Rep. Craig Johnson, R-Anchorage, chair of the House Rules Committee, meets with other committee members to consider HB 247 at the Bill Ray Center on Tuesday. The bill contains cuts to oil and gas subsidies to industry. Seen with Rep. Johnson are: Speaker of the House Mike Chenault, R-Nikiski, right, Rep. Bob Herron, D-Bethel, center, and House Minority Leader Chris Tuck, D-Anchorage.

Rep. Craig Johnson, R-Anchorage, chair of the House Rules Committee, meets with other committee members to consider HB 247 at the Bill Ray Center on Tuesday. The bill contains cuts to oil and gas subsidies to industry. Seen with Rep. Johnson are: Speaker of the House Mike Chenault, R-Nikiski, right, Rep. Bob Herron, D-Bethel, center, and House Minority Leader Chris Tuck, D-Anchorage.

New version of oil tax bill gets hearing but little applause

The Alaska Legislature is considering a new plan to cut the state’s subsidy of oil and gas drilling, but opponents of previous versions say the proposal still fails to do enough.

On Tuesday morning, the House Rules Committee held a preliminary hearing on House Bill 247, a measure originally proposed by Gov. Bill Walker but rewritten by every committee it has visited.

According to analysis by the Alaska Department of Revenue, Walker’s proposal would have saved the state between $230 million and $305 million in fiscal year 2017, which starts July 1. Those savings would have risen to as much as $515 million in fiscal year 2019 before decreasing in following years.

The proposal unveiled Tuesday, again according to estimates provided by the Alaska Department of Revenue, would save the state nothing in fiscal year 2017 and might even cost the state more money. Savings would increase over time, reaching as much as $390 million in fiscal year 2022 before decreasing.

Ken Alper, director of the state’s tax division, said the analysis of the new version of the bill is based on a previous, slightly different version of the proposal. The Department of Revenue is expected to reveal a more complete analysis in a hearing Wednesday morning.

“It’s an accumulation of many different ideas,” Rules Committee Chairman Craig Johnson, R-Anchorage, said of the new version after Tuesday’s hearing.

The new version of the bill retains less of a subsidy than pro-oil legislators want. It starts its cuts later than cost-cutting legislators want.

“We’ve got something nobody loves,” Johnson said, adding that might be a sign that the committee is on the right track.

Johnson said even he isn’t sure if he’d support the bill when it comes to a floor vote.

While disagreement might be the sign of a good compromise, the bill could fail if it lacks support. That could jeopardize any hope of a solution to the state’s $4 billion annual deficit. Walker had envisioned reductions to the drilling gas subsidy as the second-biggest piece of his plan to balance the budget.

House Minority Leader Chris Tuck, D-Anchorage, said cutting the state’s subsidy for oil and gas drillers remains a first step toward a larger budget deal. Without cuts to the subsidy, Alaskans might face tax increases but see new revenue go to the oil industry, not government operations.

“It’s unfair to ask Alaskans to reach into their pocket to pay the oil industry,” Tuck said. “We have to fix this first.”

Only 21 votes are needed to pass legislation in the House, but the support of Tuck and other members of the Democratic-led minority is needed for the Legislature to spend from the state’s $8.2 billion Constitutional Budget Reserve.

Using the reserve is thought necessary to pay for next year’s budget, but using the reserve requires a three-quarters vote in the House and a three-quarters vote in the Senate.

On the flip side, too much compromise on behalf of the minority could result in the bill losing support from members of the House Majority who live in districts where the oil industry is the biggest employer.

After Tuesday’s hearing, Johnson said the groups interested in the bill are the governor, the majority, the minority, the minority within the minority, and the minority within the majority.

The Legislature must find a balance among all those groups to get the votes it needs to pass HB 247. Passage of the bill would permit lawmakers to judge whether they can support the spending of a portion of the Alaska Permanent Fund or additional taxes.

Rep. Paul Seaton, R-Homer, could be called one of the leaders of the minority within the majority. He serves in the House majority but has encouraged further cuts.

