Gavel (Courtesy photo)

Gavel (Courtesy photo)

Judge declines to block virus aid to businesses

“The current situation is too grave,” he said.

By BECKY BOHRER

Associated Press

A state court judge Friday denied a Juneau man’s request to block distribution of federal coronavirus relief aid under expanded rules proposed by Gov. Mike Dunleavy’s administration.

Superior Court Judge Philip Pallenberg ruled Eric Forrer had not shown a “clear probability of success” on the merits in his underlying case. Even if Forrer had, Pallenberg in his order wrote he would not have blocked disbursement of funds amid the virus’ economic fallout.

“The current situation is too grave, and the needs of Alaskans too great in the present emergency, for this court to stand in the way of the distribution of these federal funds to those who need them,” he said.

The order came a day after Pallenberg heard arguments on the injunction request.

The Department of Law, in a statement, said it was pleased the ruling allows the state “to move forward with helping to meet the needs of small businesses which are the cornerstone of the State’s economy.”

Joe Geldhof, an attorney for Forrer, said Pallenberg “jumped the gun” in weighing in on the merits when the case had not been fully briefed.

“We’ll just deal with it at the Supreme Court level,” he said.

The state designated $290 million of the more than $1 billion it received in federal coronavirus relief aid toward a small business program. The program was proposed by the Dunleavy administration and ratified by lawmakers and included language saying businesses that secured federal funds directly available to them under a federal relief law would not qualify. The state later sought to expand eligibility as a way to provide additional aid to businesses and allow businesses that received $5,000 or less in certain federal relief funds to become eligible for the state’s program, provided they meet other requirements.

Forrer, who argued the ratification process itself was problematic as part of his underlying case, sought to have blocked spending that did not adhere to the “express terms” lawmakers ratified.

Attorneys for the state said Forrer relied on a “literal application of language” in a program description that they said runs counter to the program’s purposes and ignores the legislative history and context of the pandemic.

Pallenberg said in the “rapidly evolving circumstances of a public health emergency,” the plan approved by lawmakers clearly was meant to be a “broad-brush description of the program, leaving the details to be fleshed out later.”

He said Forrer had not pointed to a legislative purpose that would be served by excluding businesses that received small, prior amounts of aid.

Geldhof, in court records, argued the ratification measure was at odds with constitutional provisions relating to appropriations. But Pallenberg said he could find no reason why the measure should not be deemed valid.

More in News

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Aurora forecast through the week of Nov. 17

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police calls for Wednesday, Nov. 20, 2024

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

The U.S. Capitol Christmas Tree reaches Washington, D.C., on Wednesday, Nov. 20, to much celebration. (U.S. Capitol Christmas Tree photo)
Santa’s truck-driving helpers are east bound and down to Washington, DC

U.S. Capitol Christmas Tree completes multiweek cross-country journey from Wrangell.

The Palmer project would sit in the watershed of the Chilkat River, pictured here. (Scott McMurren/Flickr under Creative Commons license 2.0)
Japanese smelting giant pulls out of major Southeast Alaska mining project

Palmer development, above the salmon-bearing Chilkat River, has for years fueled political divisions.

Juneau Police Department cars are parked outside the downtown branch station on Thursday. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
JPD’s daily incident reports getting thinner and vaguer. Why and does it matter?

Average of 5.12 daily incidents in October down from 10.74 a decade ago; details also far fewer.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police calls for Monday, Nov. 18, 2024

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

The Douglas Island Breeze In on Wednesday. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
New owner seeks to transfer Douglas Island Breeze In’s retail alcohol license to Foodland IGA

Transfer would allow company to take over space next to supermarket occupied by Kenny’s Liquor Market.

A butter clam. Butter clams are found from the Aleutian Islands to the California coast. They are known to retain algal toxins longer than other species of shellfish. (Photo provided by the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife)
Among butter clams, which pose toxin dangers to Alaska harvesters, size matters, study indicates

Higher concentrations found in bigger specimens, UAS researchers find of clams on beaches near Juneau.

Most Read