A sample ballot for the Oct. 1 municipal election at the City and Borough of Juneau’s website.

A sample ballot for the Oct. 1 municipal election at the City and Borough of Juneau’s website.

Strong arguments for Ship-Free Saturdays, against school board recalls on CBJ ballot

Language is part of official process; additional election perspectives will come from CBJ voter guide, website

Juneau voters will see a markedly one-sided presentation of the “Ship-Free Saturdays” measure on their ballots in the Oct. 1 municipal election — and rather imbalanced wording for the recall of two school board members — but it won’t be the only side of the ballot questions residents receive from the city.

A notice of election published Monday by the municipal clerk’s office contains strong ballot wording by supporters of the Saturday cruise ship ban — such as declaring the cruise season “adversely impacts Juneau residents’ health and quality of life” — without a response from opponents of the measure.

On the same notice (and thus ballot), rebuttals are included by the top two members of the Juneau Board of Education who are the targets of the recall vote, with each given 200 words to explain why they deserve to keep their seats.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

It’s all standard procedure for a local election, but other official material will be available to voters as well, Municipal Clerk Beth McEwen said Tuesday. Those include a voter information guide published by the city manager’s office, and candidate profiles written by the people seeking Juneau Assembly and school board seats that are expected to be published at the city’s website by the end of the week.

The language submitted by the group petitioning to get Ship-Free Saturdays was reviewed, for example, but “we are not certifying that the language in there is factual whatsoever,” she said.

“We do not weigh in on the merits or on the substance of what is in the language they submitted,” McEwen said. “We just certify whether or not it meets the legal requirements for an initiative.”

The ballot language makes 11 “whereas” declarations for the Ship-Free Saturdays question — officially referred to as Proposition 2 — such as “a majority of Juneau residents think that our local government is not doing enough to manage cruise tourism.” Another “whereas” proclaims “city leaders and industry have had decades to act and have failed to balance the economic benefits to some against the economic and other harms of the many imposed by the cruise tourism industry.”

Voters are then asked if cruise ships with a capacity of 250 or more passengers should be banned from Juneau on Saturdays and the Fourth of July.

The measure is being opposed by the group Protect Juneau’s Future, backed by a multitude of cruise industry and local businesses. In addition to a large-scale advertising and events campaign planned by the group, a roughly 450-word opposing statement for the official voter information guide was written by Red Dog Saloon owner Eric Forst.

The opposing statement provides its own list of six reasons to oppose the measure including “economic disruption and job loss,” “impact on public services,” and “collaboration, confrontation” — the latter referring to voluntary agreements the industry has reached with the city such as a five-ship-a-day limit in effect now and a daily passenger limit scheduled to take effect in 2026.

Voters will be presented with pro and con arguments for the two school board recall questions, although with a decided imbalance favoring the targets of the recall.

The ballot language states the grounds for recalling the two members — President Deedie Sorensen and Vice President Emil Mackey — are “(each) demonstrated failure to perform prescribed duties, misconduct in office, and incompetence by: …Failure to understand the FY24 budget accounting errors resulting in $7.9M deficit and taxpayer loan from CBJ, violating BP3460.”

That bureaucratic language refers to a portion of the Juneau School District’s financial crisis that was publicly revealed in January — a deficit incurred during the past fiscal year resolved through cutbacks and accounting adjustments — although proponents of the recall have cited the longer-term crisis and resulting consolidation of schools that took effect in July as their motivation.

Both Sorensen and Mackey, provided with 200 words to respond, also went beyond the strict confines of the 2024 fiscal year in the recall language to defend their actions and ask voters to reject the recalls.

“The reality behind this recall is 20+ years of declining student enrollment and prior board leadership unwilling to adjust the budget to this reality,” Sorensen wrote at the beginning of her rebuttal. Toward the end she adds “we made difficult decisions for our schools in the 2025 budget. Decisions necessary to ensure our students continue to receive a great education.”

