Gavel (Courtesy photo)

Judge hears arguments in budget effective date suit

Superior Court Judge Herman Walker Jr. heard arguments in Anchorage

This story has been updated to include new information

By Becky Bohrer

Associated Press

A state court judge said he planned to issue a ruling next week in a lawsuit filed by Alaska’s attorney general that raised questions about when the state budget takes effect.

Superior Court Judge Herman Walker Jr. announced his plans after hearing arguments Friday in Anchorage.

Attorney General Treg Taylor sued the Legislative Affairs Agency in late June, after the House failed to adopt effective date provisions for a state spending package. Gov. Mike Dunleavy said the budget was “constitutionally impaired if the goal was for it to take effect on July 1.”

A week after the lawsuit was filed, and three days before the new fiscal year started on July 1, the House passed the effective date provisions. Attorneys for the Legislative Affairs Agency, in court filings, say that action itself rendered the lawsuit moot.

But attorneys James Torgerson, Kevin Cuddy and Connor Smith also say the lawsuit “in substance” is “brought in the name of the state against the Legislature,” an action they say is barred by the state constitution.

Even if the judge found the lawsuit was not an action against the Legislature, the attorneys have argued the case still should be tossed because the Legislature makes appropriations decisions and the Legislative Council makes decisions about legislative business — not the Legislative Affairs Agency.

Attorneys for the state, Margaret Paton Walsh, William Milks and Jessie Alloway, in court filings, said the issues raised by Taylor’s lawsuit could come up again and that Walker should not dismiss the matter as moot.

“Indeed, all the elements that led to this litigation appear likely to persist in the near future, with the potential that this exact situation could repeat as soon as next year,” they wrote. “After all, there is not yet any solution to the State’s fiscal problems, and next year’s budget will be the product of negotiations between the same governor and legislature as this year.”

Taylor has argued that under the state constitution, laws don’t become effective until 90 days after enactment unless the Legislature with two-thirds support in each chamber provides for other effective dates. The Department of Law attorneys, in court filings, have said retroactive provisions in the budget did not provide a workaround.

During arguments Friday, the judge, Walker, asked about a letter Dunleavy sent to Joel Bolger, then chief justice of the Alaska Supreme Court, shortly before the lawsuit was filed.

In the letter, Dunleavy said given the “consequences flowing from the lack of an effective date” he had asked Taylor “to seek a determination of the issue” through the courts.

Walker, speaking of Taylor, asked Paton Walsh: “In essence, isn’t he following what his boss is telling him to do?”

In Alaska, attorneys general are appointed by the governor and confirmed by lawmakers. Paton Walsh said the attorney general has independent authority to bring actions in the public interest.

“The fact that the governor wanted him to do it doesn’t change the fact that he has that independent authority,” she said.

Attorneys for the state have highlighted an email from Jessica Geary, executive director of the Legislative Affairs Agency, dated June 18, in which she said it would “likely be the Legislature’s position that a functional budget was passed which allows authorized legislative personnel to continue employment on July 1.”

She cited past practice and the interpretation of legislative attorneys surrounding the retroactive provisions. She also noted the potential for things to change, and said a contingency plan would need to be implemented if disagreements were not worked out by July 1.

Agency attorneys, in court filings, said the email was reporting on a “‘likely’ position that might be taken by the Legislature — not the LAA — based on a hypothetical state of facts.

They also noted a June 23 email from Geary to legislative leaders seeking direction around planning for a possible government shutdown. A later vote by the Legislative Council authorized temporary use of existing funds for legislative operations until money in the budget bill became available, according to a court filing by agency attorneys.

Torgerson, in arguments Friday, referred to Geary as the “messenger.”

“This is just like if somebody in the clerk of court sent out an opinion from the Supreme Court that somebody didn’t like. They can’t sue the Supreme Court so they’re now saying, Oh, we’ll sue the clerk’s office,” he said.

Paton Walsh disputed that comparison.

She said in this case, there was an agency that “was proposing to spend money in violation of the law.”

More in News

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Aurora forecast through the week of Nov. 17

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

A butter clam. Butter clams are found from the Aleutian Islands to the California coast. They are known to retain algal toxins longer than other species of shellfish. (Photo provided by the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife)
Among butter clams, which pose toxin dangers to Alaska harvesters, size matters, study indicates

Higher concentrations found in bigger specimens, UAS researchers find of clams on beaches near Juneau.

An aerial view of people standing near destroyed and damaged buildings in the aftermath of Hurricane Helene flooding on Oct. 8, 2024 in Bat Cave, North Carolina. (Mario Tama/Getty Images)
Members of U.S. Senate back disaster aid request amid increasing storm severity

WASHINGTON — The Biden administration’s request for nearly $100 billion in natural… Continue reading

Media members and other observers gather at the Alaska Division of Elections office on Wednesday evening as the results of all ballots, including ranked choice tabulations, were announced. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Ranked choice voting repeal fails by 0.2%, Begich defeats Peltola 51.3%-48.7% on final day of counting

Tally released Wednesday night remains unofficial until Nov. 30 certification.

Looking through the dining room and reception area to the front door. The table will be covered with holiday treats during the afternoon open house. The Stickley slide table, when several extensions are added, provides comfortable seating for 22 dinner guests. (Laurie Craig / Juneau Empire)
The Governor’s House: Welcoming Alaskans for more than 100 years

Mansion has seen many updates to please occupants, but piano bought with first funds still playable.

The language of Ballot Measure 2 appears on Alaska’s 2024 absentee ballots. The measure would repeal the states open primary and ranked choice voting system. (Andrew Kitchenman/Alaska Beacon)
Count tightens to 45-vote margin for repealing Alaska’s ranked choice system going into final day

State Division of Elections scheduled to conduct final tally at 5 p.m. Wednesday.

The drive-through of the Mendenhall Valley branch of True North Federal Credit Union, seen on June 13, is where a man was laying down when he was fatally struck by a truck during the early morning hours of June 1. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police: Driver of CBJ truck not at fault in death of man struck in drive-through lane of bank

Victim laying on pavement during early-morning incident in June couldn’t be seen in time, JPD chief says.

Juneau Assembly members confer with city administrative leaders about details of a proposed resolution asking the state for more alcohol licenses during an Assembly meeting Monday night. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Petition seeking one-third expansion of alcohol-serving establishments gets Assembly OK

Request to state would allow 31 licensees in Juneau instead of 23; Assembly rejects increase to 43.

Noah Teshner (right) exhibits the physical impact military-grade flood barriers will have on properties with the help of other residents at a Juneau Assembly meeting on Monday night. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Locals protesting $8K payment for temporary flood barriers told rejection may endanger permanent fix

Feds providing barriers free, but more help in danger if locals won’t pay to install them, city manager says.

Most Read