Lora Vess

Lora Vess

Remembering the effects of plastics

We are entering finals week at the University of Alaska Southeast. As students and faculty wrap up our courses, many of us are thinking about the upcoming holidays.

Gift giving is an important ritualized act of kindness and reciprocity. As the season of gifts is upon us, we hope you’ll pause to consider the ecological footprint of the gifts you give, striving to make responsible decisions regarding your purchases. How sustainable is the material? How far did it travel? Is the gift one of planned obsolescence (“designed for the dump”) or of perceived obsolescence, where we quickly discard older, but working versions of products because we buy into the idea that a newer style is more desirable?

If we think about our purchases, almost all of them will be connected in some way to plastic, whether it’s in the product itself, the packaging or the credit card we swipe to pay for it. Plastic is ubiquitous in modern society. A 2017 report revealed that in the previous 13 years, global plastic production was equivalent to the amount of plastic made in the previous half-century.

Almost all plastics are produced from chemicals derived from non-renewable resources. While that may be good news for Alaska’s oil-based economy, if current trends continue the plastic industry could account for 20 percent of the world’s total oil consumption by 2050. Given how much plastic is designed for single-use (planned obsolescence), and with packaging accounting for 26 percent of the total volume of plastics used, that does not seem like the best or most efficient use of a valuable resource.

Reducing plastic’s prevalence at UAS is one of the Sustainability Committee’s goals for this year. At this year’s annual Power and Privilege Symposium in November, members of the Committee and the student Sustainability Club presented “Plastic, plastic everywhere: How throwaway consumerism harms societies and ecosystems, and what we can do about it.” In our discussion, attendees proposed some great ideas for addressing the problems of plastic from the micro-level (including reducing disposable, single-use packaging) to the global scale, such as an international treaty on plastic to protect our seas.

Unfortunately, the news is not good. The treaties that exist are non-binding and only about 9 percent of plastics are recycled. In Juneau we are limited to recycling plastics coded 1 and 2 and plastic grocery bags. Even if recycling rates were higher, it is not enough. The culture of recycling convinces us that we are doing our part and grants us psychological permission to continue on the current path, ultimately individualizing a problem whose roots lie in production practices, lack of corporate accountability, and limited effective legislation that incentivizes reduction or recycling of plastics. In fact, 10 states have preemption laws preventing municipalities from regulating plastic at the local level, with other states considering prohibitive legislation.

Environmental concerns rightly take a center stage when considering the human impact on the planet. However, social sustainability is an often overlooked but critical dimension of sustainability. Social sustainability attends to issues of equity, justice and human rights. In practical terms, this may be evaluated with regards to toxic exposures and impacts on human health or safe workplaces with fair labor practices.

For instance, we know that chemicals used in plastics may be endocrine disruptors or carcinogenic. Plastics workers have higher body burdens (chemicals in their bodies) than non-exposed groups in the general population. Social sustainability proponents ask questions like: What are the conditions and wages like for the workers who produce our goods? What is the human toll embodied in achieving that quick delivery of goods? Is the workforce racially diverse from floor workers to top management? Is the company a good neighbor to local communities whether they are located in Baton Rouge, Louisiana or Shenzhen, China?

As the holiday season jumps into full swing, I would like to wish Southeast Alaskans much joy and good health. But I’d also encourage shoppers to consider the environmental and social sustainability of the gifts we choose to give and what that means not only for the recipient, but also the planet and its people. If you’d like to think critically about the broader impacts of your personal choices, sign up for a sustainability-focused class at UAS for spring semester, and help us keep the critical dialogues going.


• Dr. Lora Vess is an assistant professor at the University of Alaska Southeast and lives in Juneau. Dr. Vess is a member of the University of Alaska Southeast Sustainability Committee. The views expressed here do not necessarily represent the views of the University of Alaska Southeast.


More in News

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Aurora forecast through the week of Dec. 22

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

Juneau Police Department officers close off an area around the intersection of Glacier Highway and Trout Street on Wednesday morning following an officer-involved shooting that resulted in the death of a woman believed to be experiencing homelessness. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Update: Woman wielding hammer, hatchet dies in officer-involved shooting near valley Breeze In

Woman threatened person at convenience store with hammer, officers with hatchet, according to JPD

Maria Laura Guollo Martins, 22, an Eaglecrest Ski Area employee from Urussanga, Brazil, working via a J-1 student visa, helps Juneau kids make holiday decorations during the resort’s annual Christmas Eve Torchlight Parade gathering on Tuesday. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Foreign students working at Eaglecrest trade Christmas Eve traditions for neon lights and lasagna

26 employees from Central and South America are far from family, yet among many at Torchlight Parade.

An aerial view of L’áan Yík (Channel inside or Port Camden) with cars and people gathered on the bridge over Yéil Héeni (Raven’s Creek) during a May 2024 convening on Kuiu Island. Partners that comprise the Ḵéex̱’ Ḵwáan Community Forest Partnership and staff from the Tongass National Forest met to discuss priorities for land use, stream restoration, and existing infrastructure on the north Kuiu road system. (Photo by Lee House)
Woven Peoples and Place: U.S. Forest Service’s Tongass collaboration a ‘promise to the future’

Multitude of partners reflect on year of land management and rural economic development efforts.

The city of Hoonah is seeking to incorporate as a borough with a large tract of surrounding area that includes most of Glacier Bay National Park and a few tiny communities. (Alaska Department of Commerce, Community, and Economic Development photo)
New Xunaa Borough gets OK in published decision, but opponents not yet done with challenges

State boundary commission reaffirms 3-2 vote; excluded communities likely to ask for reconsideration.

Bartlett Regional Hospital leaders listen to comments from residents during a forum June 13 about proposed cuts to some services, after officials said the reductions were necessary to keep the hospital from going bankrupt within a few years. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Bartlett rebounds from years of losses with profits past six months; staffing down 12% during past year

Hospital’s balance sheet shows dramatic bottom-line turnaround starting in May as services cut.

A street in a Mendenhall Valley neighborhood is closed following record flooding on Aug. 6 that damaged nearly 300 homes. (City and Borough of Juneau photo)
Flood district protection plan faces high barrier if enough property owners protest $6,300 payments

Eight of nine Assembly members need to OK plan if enough objections filed; at least two already have doubts.

Sunset hues color the sky and the snow at the University of Alaska Fairbanks campus on Feb. 26, 2024. The University of Alaska system and the union representing nearly 1,100 faculty members and postdoctoral fellows are headed into federal mediation in January. (Yereth Rosen/Alaska Beacon)
University of Alaska-faculty contract negotiations head for federal mediation

Parties say they’re hopeful; outcome will depend on funding being included in the next state budget.

Most Read