Mackey challenged the ballot’s description of the district’s situation, asserting among other things a shortage of state funding for many years is the key cause of the crisis.

“The budgetary choice was simply buildings versus staff,” he wrote. “In FY 2024, the District employed 317 teachers. The chosen model laid off 46.5 teachers. Had we adopted the model advocated by recall sponsors, the district would have had to lay-off 84 of the 317 teachers. Nobody liked the choices, but the chosen alternative was the best decision possible for student success and kept the lowest possible Pupil/Teacher Ratio for years to come.”

Rebuttals by Sorensen and Mackey are included on the ballot because “the recall petition is an entirely different process under different statutes” than the cruise ship initiative, McEwen said.

Also being decided in the Oct. 1 election are two bond measures totaling nearly $23 million (each with statements of roughly 100 words describing their purpose), a mayor’s race with two declared candidates, a District 1 Assembly race with two declared candidates, a District 2 Assembly race with five declared candidates, and a school board race where six candidates are seeking three open seats.

Ballots for the by-mail election are scheduled to be mailed to residents on Sept. 12.

• Contact Mark Sabbatini at mark.sabbatini@juneauempire.com or (907) 957-2306.

More in News

(Juneau Empire file photo)
Aurora forecast through the week of March 23

These forecasts are courtesy of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Geophysical Institute… Continue reading

Angie Flick (center), finance director for the City and Borough of Juneau, explains to Assembly members the financial impacts of various adjustments to the mill rate during a Finance Committee meeting on Wednesday, May 22, 2024. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire file photo)
Proposed CBJ budget eyes increase to 10.19 mills due to school building takeover, other costs

Unknowns as Assembly begins two-month process are contract negotiations, federal funding.

President Donald Trump signs the Save Our Seas Act in the Oval Office in the White House in Washington, Oct. 11, 2018. The bill’s sponsor, Sen. Dan Sullivan (R-Alaska), is second from the left. Both Republican politicians got relatively high favorable ratings in a poll of Alaskans published this month. (Gabriella Demczuk/The New York Times)
Statewide poll: Trump, Murkowski provoke strongest feelings; Sullivan most popular among delegation

Alaskans also split on continuing aid to Ukraine, agree Russia started war, oppose Canada/Mexico tariffs.

Lesley Thompson asks a question during a town hall with the three members of Juneau’s state legislative delegation Thursday night at the Mendenhall Valley Public Library. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Local legislators emphasize wise navigation on bumpy state and federal policy highways during town hall

Federal shakeups affecting medical care, fiscal stability, schools and other legislative issues loom large.

The Juneau School District administrative office inside Thunder Mountain Middle School on Tuesday, Jan. 14, 2025. (Mark Sabbatini / Juneau Empire)
Update: Students and staff affected by PowerSchool data breach offered two years of identity protection services

The complimentary identity protection services apply to all impacted students and educators.

(Michael Penn / Juneau Empire file photo)
Police calls for Wednesday, March 26, 2025

This report contains public information from law enforcement and public safety agencies.

(Illustration by Stephanie Harold)
Woven Peoples and Place: Seals, science and sustenance

Xunaa (Hoonah) necropsy involves hunters and students

Natural gas processing equipment is seen at Furie Operating Alaska’s central processing facility in Nikiski, Alaska, on Wednesday, July 10, 2024. (Jake Dye/Peninsula Clarion)
Glenfarne takes majority stake of Alaska LNG Project, will lead development

The Alaska Gasline Development Corporation announced Thursday they had reached an agreement with the New York-based company.

Tom Dawson touches a 57-millimeter Bofors gun during a tour of the U.S. Coast Guard Cutter Munro on Tuesday, March 25, 2025. (Jasz Garrett / Juneau Empire)
US Coast Guard Cutter Munro stops in Juneau as it begins its patrol

Crew conducts community outreach and details its mission in Alaska.

Most Read