He said a good version of House Bill 247 would accomplish three things: protect companies newly arrived in Alaska, lower the liability for the state, and have an immediate budget impact.

“I don’t think that this proposal accomplishes any one of those,” he said.

The House Rules Committee is expected to meet again several times Wednesday to gather additional information, hear public testimony, and hear from the industry. Members of the committee face a 2 p.m. deadline to offer amendments to the bill.

Those amendments could be considered as early as Thursday, and a floor vote on the bill could come as early as this weekend, but the only firm deadline is May 18. That’s the Legislature’s 121st day and the constitutional limit of the regular session. Lawmakers can extend the session for 10 more days with a two-thirds vote of the House and Senate separately, but after that, there will be no more time without a special session.

• Contact reporter James Brooks at james.k.brooks@juneauempire.com.

Related stories:

On oil and gas subsidies, House commits turnover

Debate on oil tax credits slows progress

Committee approves bigger subsidy for oil and gas drillers

More in News

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Aurora forecast through the week of Dec. 22

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

Maria Laura Guollo Martins, 22, an Eaglecrest Ski Area employee from Urussanga, Brazil, working via a J-1 student visa, helps Juneau kids make holiday decorations during the resort’s annual Christmas Eve Torchlight Parade gathering on Tuesday. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Foreign students working at Eaglecrest trade Christmas Eve traditions for neon lights and lasagna

26 employees from Central and South America are far from family, yet among many at Torchlight Parade.

An aerial view of L’áan Yík (Channel inside or Port Camden) with cars and people gathered on the bridge over Yéil Héeni (Raven’s Creek) during a May 2024 convening on Kuiu Island. Partners that comprise the Ḵéex̱’ Ḵwáan Community Forest Partnership and staff from the Tongass National Forest met to discuss priorities for land use, stream restoration, and existing infrastructure on the north Kuiu road system. (Photo by Lee House)
Woven Peoples and Place: U.S. Forest Service’s Tongass collaboration a ‘promise to the future’

Multitude of partners reflect on year of land management and rural economic development efforts.

The city of Hoonah is seeking to incorporate as a borough with a large tract of surrounding area that includes most of Glacier Bay National Park and a few tiny communities. (Alaska Department of Commerce, Community, and Economic Development photo)
New Xunaa Borough gets OK in published decision, but opponents not yet done with challenges

State boundary commission reaffirms 3-2 vote; excluded communities likely to ask for reconsideration.

Bartlett Regional Hospital leaders listen to comments from residents during a forum June 13 about proposed cuts to some services, after officials said the reductions were necessary to keep the hospital from going bankrupt within a few years. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Bartlett rebounds from years of losses with profits past six months; staffing down 12% during past year

Hospital’s balance sheet shows dramatic bottom-line turnaround starting in May as services cut.

A street in a Mendenhall Valley neighborhood is closed following record flooding on Aug. 6 that damaged nearly 300 homes. (City and Borough of Juneau photo)
Flood district protection plan faces high barrier if enough property owners protest $6,300 payments

Eight of nine Assembly members need to OK plan if enough objections filed; at least two already have doubts.

Sunset hues color the sky and the snow at the University of Alaska Fairbanks campus on Feb. 26, 2024. The University of Alaska system and the union representing nearly 1,100 faculty members and postdoctoral fellows are headed into federal mediation in January. (Yereth Rosen/Alaska Beacon)
University of Alaska-faculty contract negotiations head for federal mediation

Parties say they’re hopeful; outcome will depend on funding being included in the next state budget.

The newly named Ka-PLOW is seen with other Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities equipment in Juneau in a video announcing the names of three local snowplows in a contest featuring more than 400 entries. (Screenshot from Alaska Department of Transportation and Public Facilities video)
Newly named DOT snowplows probably won’t visit Juneau neighborhoods until after Christmas

Berminator, Salt-O-Saurus Rex, Ka-PLOW selected as winners in contest with more than 400 entries.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police calls for Friday, Dec. 20, 2024

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

Most Read