Custody case goes before Supreme Court

Justices consider application of new law in rape case

Angelica Curtis and her son Jonathan are shown in this recent photograph. (Courtesy photo | Curtis family)

Angelica Curtis and her son Jonathan are shown in this recent photograph. (Courtesy photo | Curtis family)

A long-standing child custody case went before the Supreme Court on Thursday, as the justices considered how a law passed by the Legislature last year changes the case.

The case, Angelica Curtis v. Jonathan Chim, is about custody of a child conceived through statutory rape. Curtis was 13 and Chim was 19 when they were in a relationship and the child — whose name is also Jonathan — was conceived in June 2009.

The age of consent in Alaska is 16, and according to state law, a person 17 years old or older is committing sexual abuse of a minor if they have sex with someone who is 13, 14 or 15 and at least four years younger than them.

Both sides presented their arguments Thursday. Curtis (who is now 23) argued that in cases where a child is conceived during a sexual assault, the parental rights of the offender should be terminated. The defense is that parents have equal rights to custody and that a court cannot terminate one parent’s rights without a specific legal reason.

The case is far from simple, though, and brings up questions of whether a Legislature can determine the intent of a past Legislature.

The facts

The custody battle has been going for nearly a decade, according to previous reporting from the Empire. Chim currently has custody, and Curtis gets supervised visits, attorneys said in court Thursday.

About a year after Jonathan (who is now 8 years old) was born, Curtis was sent to the McLaughlin Youth Center for rifling cars. Chim, who was sentenced to three years for the statutory rape of Curtis, was still in Lemon Creek Correctional Center at the time, so Curtis’ parents applied for legal guardianship, the Empire reported in 2016.

To get guardianship, Curtis parents (Miles and Tonya) had to notify the biological father, Chim. That began the custody battle that has now made it all the way to the Supreme Court.

“It’s pretty much determined what we’ve had to do with our lives,” Miles Curtis said in a recent phone interview. “We actually had to move, me and my wife. We were basically raising the child, at least for the first six years of his life.”

The Curtis family and Chim’s family currently both live in Petersburg, attorneys said in court Thursday.

Angelica Curtis and her son Jonathan are shown in this recent photograph. (Courtesy photo | Curtis family)

Angelica Curtis and her son Jonathan are shown in this recent photograph. (Courtesy photo | Curtis family)

Thursday’s arguments

During his oral argument Thursday, Chim’s attorney Fred Triem argued that Curtis does not have her child’s best interests at heart. Triem said the relationship was seemingly happy between Chim and Curtis for a while until Curtis abruptly changed her tune.

“Her motive is vindictive,” Triem said. “She decided she’s going to get back at this wrongdoer after years and years of peace and harmony. She’s switched her positions, which is what happened here.”

Curtis argued over the phone at Thursday’s hearing that this is not the case. She said that as she’s gotten older and has learned more, she’s realized that Chim was controlling her at that young age.

“He didn’t rely on brute force in the commission of the crimes or the use of weapons,” Curtis said, “but used drugs and deception and preyed on my youthfulness instead.”

The issue of intent

Anna Jay, an attorney for the state, spoke in front of the Supreme Court on Thursday and gave a brief overview of the Legislature’s recent action.

A law passed by the Legislature in 2018 — Senate Bill 162 — actually didn’t change the law at all, Jay said. It merely is meant to clarify that the original law (Alaska Statute 25.23.180) allows for a parent to petition for the termination of parental rights if the child was conceived as the result of a sexual assault in cases beyond adoption, despite the law only appearing in state statute that deals with adoption. Specifically, it says the parent who committed the sexual assault can be blocked from attempting to later adopt the child.

Jay explained that in 1987, the statute was originally placed in the section of Alaska law that dealt with adoption because there was already an area of the adoption section dealing with the termination of parental rights. Jay said in court Thursday that SB 162 sought “to remove any doubts about the statute’s application to cases like this one.”

The bill, sponsored by former Sen. Berta Gardner, D-Anchorage, clarifies that this law applies to cases beyond just adoption, Jay explained. Jay said SB 162 states that the 1987 Legislature intended this law to apply more broadly, but only listed in the adoption section because it was more efficient to do so.

The judges asked Jay if a Legislature can determine the intent of a previous Legislature. Jay said that depends on the interpretation of a court, but that there’s case law that backs up that a Legislature can clarify a law passed previously. SB 162 doesn’t make any substantive changes, Jay said, and is only a clarification.

Chief Justice Joel H. Bolger closed Thursday’s hearing saying he thought the arguments were illuminating, especially the background from Jay.

“This case involves important questions of public policy and we appreciate the assistance,” Bolger said. “We will take the matter under advisement and issue a written decision at a later time.”


• Contact reporter Alex McCarthy at 523-2271 or amccarthy@juneauempire.com. Follow him on Twitter at @akmccarthy.


More in News

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Aurora forecast through the week of Dec. 22

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

The U.S. Capitol in Washington, Dec. 18, 2024. The Senate passed bipartisan legislation early Saturday that would give full Social Security benefits to a group of public sector retirees who currently receive them at a reduced level, sending the bill to President JOE Biden. (Kenny Holston/The New York Times)
Congress OKs full Social Security benefits for public sector retirees, including 15,000 in Alaska

Biden expected to sign bill that eliminates government pension offset from benefits.

Pauline Plumb and Penny Saddler carry vegetables grown by fellow gardeners during the 29th Annual Juneau Community Garden Harvest Fair on Saturday, Aug. 19, 2023. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Dunleavy says he plans to reestablish state Department of Agriculture via executive order

Demoted to division status after statehood, governor says revival will improve food production policies.

Alan Steffert, a project engineer for the City and Borough of Juneau, explains alternatives considered when assessing infrastructure improvements including utilities upgrades during a meeting to discuss a proposed fee increase Thursday night at Thunder Mountain Middle School. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Hike of more than 60% in water rates, 80% in sewer over next five years proposed by CBJ utilities

Increase needed due to rates not keeping up with inflation, officials say; Assembly will need to OK plan.

Gov. Mike Dunleavy and President-elect Donald Trump (left) will be working as chief executives at opposite ends of the U.S. next year, a face constructed of rocks on Sandy Beach is seen among snow in November (center), and KINY’s prize patrol van (right) flashes its colors outside the station this summer. (Photos, from left to right, from Gov. Mike Dunleavy’s office, Elliot Welch via Juneau Parks and Recreation, and Mark Sabbatini via the Juneau Empire)
Juneau’s 10 strangest news stories of 2024

Governor’s captivating journey to nowhere, woman who won’t leave the beach among those making waves.

Police calls for Wednesday, Dec. 18, 2024

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

The U.S. Capitol on Wednesday. Funding for the federal government will lapse at 8:01 p.m. Alaska time on Friday if no deal is reached. (Kenny Holston/The New York Times)
A federal government shutdown may begin tonight. Here’s what may happen.

TSA will still screen holiday travelers, military will work without paychecks; food stamps may lapse.

The cover image from Gov. Mike Dunleavy’s “Alaska Priorities For Federal Transition” report. (Office of the Governor)
Loch Ness ducks or ‘vampire grebes’? Alaska governor report for Trump comes with AI hallucinations

A ChatGPT-generated image of Alaska included some strange-looking waterfowl.

Bartlett Regional Hospital, along with Juneau’s police and fire departments, are partnering in a new behavioral health crisis response program announced Thursday. (Bartlett Regional Hospital photo)
New local behavioral health crisis program using hospital, fire and police officials debuts

Mobile crisis team of responders forms five months after hospital ends crisis stabilization program.

Most Read