The MV Kennicott, docked at the Auke Bay Ferry Terminal, was out of commission awaiting repairs on Friday, Oct. 23, 2020. Chairman of the Alaska Marine Highway Reshaping Workgroup Admiral Tom Barrett said the system’s inability to plan long-term was hindering its ability to be effective. (Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire)

The MV Kennicott, docked at the Auke Bay Ferry Terminal, was out of commission awaiting repairs on Friday, Oct. 23, 2020. Chairman of the Alaska Marine Highway Reshaping Workgroup Admiral Tom Barrett said the system’s inability to plan long-term was hindering its ability to be effective. (Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire)

AMHS needs ability to plan long-term, says reshaping group chairman

Ferry can’t plan year-to-year

The lack of a long-term planning and an unclear fiscal picture are two of the main challenges facing the Alaska Marine Highway System, Admiral Tom Barrett said Thursday to the Greater Juneau Chamber of Commerce.

Barrett is chairman of the AMH Reshaping Work Group which recently submitted its final report and list of recommendations to the governor’s office. Speaking to the chamber, he said the inability to plan over several years and the changing political environment that controls the system’s budget made it difficult for AMHS to build a reliable system amongst a changing transportation environment.

There was no multi-year budget process, Barrett said, but there were methods for future funding under state law. If money wasn’t available under the current fiscal circumstances, he said, then a multi-year fiscal plan should be made to at least provide AMHS with the ability to plan long term.

Barrett said many of the communities the group spoke to said they would accept less service if the system were more reliable, but there was no consensus on what essential ferry service was in many of the communities served by AMHS. The system was built when the state had more money, he said, and communities were added to the ferry even as air travel became more affordable and reliable.

“You have to consider where is the state as a whole? What level of service can you provide,” Barrett said. “This system was built when it was preferable to (travel by ferry) and there was money to do it.”

Several questions asked of Barrett following the speech had to do with next steps for AMHS and the group’s report. Barrett said the workgroup had submitted its recommendations to the Gov. Mike Dunleavy’s office and the administration would take the next step regarding the ferry system.

In an email, Dunleavy spokesperson Jeff Turner said the administration continues to review the recommendations put forth by the workgroup.

[Reshaping recommendations roil stakeholders]

But many of the ferry system’s stakeholders balked at the recommendations made by the workgroup and found fault with the group’s analysis. The workgroup used a report released in January from Northern Economics but that report was criticized by local lawmakers and others when it was released. Following the release of the workgroup’s recommendations, one of the lawmakers assigned to the group itself, state Rep. Louise Stutes, R-Kodiak, called the report “a little disappointing.”

The MV Kennicott is illuminated at night while docked at the Auke Bay Ferry Terminal on Thursday, Oct. 22, 2020. Chairman of the Alaska Marine Highway Reshaping Workgroup Admiral Tom Barrett said the system’s inability to plan long-term was hindering its ability to be effective. (Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire)

The MV Kennicott is illuminated at night while docked at the Auke Bay Ferry Terminal on Thursday, Oct. 22, 2020. Chairman of the Alaska Marine Highway Reshaping Workgroup Admiral Tom Barrett said the system’s inability to plan long-term was hindering its ability to be effective. (Ben Hohenstatt / Juneau Empire)

Renegotiating union contracts was another recommendation made by the group, Barrett said, noting labor representatives have seemed at least willing to discuss the matter in past conversations. But the workgroup’s report says labor costs make up 70% of the system’s cost, a number of labor representatives have said is an overestimation.

Perhaps most critical of the workgroup’s recommendations is the Alaska Municipal League, which said the study and others like it were based on what they called a “feedback loop” of negative information, where decisions and studies made about the ferry’s future are based on actions meant to diminish the system.

“What we see is this mutually reinforcing scenario, where decisions are taken in real time to diminish the system, while iterative planning processes for the longer term are based on the results of those ongoing decisions,” AML said in a letter to the governor about the workgroup’s recommendations.

“Thus, the current study is based on a system that is the result of negative impacts from past studies and decisions,” the letter continued. “Our baseline is lack of viability, and recommendations based on not how to improve the system but to stem the loss,” the letter said.

There us no way the ferry could currently exist without a state subsidy, Barrett said, and the system is not yet in a place where it could be divorced from politics or privatized and sold to a commercial operator.

Working with the governor’s administration, Barrett said he didn’t believe there was a desire to end the system entirely.

“I didn’t hear any of that at all,” Barrett said of notions the governor wanted to end the ferry system. “I think there’s an appreciation for the value of the system and a desire to reduce some of its cost.”

• Contact reporter Peter Segall at psegall@juneauempire.com. Follow him on Twitter at @SegallJnuEmpire.

More in News

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Aurora forecast through the week of Nov. 3

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

Nesbett Courthouse in downtown Anchorage on Oct. 7, 2024. (Yereth Rosen/Alaska Beacon)
After controversial correspondence school decision, Anchorage judge faces voters in election

Adolf Zeman is one of 19 judges on Alaska’s ballots, but he’s the only one with a campaign against him.

The outcome of the struggle for control of both the House and Senate will have sweeping implications for the country’s future. Shown is the U.S. Capitol on Oct. 9, 2024. (Jane Norman/States Newsroom)
Will control of Congress shift? The results hinge on a handful of states and races

Narrow Republican Senate majority would allow Murkowski to wield outsized influence, expert says.

A sign on Egan Drive reminds motorists at midday Friday a lower seasonal speed limit is in effect in an attempt to reduce collisions at the Fred Meyer intersection. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Reduced 45 mph speed limit goes into effect on Egan Drive in vicinity of Fred Meyer intersection

Change in effect until Jan. 31 intended to improve safety; JPD reports normal number of traffic stops.

People voting ahead of Election Day line up inside the Mendenhall Mall annex on Friday, Oct. 25. (Laurie Craig / Juneau Empire)
Juneau an afterthought for candidates ahead of Tuesday’s election, but early voting at a record pace

Toss-up U.S. House race, minimum wage increase, repeal of ranked choice voting on ballot.

Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo
Tesla Cox (left) explains the damage done to her home and possessions by record flooding Aug. 6 to a delegation of municipal, tribal and federal officials on Aug. 11. The City and Borough of Juneau is considering a memorandum of agreement with the Central Council Tlingit and Haida Indian Tribes of Alaska for public safety issues such as emergency response, plus a similar agreement involving solid waste operations.
City leaders, Tlingit and Haida considering operational pacts for public safety, solid waste

Assembly members Monday will also discuss flood barriers, short-term rentals, homeless.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police calls for Wednesday, Oct. 30, 2024

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

The Tongass National Forest near Sitka on Oct. 10, 2024. The remains of a hunter who the authorities believe was fatally mauled by a bear were recovered on Wednesday, Oct. 30, 2024, from a remote region in Alaska where such attacks are rare. (Christopher Miller/The New York Times)
Deer hunter is killed in apparent bear attack near Sitka, authorities say

The remains of a hunter who authorities believe was fatally mauled by… Continue reading

Most Read