough deal to uphold.

First, there’s the family birthday dinner, usually something special, followed by the chosen dessert. Then there’s the party with friends, which requires an additional dessert. Even if the kid had a massive layer cake for the family birthday, with more than half of it uneaten, there is no way they would allow that leftover cake to be the centerpiece of the birthday party with friends. Second dessert, coming right up. Add on the cupcakes for school for young kids, and that’s a lot of dessert. Did I mention that we have birthday buddies in my house?

[Juneau Style: The capital city’s fashion blog]

My daughter was born on her dad’s birthday, resulting in not one but two pies for the family day (but still only one party with friends, thank goodness). With her brother’s birthday a mere six days later, our house is awash in desserts from the second week of November all the way to Thanksgiving, at which time the proper response to that all-important question is “pumpkin pie.” Moving on to Christmas cookies, Valentine’s candy and chocolate Easter eggs takes the pressure off. “What’s for dessert?” the kids ask. Mom’s stock answer: “Just go look in your candy bucket, there’s bound to be something.”

My favorite dessert to make is brownies. Yes, I use a mix. I like the mix. It tastes delicious, just the way brownies should taste — just like mom’s. Oh yeah, mom used the mix too. And why not? It’s fast, easy, and oh, so satisfying. My favorite dessert for someone else to make me is North Douglas chocolate cake with lots of frosting. If you’re a baker looking for an appreciative audience for your North Douglas chocolate cake, look no further. I’m your woman. I even make house calls.

Which is all to say that I’m having a serious chocolate craving right now, even without giving up chocolate for Lent. What’s for dessert? Alas, the chocolate birthday cake is history, and the Girl Scout cookies have all but disappeared. I’m munching on potato chips right now. Seriously.

What’s for dessert at your house? Can I come over?


• Peggy McKee Barnhill is a wife, mother and author who writes cozy mysteries under the pen name “Greta McKennan.” She likes to look at the bright side of life. Her column runs on the last Sunday of every month.


More in Neighbors

Hiking down from Dan Moller cabin in mid-January 2025. (photo courtesy John Harley)
Sustainable Alaska: Skiing on the edge

The difference between a great winter for skiing and a bad one can be a matter of a few degrees.

Jeff Lund photo 
The author practices in case he had the chance to be Jimmy from the 1986 movie Hoosiers. He never got the chance on the basketball floor, but had moments in life in which he needed to be clutch.
Opinion: Everyone wants to be Jimmy

Sports, and the movie “Hoosiers,” can teach you lessons in life

Laura Rorem (courtesy photo)
Living and Growing: Gracious, gentle power

Gracious power is grace expressed with kindness and mercy.

Juneau as pictured from the Downtown Public Library on Thursday, Dec. 19, 2025. (Mari Kanagy/Juneau Empire)
Weekly events guide: Juneau community calendar for Dec. 15-21

Visit Juneau Arts and Humanities Council at JAHC.org for more details on this week’s happenings.

Downtown Juneau experiences its first significant city-level snow fall of the season as pictured on Saturday, Dec. 6, 2025. (Mari Kanagy / Juneau Empire)
Weekend guide for Dec. 12-14

Visit Juneau Arts and Humanities Council at jahc.org for more details on this week’s happenings.

A totem pole, one of 13 on downtown’s Totem Pole Trail in Juneau, Alaska, Nov. 27, 2024. (Christopher S. Miller/The New York Times)
Peggy McKee Barnhill (Courtesy photo)
Gimme a smile: My roommate’s name is Siri

She hasn’t brought a lot of stuff into the house, and she takes up very little space.

photo courtesy Tim Harrison 
Rev. Tim Harrison is senior pastor at Chapel by the Lake.
Living and Growing: I Wonder as I Wander

The Rev. Tim Harrison reflects on the Christmas season.

Jeff Lund photo 
The author heard what he thought was a squirrel. It was not a squirrel.
I Went into the Woods: A change of plans

It was only a 30-hour trip but it’s always better to bring more food than you count on eating.

Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire file photo
Reverend Gordon Blue from the Church of the Holy Trinity gives an invocation at the Alaska Commercial Fishermen’s Memorial on Saturday, May 3, 2025.
Living and Growing: Psalm 30, Ouroboros, the dragon of fear and love.

Psalm 30:6 Weeping may spend the night, but joy comes in the… Continue reading

Shoppers and vendors mingle along rows of booths in the mall ballroom at Centennial Hall during the Juneau Public Market last year, which returns this year starting Friday, Nov. 28. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Cold water dipping is a centuries old stress reduction technique still practiced today. (Photo by Raven Hotch)
Recipes for stress reduction rooted in Indigenous knowledge

We must choose to live intentionally and learn to commit to our wellbeing.